活动平台单髁膝关节置换术后衬垫脱位与骨关节炎进展在亚洲与西方患者间存在差异:一项Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入27项研究(其中16项随访>5年进入Meta分析),比较亚洲与西方内侧膝骨关节炎患者接受Oxford Phase III单髁膝关节置换术后因衬垫脱位和外侧间室骨关节炎进展再手术的标准化发生率。结果显示全因再手术率无显著差异,但亚洲患者因衬垫脱位再手术率更高,西方患者因外侧膝骨关节炎进展再手术率更高。
要点
- 全因再手术率亚洲与西方患者无显著差异(OR 0.7839,95%CI 0.5323-1.1545,p=0.178)。
- 因衬垫脱位再手术率亚洲高于西方(OR 3.7378,95%CI 1.694-8.248,p=0.001)。
- 因外侧膝骨关节炎进展再手术率西方高于亚洲(OR 0.3114,95%CI 0.0986-0.9840,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 全因再手术率在亚洲与西方患者间无显著差异,但亚洲患者因衬垫脱位再手术的可能性更高,西方患者因外侧膝骨关节炎进展再手术的可能性更高。
- 作者认为,尽管可对这些发现提出可能解释,但仍需额外的随机、前瞻性比较研究。
- 作者认为,更好的单髁膝关节置换术后生存结局可能需要在传统手术技术和围手术期护理之外考虑种族和生活方式选择。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索MEDLINE(1976年1月1日至2017年5月31日)、EMBASE(1985年1月1日至2017年5月31日)和Cochrane Library(1987年1月1日至2017年5月31日)。
- 纳入27项报告Oxford Phase III单髁膝关节置换术后并发症的研究进入系统综述,其中16项随访>5年的研究进入Meta分析。
- 按医院所在地将研究分为亚洲组与西方组,共评估25项研究,包含3152例亚洲患者和5455例西方患者。
- 研究质量采用改良Coleman方法学评分(MCMS)评估,所有研究均为Level IV,平均MCMS评分为66.92(SD 8.7;95%CI 63.5-70.3),提示质量中等。
- 由于所有亚组Meta分析异质性均高,采用随机效应模型并以限制性最大似然法估计。
主要发现
- 每100个观察组件年的全因再手术率:亚洲患者1.022(95%CI 0.810-1.235) vs 西方患者1.300(95%CI 1.067-1.534),OR 0.7839(95%CI 0.5323-1.1545,p=0.178),无显著差异。
- 每100个观察组件年的因衬垫脱位再手术率:亚洲患者0.525(95%CI 0.407-0.643) vs 西方患者0.141(95%CI 0.116-0.166),OR 3.7378(95%CI 1.694-8.248,p=0.001),亚洲高于西方。
- 每100个观察组件年的因外侧膝骨关节炎进展再手术率:亚洲患者0.093(95%CI 0.070-0.115) vs 西方患者0.298(95%CI 0.217-0.379),OR 0.3114(95%CI 0.0986-0.9840,p<0.001),西方高于亚洲。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准为报告Oxford Phase III单髁膝关节置换术后因衬垫脱位和/或外侧膝骨关节炎进展再手术率的研究。
- 再手术率基于各研究的平均随访时间和受累膝关节数转换为标准化发生率(每100个观察组件年的再手术数)。
- 按医院所在地将研究分为亚洲组与西方组。
- 研究质量采用改良Coleman方法学评分(MCMS)评估。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 所有纳入研究均为Level IV证据。
- 所有亚组Meta分析的异质性均高,故采用随机效应模型。
- 作者结论指出,尽管可对这些发现提出可能解释,但仍需额外的随机、前瞻性比较研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Implant survivorship is reported to be lower and complications, particularly bearing dislocation, are reported to be more frequent in Asian than in Western patients with medial knee osteoarthritis (OA) undergoing Oxford® Phase III unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). To date, however, these complications have not been compared between these groups of patients. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purpose of this study was to perform a meta-analysis comparing the standardized incidence rates of (1) all-cause reoperation; (2) reoperation related to bearing dislocation; and (3) reoperation related to progression of lateral compartment arthritis in Asian and Western patients with medial knee OA who underwent Oxford Phase III UKA. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE® (January 1, 1976, to May 31, 2017), EMBASE® (January 1, 1985, to May 31, 2017), and the Cochrane Library (January 1, 1987, to May 31, 2017) for studies that reported complications of Oxford Phase III UKAs. Studies were included if they reported reoperation rates attributable to bearing dislocation and/or progression of lateral knee OA after surgery with this implant. Twenty-seven studies were included in this systematic review and 16 studies with followups > 5 years were included in the meta-analysis. These rates were converted to standardized incidence rate (that is, reoperations per 100 observed component years) based on mean followup and number of involved knees in each study. After applying prespecified inclusion and exclusion criteria, the studies were categorized into two groups, Asian and Western, based on hospital location. Twenty-five studies, containing 3152 Asian patients and 5455 Western patients, were evaluated. Study quality was assessed by the modified Coleman Methodology score (MCMS). Although all studies were Level IV, their mean MCMS score was 66.92 (SD, 8.7; 95% confidence interval [CI], 63.5-70.3), indicating fair quality. Because the heterogeneity of all subgroup meta-analyses was high, a random-effects model was used with estimations using the restricted maximum likelihood method. RESULTS: There was no difference in the proportion of Asian patients versus Western patients undergoing reoperation for any cause calculated as 100 component observed years (1.022 of 3152 Asian patients; 95% CI, 0.810-1.235 versus 1.300 of 5455 Western patients; 95% CI, 1.067-1.534; odds ratio, 0.7839; 95% CI, 0.5323-1.1545; p = 0.178). The mean reoperation rate attributable to bearing dislocation per 100 observed years was higher in Asian than in Western patients (0.525; 95% CI, 0.407-0.643 versus 0.141; 95% CI, 0.116-0.166; odds ratio, 3.7378; 95% CI, 1.694-8.248; p = 0.001) Conversely, the mean reoperation rate attributable to lateral knee OA per 100 observed years was lower in Asian than in Western patients (0.093; 95% CI, 0.070-0.115 versus 0.298; 95% CI, 0.217-0.379; odds ratio, 0.3114; 95% CI, 0.0986-0.9840; p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Although total reoperation rates did not differ in the two populations, reoperation for bearing dislocation was more likely to occur in Asian than in Western patients, whereas reoperation for lateral knee OA progression was more likely to occur in Western than in Asian patients after Oxford Phase III UKA. Although possible explanations for these findings may be hypothesized, additional randomized, prospective comparative studies are needed. However, better survival outcomes after UKA may require consideration of ethnicity and lifestyle choices in addition to traditional surgical technique and perioperative care. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Ro KH, Heo JW, Lee DH, et al. Bearing Dislocation and Progression of Osteoarthritis After Mobile-bearing Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty Vary Between Asian and Western Patients: A Meta-analysis. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29406457. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000205
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。