文献速递运动医学关节外科

精英职业投掷运动员的许多肩部MRI表现会在退役后消退:一项临床与影像学研究

Many Shoulder MRI Findings in Elite Professional Throwing Athletes Resolve After Retirement: A Clinical and Radiographic Study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2018-01-01

该研究对瑞士国家男子手球队30名无肩部手术史的职业运动员进行随访,其中20人在退役后平均6年接受临床与双肩MRI评估,另18名退役平均15年的前职业运动员作为长期对照。结果显示投掷肩MRI异常比例高但部分表现如大于5mm的腱鞘囊肿在退役后消退,肩袖部分撕裂未进展为全层撕裂,Constant-Murley评分轻度升高但低于最小临床重要差异。

要点

  • 职业手球运动员投掷肩MRI可诊断表现比例高(初始20人中19人,95%),非投掷肩为17/20(85%)。
  • 退役后无一例肩袖撕裂进展为全层撕裂,投掷肩大于5mm的腱鞘囊肿从初始6/20(30%)降至退役6年后0/20(0%)。
  • Constant-Murley评分投掷肩从初始93分(SD 6)升至退役6年98分(SD 3),平均差5分(SD 5;95%CI 2.5-7.4;p<0.001),但低于最小临床重要差异。

核心结论

  • 作者认为投掷肩的部分肩袖撕裂、骨囊肿和腱鞘囊肿等表现退役后不进展,有时会消退。
  • 由于许多MRI改变与临床症状相关性差,作者提出应非常谨慎地评估针对这些表现的手术指征。

研究设计与样本

  • 预后研究,证据等级II级。
  • 初始队列为2001年瑞士全国手球联赛中除守门员外的全部30名瑞士国家手球队职业运动员,均无肩部手术史。
  • 30人中排除10人(4人继续职业比赛、4人拒绝参与、2人在初始研究后接受手术),最终20人(66%)在退役后平均6年(SD 3年)接受分析。
  • 另纳入18名无肩部手术史、曾效力瑞士最高联赛和国家队、退役平均15年(SD 3年)的前职业欧洲手球运动员。
  • 所有受试者接受详细问诊、标准化临床检查(含活动度测量)、双肩Constant-Murley评分和主观肩关节评分及双肩MRI。

主要发现

  • 初始MRI评估时,投掷肩有可诊断MRI表现的比例为20人中19人(95%),非投掷肩为20人中17人(85%)。
  • 退役15年后所有受试者双肩均显示MRI表现。
  • 退役后无一例肩袖撕裂进展为全层撕裂。
  • 投掷肩大于5mm的腱鞘囊肿:初始随访6/20(30%)vs 退役6年后0/20(0%)(比值比14.5;95%CI 0.7-283;p=0.044)。
  • Constant-Murley评分投掷肩从初始93分(SD 6)升至退役6年平均98分(SD 3)(平均差5分;SD 5;95%CI 2.5-7.4;p<0.001),退役15年平均97分(SD 3);但差异低于通常报告的最小临床重要差异,故不太可能具有临床相关性。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为针对投掷肩部分肩袖撕裂、骨囊肿和腱鞘囊肿等MRI表现的手术指征应非常谨慎地评估。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Anatomic findings on MRI scans of the shoulder likely affect patients differently based on their physical demands and fitness levels. The natural history of these anatomic findings once professional overhead athletes retire remains unclear. A better understanding of what happens with these findings after retirement may influence how we manage shoulder problems in athletes. PURPOSE: (1) What is the natural history of MRI-observed findings in the throwing and nonthrowing shoulders of professional European handball players after retirement from the sport? What proportion of these individuals have diagnosable findings on MRI, and do these findings disappear after retirement? (2) Do clinical findings such as Constant and Murley score and shoulder ROM change after retirement in these professional overhead athletes? METHODS: The inception cohort of this series consisted of the entire Swiss National European handball team except the goalkeepers. These 30 professional players also played in the highest Swiss handball league in 2001. None of these players previously had shoulder surgery. During their career, they had a clinical assessment and bilateral shoulder MRI as part of an earlier study. We sought to evaluate the players who had retired and did not have a history of shoulder surgery, to evaluate the natural history of MRI-observed findings made in the initial study during their professional career. Of the 30 players, 10 were excluded (four continued to play professionally, four declined participation, and two had surgery after the initial study), leaving 20 (66%) for analysis at a mean of 6 years (SD, 3 years) after retirement. To gain a better understanding of the evolution of these MRI findings in the longer-term, we also evaluated 18 additional former professional European handball players who did not have any history of shoulder surgery, had all played in the highest Swiss league and for the National Team, and had terminated their career at a mean of 15 years (SD, 3 years) ago. All the subjects in both study groups (those at 6 and 15 years after retirement) underwent a detailed interview, standardized clinical examination including ROM measurements, collection of the Constant and Murley scores and the subjective shoulder value of both shoulders, and bilateral shoulder MRI. MRI findings (consisting of abnormalities and normal variations) were reported as radiographic diagnoses, independent of the potential that these findings could be considered normal variations in people in this age group. RESULTS: At the initial MRI evaluation, the proportion of active professional European handballers with diagnosable MRI findings in the throwing shoulder was 19 of 20 (95%) and for the handballers with nonthrowing shoulders was 17 of 20 (85%), while 15 years after retirement, both shoulders of all subjects showed MRI findings. None of the rotator cuff tears progressed to full-thickness tears after retirement. In the throwing shoulders, we observed fewer individuals with ganglion cysts larger than 5 mm (initial followup: six of 20 [30%] versus 6 years after retirement: 0 of 20 (0%); odds ratio, 14.5; [95% CI, 0.7-283]; p = 0.044). The Constant and Murley score increased in the throwing shoulder from 93 points (SD, 6 points) at initial followup to 98 points (SD, 3 points) at a mean of 6 years after retirement (mean difference, 5 points; SD, 5 points; 95% CI, 2.5-7.4; p < 0.001), and to 97 points (SD, 3 points) at a mean of 15 years after retirement. However these differences are below the typically reported minimum clinically important difference for the Constant and Murley score, and so are unlikely to be clinically relevant. External rotation in 90° abduction remained increased in the throwing shoulder compared with the nonthrowing shoulder up to 15 years after retirement (initial followup: mean difference, 8°; p = 0.014; 15 years after retirement: mean difference, 4°; SD, 15; p = 0.026). Internal rotation remained decreased in the throwing compared with the nonthrowing shoulders (during the career: mean difference, 5° [SD, 10°], p = 0.036; 15 years after retirement: mean difference, 3° [SD, 4°], p = 0.021). CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that findings of the throwing shoulder like partial rotator cuff tears, bony cysts and ganglions do not progress after retirement, and sometimes they resolve. Because of this and because many MRI changes correlate poorly with clinical symptoms, the indication for surgical treatment of these findings should be questioned very carefully. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, prognostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Schär MO, Dellenbach S, Pfirrmann CW, et al. Many Shoulder MRI Findings in Elite Professional Throwing Athletes Resolve After Retirement: A Clinical and Radiographic Study. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29408833. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000042

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。