文献速递运动医学关节外科

高水平运动员前交叉韧带断裂手术与非手术治疗的二十年随访比较研究

Twenty-Year Follow-up Study Comparing Operative Versus Nonoperative Treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Ruptures in High-Level Athletes.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2018-02-13

该队列研究纳入50例前交叉韧带断裂的高水平运动员,根据3个月非手术治疗的反应分为非手术组(n=25,1992年)和手术组(n=25,1994-1996年行关节镜下经胫骨骨-髌腱-骨重建),配对匹配后随访20年。结果显示两组膝骨关节炎发生率无显著差异(手术组80% vs 非手术组68%,P=0.508),功能结局无差异,但手术组膝关节稳定性更优(IKDC客观评分正常或接近正常者84% vs 20%,P<0.001;轴移试验阴性68% vs 13%,P<0.001;Lachman试验阴性48% vs 4%,P=0.002)。

要点

  • 20年随访时手术组与非手术组膝骨关节炎发生率无显著差异(80% vs 68%,P=0.508)。
  • 手术组IKDC客观评分正常或接近正常者占84%,非手术组占20%(P<0.001)。
  • 手术组膝关节稳定性更优,但未转化为更好的主观和客观功能结局。

核心结论

  • 在这项回顾性配对匹配随访研究中,根据患者对3个月非手术治疗的反应分配治疗后,手术与非手术治疗在20年随访时的膝骨关节炎发生率无差异。
  • 尽管手术组膝关节稳定性更好,但并未带来更好的主观和客观功能结局。

研究设计与样本

  • 队列研究,证据等级2。
  • 50例前交叉韧带断裂患者符合参与条件,非手术组(n=25)于1992年接受结构化康复和生活方式调整,手术组(n=25)于1994至1996年间接受关节镜下经胫骨骨-髌腱-骨技术重建。
  • 非手术组选自对3个月非手术治疗反应良好者,手术组选自3个月非手术治疗后仍有持续不稳定者。
  • 两组配对匹配,并在10年和20年随访时评估放射学膝骨关节炎、功能结局(Lysholm、国际膝关节文献委员会[IKDC]、Tegner、膝关节损伤和骨关节炎结局评分)、半月板状态和膝关节稳定性(KT-1000关节动度计、轴移试验、Lachman试验、单腿跳试验)。

主要发现

  • 全部50例患者(100%)均纳入本次研究随访。
  • 20年后,手术组膝骨关节炎发生率为80%,非手术组为68%(P=0.508)。
  • 两组在功能结局和半月板切除方面无差异。
  • 手术组IKDC主观评分中位数为81.6(四分位距[IQR] 59.8-89.1),非手术组为78.2(IQR 61.5-92.0)(P=0.679)。
  • IKDC客观评分方面,手术组21例(84%)为正常或接近正常(A和B级),非手术组5例(20%)(P<0.001);轴移试验阴性分别为17例(68%)对3例(13%)(P<0.001);Lachman试验阴性分别为12例(48%)对1例(4%)(P=0.002)。

局限性

  • 原文在结论中写明本研究为回顾性配对匹配随访研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: An anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture has major consequences at midterm follow-up, with an increasing chance of developing an old knee in a young patient. The long-term (≥20 years) effects of the operative and nonoperative treatment of ACL ruptures are still unclear. PURPOSE: To compare the long-term treatment outcomes of operative versus nonoperative treatment of ACL ruptures in high-level athletes. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Fifty patients with an ACL rupture were eligible for participation, and they were treated either nonoperatively (n = 25) in 1992, consisting of structured rehabilitation and lifestyle adjustments, or operatively (n = 25) between 1994 and 1996 with an arthroscopic transtibial bone-patellar tendon-bone technique. The patients in the nonoperative group were drawn from those who responded well to 3 months of nonoperative treatment, whereas the patients in the operative group were drawn from those who had persistent instability after 3 months of nonoperative treatment. Both groups were pair-matched and assessed at 10- and 20-year follow-up regarding radiological knee osteoarthritis, functional outcomes (Lysholm, International Knee Documentation Committee [IKDC], Tegner, Knee injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score), meniscal status, and knee stability (KT-1000 arthrometer, pivot-shift test, Lachman test, 1-legged hop test). RESULTS: All 50 patients (100%) were included in the current study for follow-up. After 20 years, we found knee osteoarthritis in 80% of the operative group compared with 68% of the nonoperative group ( P = .508). There was no difference between groups regarding functional outcomes and meniscectomy performed. The median IKDC subjective score was 81.6 (interquartile range [IQR], 59.8-89.1) for the operative group and 78.2 (IQR, 61.5-92.0) for the nonoperative group ( P = .679). Regarding the IKDC objective score, 21 patients (84%) in the operative group had a normal or near normal score (A and B) compared with 5 patients (20%) in the nonoperative group ( P < .001). The pivot-shift test finding was negative in 17 patients (68%) versus 3 patients (13%) for the operative and nonoperative groups, respectively ( P < .001), and the Lachman test finding was negative in 12 patients (48%) versus 1 patient (4%), respectively ( P = .002). CONCLUSION: In this retrospective pair-matched follow-up study, we found that after 20-year follow-up, there was no difference in knee osteoarthritis between operative versus nonoperative treatment when treatment was allocated on the basis of a patient's response to 3 months of nonoperative treatment. Although knee stability was better in the operative group, it did not result in better subjective and objective functional outcomes.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. van Yperen DT, Reijman M, van Es EM, et al. Twenty-Year Follow-up Study Comparing Operative Versus Nonoperative Treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Ruptures in High-Level Athletes. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29438635. doi:10.1177/0363546517751683

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。