术前胫骨软骨下骨髓病变模式与孤立性半月板同种异体移植术后结局的关联
本研究为队列研究(证据等级3),纳入2006年10月至2017年2月由单一外科医生行孤立性半月板同种异体移植术(MAT)的患者,评估三种胫骨软骨下骨髓病变(BML)分级方法的评分者间信度(IRR),并分析术前BML模式与术后临床结局及失败率的关联。结果显示,66.7%的可用MRI存在软骨下BML;Welsch法及Costa-Paz法的IRR为强/几乎完美一致;Welsch分级与KOOS疼痛(负相关,P=0.05)、WOMAC疼痛(正相关,P=0.026)及Marx活动评分(负相关,P=0.019)显著相关;Costa-Paz分级与术后满意度正相关(P=0.018);基于分级的生存率无显著差异。
要点
- 近三分之二接受孤立性MAT的患者术前MRI存在胫骨软骨下BML。
- Welsch法和Costa-Paz法的评分者间信度为强/几乎完美一致。
- Welsch分级BML增大与术后疼痛更差及活动评分更低相关。
核心结论
- 近三分之二接受孤立性MAT的患者术前MRI存在软骨下BML。
- Welsch法BML大小增加与术后疼痛指标(KOOS疼痛、WOMAC疼痛)更差及活动评分(Marx活动评分)更差相关。
- Costa-Paz法皮质表面正常轮廓破坏或凹陷增加(伴或不伴与下方关节面连续)与术后满意度更高相关。
- 基于分级的生存率无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 纳入2006年10月至2017年2月由单一外科医生行孤立性MAT的所有患者。
- 共60例MRI扫描可用于软骨下BML分级。
- 评估三种胫骨软骨下BML量化方法:Welsch等(基于病变最大直径)、Costa-Paz等(基于病变外观和位置)、Filardo等(基于发现严重程度)。
- 计算并比较三种分类的评分者间信度(IRR)。
主要发现
- 评分者1在40例(66.7%)可用MRI中识别出受累间室胫骨软骨下BML,评分者2为38例(63.3%)。
- Welsch等和Costa-Paz等分类的IRR评为强/几乎完美一致。
- 评分者1使用Welsch分级与KOOS疼痛(负相关,P=0.05)、WOMAC疼痛(正相关,P=0.026)及Marx活动评分(负相关,P=0.019)显著相关。
- 评分者2使用Costa-Paz分级与术后满意度正相关(P=0.018)。
- 基于分级的生存率无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 评分者间信度(IRR):Welsch等和Costa-Paz等分类为强/几乎完美一致。
- Welsch分级与KOOS疼痛负相关(P=0.05),与WOMAC疼痛正相关(P=0.026),与Marx活动评分负相关(P=0.019)。
- Costa-Paz分级与术后满意度正相关(P=0.018)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The association between preoperative tibial subchondral bone marrow lesion (BML) patterns and outcomes after isolated meniscus allograft transplantation (MAT) are unknown. PURPOSE: To determine (1) if a superior classification means exists (ie, high interrater reliability [IRR]) for grading tibial subchondral BML before isolated MAT and (2) whether quality and/or severity of preoperative tibial subchondral BML patterns was associated with clinical outcomes and/or failure rates after isolated MAT. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: All patients who underwent isolated MAT with a single surgeon between October 2006 and February 2017 were identified. Three means were evaluated to quantify the degree of subchondral BML in the affected tibial-sided compartment: Welsch et al, based on maximum diameter of the lesion; Costa-Paz et al, based on appearance and location of the lesion; and Filardo et al, based on severity of findings. IRR was generated and compared among the 3 classifications. The preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) subchondral BML grading scheme with the highest IRR was then used to assess for associations with postoperative outcomes for those patients with >2-year follow-up, per a Spearman correlation matrix with each reviewer's grades. RESULTS: In total, 60 MRI scans were available for subchondral BML grading. Grader 1 identified the presence of subchondral BML in the tibia of the affected compartment in 40 (66.7%) of the available MRI scans, as compared with 38 (63.3%) for grader 2. The calculated IRRs with the Welsch et al and Costa-Paz et al classifications were rated "strong/almost perfect" agreement. A significant correlation was demonstrated between grader 1 with the Welsch et al grading scheme and outcome measures of KOOS pain (Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score; negative correlation, P = .05), WOMAC pain (Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index; positive correlation, P = .026), and Marx Activity Rating Scale (negative correlation, P = .019). A significant correlation was demonstrated between grader 2 with the Costa-Paz et al grading scheme and postoperative satisfaction (positive correlation, P = .018). There were no significant differences in survivorship based on gradings. CONCLUSION: Nearly two-thirds of patients who undergo isolated MAT have subchondral BML on preoperative MRI. Our findings suggest that increasing BML size (Welsch et al) is correlated with worse postoperative pain measures (KOOS pain, WOMAC pain) and worse activity ratings (Marx Activity Rating Scale). Additionally, increasing disruption or depression of the normal contour of the cortical surface, with or without lesion contiguity with the subjacent articular surface (Costa-Paz et al), is correlated with greater postoperative satisfaction.
引用
- Saltzman BM, Cotter EJ, Stephens JP, et al. Preoperative Tibial Subchondral Bone Marrow Lesion Patterns and Associations With Outcomes After Isolated Meniscus Allograft Transplantation. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29382216. doi:10.1177/0363546517751690
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。