文献速递关节外科

外科医疗任务评估的概念模型

A Conceptual Model for the Evaluation of Surgical Missions.
PubMed 文献 · J Bone Joint Surg Am · 2018-01-01

本文描述Operation Walk波士顿的研究项目,并提出一个借鉴Donabedian框架的外科医疗任务评估模型,涵盖文化信念等情境因素、系统管理(结构、过程与结局)及可持续性。该模型用于呈现该项目的定量与定性研究结果,作者建议外科医疗任务采用定量与定性策略记录其影响。

要点

  • 提出涵盖情境因素、系统管理与可持续性的外科医疗任务评估模型。
  • 多米尼加患者术前WOMAC功能评分33.6、疼痛较美国全髋或全膝置换患者(WOMAC功能评分43.3至54)更差,但获得50分改善的优良结局。
  • Op-Walk波士顿提供的医疗质量符合Blue Cross Blue Shield卓越中心(Blue Distinction)标准,可持续改变已转移至宿主医院。

核心结论

  • 所提出的模型为正式评估医疗任务提供了方法,回应了对其实证价值的需求。
  • 作者建议外科医疗任务采用定量与定性策略记录其影响、识别改进领域并论证项目延续、扩展与支持。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文描述Operation Walk(Op-Walk)波士顿的研究项目,并提出一个借鉴Donabedian工作、由其研究项目证据丰富的评估模型。
  • 该模型要求评估显著情境因素(文化与信念)、系统管理(结构、过程与结局)以及项目干预的可持续性。
  • 使用上述领域呈现Op-Walk波士顿定量与定性研究工作的发现。

主要发现

  • Op-Walk定性研究显示文化因素是患者对关节炎病因、体力活动模式和治疗偏好认知的重要决定因素。
  • 定量评估记录多米尼加患者术前下肢功能状态(WOMAC功能评分均值33.6)和疼痛较美国全髋或全膝置换患者(WOMAC功能评分43.3至54)更差,但获得50分改善的优良结局,与美国患者相当。
  • Op-Walk项目质量与可持续性评估显示,Op-Walk波士顿提供的医疗质量符合Blue Cross Blue Shield卓越中心(Blue Distinction)标准,可持续改变已转移至宿主医院。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议外科医疗任务采用定量与定性策略记录其影响、识别改进领域并论证项目延续、扩展与支持。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Medical missions to low and middle-income countries are increasingly frequent, with an estimated 6,000 trips sponsored by U.S. organizations accounting for approximately 200,000 surgical cases and $250 million in costs annually. However, these missions have received little critical evaluation. This paper describes the research program Operation Walk (Op-Walk) Boston, and proposes an evaluation model for similar surgical missions. METHODS: We propose an evaluation model, borrowing from the work of Donabedian and enriched by evidence from our research program. The model calls for evaluation of the salient contextual factors (culture and beliefs), system management (structure, process, and outcomes), and sustainability of the program's interventions. We used these domains to present findings from the quantitative and qualitative research work of Op-Walk Boston. RESULTS: Op-Walk's qualitative research findings demonstrated that cultural factors are important determinants of patients' perceptions of arthritis etiology, physical activity patterns, and treatment preferences. Quantitative assessments documented that Dominican patients had worse lower-extremity functional status (mean Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index [WOMAC] function score of 33.6) and pain preoperatively than patients undergoing total hip or knee replacement in the U.S. (WOMAC function score of 43.3 to 54), yet they achieved excellent outcomes (50-point improvement), comparable to those of their U.S. counterparts. Assessments of the quality and sustainability of the Op-Walk program showed that the quality of care provided by Op-Walk Boston meets Blue Cross Blue Shield Centers of Excellence (Blue Distinction) criteria, and that sustainable changes were transferred to the host hospital. CONCLUSIONS: Our proposed model offers a method for formal assessment of medical missions that addresses the call for evidence of their merit. We suggest that surgical missions adopt quantitative and qualitative strategies to document their impact, identify areas of improvement, and justify program continuation, growth, and support.

来源:J Bone Joint Surg Am,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bido J, Ghazinouri R, Collins JE, et al. A Conceptual Model for the Evaluation of Surgical Missions. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2018. PMID: 29557871. doi:10.2106/JBJS.17.00689

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。