AJSM作者自报告利益冲突披露与医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心开放支付数据库之间的准确性比较
该横断面研究纳入2016年发表于《美国运动医学杂志》(AJSM)的434名符合条件作者,将其自报告的利益冲突披露与医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心开放支付数据库(OPD)的行业支付记录进行比对。结果显示,作者披露与OPD记录之间存在差异,总支付金额较低者、中间作者和女性作者出现披露差异的比例更高。
要点
- 434名作者中,每位作者每年总支付金额均值为76,941美元、中位数为1,692美元。
- 最常收到的支付类别为食品和饮料(81.3%的作者),其次为旅行和住宿(45.4%)和咨询(31.8%)。
- 总支付金额超过500,000美元的作者支付值差异比例为16.1%,低于10,000美元者为85.3%(P < .001)。
核心结论
- AJSM发表文章的作者所报告的披露与OPD报告的内容之间存在差异。
- 获得较低总支付金额的作者、中间作者和女性作者更可能出现披露差异。
- 行业研究资助支持和所有权利益最可能未被报告。
- 作者认为,随着OPD等国家登记数据库日益被使用,医生在提交利益冲突披露前参考此类数据库可能有益。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,无证据等级(非临床)。
- 筛选2016年发表于《美国运动医学杂志》(AJSM)的所有文章以识别符合条件的作者,基于OPD报告纳入隶属于美国机构的医生作者,共纳入434名作者。
- 将AJSM出版物中这些作者声明的披露与OPD上行业报告的支付进行比较。
主要发现
- 每位作者每年总支付金额均值为76,941美元,中位数为1,692美元。
- 最常收到的支付为食品和饮料(81.3%的作者),其次为旅行和住宿(45.4%)和咨询(31.8%)。
- 总支付金额超过500,000美元的作者支付值差异比例为16.1%,而低于10,000美元者为85.3%(P < .001)。
- 第一作者支付值差异比例为13.8%,中间作者为31.9%(P = .001)。
- 男性作者(418名)支付值差异比例为22.3%,女性作者(16名)为95.3%(P < .001);AJSM披露表特别要求的行业支付类别(版税、咨询、研究支付、所有权和投资)中,仅25.3%的作者在这些类别总体上存在差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 总支付金额超过500,000美元的作者支付值差异比例为16.1%,低于10,000美元者为85.3%(P < .001)。
- 第一作者支付值差异比例为13.8%,中间作者为31.9%(P = .001)。
- 男性作者(418名)支付值差异比例为22.3%,女性作者(16名)为95.3%(P < .001)。
- AJSM披露表特别要求的支付类别(版税、咨询、研究支付、所有权和投资)中,25.3%的作者在这些类别总体上存在差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,随着OPD等国家登记数据库日益被使用,医生在提交利益冲突披露前参考此类数据库可能有益。
局限性
- 本研究未评估接受行业支付的作者是否优先发表与其接受资助公司产品相关的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Inaccurate disclosures of physician and industry relationships in scientific reporting may create an asymmetry of information by hiding potential biases. The accuracy of conflict of interest disclosure in sports medicine research is unknown. PURPOSE: To compare author financial disclosures in published articles in 2016 in the American Journal of Sports Medicine ( AJSM) with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' Open Payments Database (OPD) to determine the percentage of payments values and percentage of eligible authors with discrepancies. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study; no level of evidence (nonclinical). METHODS: All articles published in 2016 in AJSM were screened to identify eligible authors. On the basis of OPD reporting, physician authors affiliated with a US institution were included. Stated disclosures in AJSM publications for these authors were identified and compared with industry-reported payments on OPD. RESULTS: A total of 434 authors were included in this study. Mean and median total payments per author per year were $76,941 and $1692, respectively. The most commonly received payment was for food and beverage (81.3% of authors), followed by travel and lodging (45.4%) and consulting (31.8%). Authors with higher total payments were less likely to be discrepant in their reporting-notably, authors earning >$500,000 had 16.1% of payment values with discrepancy, as opposed to 85.3% for those earning <$10,000 ( P < .001). First authors had a lower percentage of payment values with discrepancy (13.8%) versus middle authors (31.9%, P = .001). Finally, men had a lower percentage of payment values with discrepancy (418 authors, 22.3% of payment values with discrepancy) as compared with women (16 authors, 95.3%; P < .001). Regarding industry payments specifically requested on the AJSM disclosure form for authors (royalties, consulting, research payments, and ownership and investments), only 25.3% of authors had a discrepancy in these payment categories in aggregate. CONCLUSION: Discrepancies exist between disclosures reported by authors publishing in AJSM and what is reported in the OPD. Authors receiving lower total payments, middle authors, and women are more likely to have disclosure discrepancies. Additionally, industry research funding support and ownership interest are most likely to go unreported. However, this study did not assess whether authors with industry payments preferentially published studies pertaining to products from companies from which they received funding. As national registries such as the OPD are increasingly utilized, physicians may benefit from referencing such databases before submitting conflict of interest disclosures.
引用
- Boddapati V, Fu MC, Nwachukwu BU, et al. Accuracy Between AJSM Author-Reported Disclosures and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Open Payments Database. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29382212. doi:10.1177/0363546517750124
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。