文献速递关节外科创伤骨科

初次肩关节半肩置换术:从359例翻修手术病例中能学到什么?

Primary Shoulder Hemiarthroplasty: What Can Be Learned From 359 Cases That Were Surgically Revised?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2018-01-01

该研究基于1991年1月至2017年1月单中心关节置换翻修数据库,分析359例因初次半肩置换术后持续疼痛或功能不良而行翻修手术的患者特征。翻修半肩置换常见特征包括女性(81%)、肩袖或肩胛下肌失效、既往骨折相关问题、盂磨蚀和假体位置不良;骨折相关半肩置换常伴结节畸形愈合/不愈合及肱骨假体在盂表面偏心。作者认为通过使假体肱骨关节面在盂凹上居中、避免肱骨假体外翻位置以及用盂肱关节置换而非单纯半肩置换处理盂病变,或可避免部分翻修。

要点

  • 翻修半肩置换患者中女性占81%,肩袖失效占25%,肩胛下肌失效占23%。
  • 翻修半肩置换中43%与既往骨折相关,35%存在盂磨蚀,25%存在假体位置不良。
  • 骨折相关半肩置换翻修中73%伴结节畸形愈合/不愈合,63%存在肱骨假体在盂表面偏心。

核心结论

  • 作者认为,通过使假体肱骨关节面在盂凹上居中、采用合适的肱骨假体位置和软组织平衡、避免肱骨假体外翻位置,以及用盂肱关节置换而非单纯半肩置换处理盂病变,或可避免部分初次半肩置换的翻修。
  • 当肩胛下肌、肩袖和结节的持久稳定性存疑时,作者建议术者可考虑反式全肩关节置换术。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析单中心纵向维护的关节置换翻修数据库,1991年1月至2017年1月期间共983例因任何类型肩关节置换行翻修手术的患者。
  • 其中359例(37%)为初次半肩置换翻修,为本研究对象;无患者被排除。
  • 112例初次半肩置换因骨折相关诊断而实施,对此进行亚组分析;359例中273例(76%)在翻修术前3个月内有足够的平片用于评估盂、肱骨、肱骨假体及盂肱关系,对此进行亚组分析。

主要发现

  • 翻修半肩置换患者术前自评肩部舒适和功能严重丧失,简单肩关节测试(SST)评分平均为2.2 ± 2.2(满分12分)。
  • 翻修半肩置换常见特征包括女性(81%)、肩袖失效(89/359;25%)或肩胛下肌失效(81/359;23%)、既往骨折相关问题(154/359;43%)、盂磨蚀(125/359;35%)和假体位置不良(89/359;25%)。
  • 因骨折相关问题行半肩置换者常伴结节畸形愈合或不愈合(58/79;73%)及肱骨假体在盂表面偏心(45/71;63%)。
  • 严重盂磨蚀(3级或4级)在偏心半肩置换中(42/102;41%)比居中半肩置换中(36/146;25%)更常见(Fisher精确检验p=0.008),在外翻位置半肩置换中(28/50;56%)比中立或内翻位置中(40/188;21%)更常见(Fisher精确检验p<0.0001)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 盂磨蚀分级标准:1级为无磨蚀,2级为磨蚀限于软骨下骨,3级为中度磨蚀伴内移,4级为内移超过喙突基底。
  • 严重盂磨蚀定义为3级或4级。
  • SST评分满分12分,翻修半肩置换患者平均2.2 ± 2.2。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,为避免部分初次半肩置换翻修,手术技术应致力于使假体肱骨关节面在盂凹上居中,采用合适的肱骨假体位置和软组织平衡,避免肱骨假体外翻位置,并用盂肱关节置换而非单纯半肩置换处理盂病变。
  • 作者建议,当肩胛下肌、肩袖和结节的持久稳定性存疑时,术者可考虑反式全肩关节置换术。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Primary shoulder hemiarthroplasty is used to address a range of glenohumeral disorders, including fracture, arthritis, avascular necrosis, and capsulorrhaphy arthropathy; some patients with hemiarthroplasties undergo revision surgery for persistent pain or residual shoulder dysfunction. The literature does not clarify the features of the hemiarthroplasties having repeat surgery in a way that can guide surgeons' efforts to minimize the need for revision. To help address this gap, we analyzed the characteristics of patients from our region for whom we performed surgical revision of a prior humeral hemiarthroplasty QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What are the common characteristics of shoulder hemiarthroplasties having a revision? (2) What are the common characteristics of the subset of revised shoulder hemiarthroplasties that were performed for fracture? (3) What are characteristics of the subset of all revised hemiarthroplasties that were associated with glenoid bone erosion? METHODS: Data for 983 patients for whom we performed a surgical revision of any type of shoulder arthroplasty between January 1991 and January 2017 were identified in our longitudinally maintained institutional arthroplasty revision database. In each case, revision had been elected by shared patient and surgeon decision-making after consideration of the disorder, degree of compromised comfort and function, treatment alternatives, and the risks of surgery. Of these 983 patients, 359 (37%) had a revision of a prior primary hemiarthroplasty; these patients were the subjects of this investigation. In this group of patients, we investigated the patient demographics, shoulder characteristics, prerevision radiographic findings, and findings at revision surgery. No patients were excluded. The patients having revision of primary hemiarthroplasties had severe loss of self-assessed shoulder comfort and function, with Simple Shoulder Test (SST) scores averaging 2.2 ± 2.2 of the maximum score of 12. The majority of these patients (81%) were women. The medical records of these 359 patients were abstracted to determine the diagnosis for the index primary hemiarthroplasty, clinical characteristics before surgery, and findings at surgical revision. One hundred twelve of the arthroplasties had been performed for fracture-related diagnoses; a subgroup analysis was performed on these patients. Two hundred seventy-three of the 359 patients (76%) had plain radiographs performed within 3 months before revision surgery that were adequate for assessing the radiographic characteristics of the glenoid, humerus, humeral component, and glenohumeral relationships; a subgroup analysis was performed on these patients. The degree of glenoid erosion was measured by a single observer in accordance with established criteria: Grade 1 is no erosion, Grade 2 is erosion limited to subchondral bone, Grade 3 is moderate erosion with medialization, and Grade 4 is medialization beyond the coracoid base. Some patients were included in both of these subgroups. RESULTS: Common characteristics of the revised hemiarthroplasties included female sex (81%), rotator cuff (89 of 359; 25%) or subscapularis (81 of 359; 23%) failure, problems related to prior fracture (154 of 359; 43%), glenoid erosion 125 of 359; 35%), and component malposition (89 of 359; 25%). Hemiarthroplasties performed for fracture-related problems often were associated with tuberosity malunion or nonunion (58 of 79; 73%) and decentering of the humeral component on the glenoid surface (45 of 71; 63%). Major erosion of the bony glenoid (Grade 3 or 4) was more common in decentered hemiarthroplasties (42 of 102; 41%) than for centered hemiarthroplasties (36 of 146; 25%) (Fisher's exact p = 0.008) and more common for hemiarthroplasties positioned in valgus (28 of 50; 56%) than for those positioned in neutral or varus (40 of 188; 21%) (Fishers' exact p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that some revisions of primary hemiarthroplasties may be avoided by surgical techniques directed at centering the prosthetic humeral articular surface on the glenoid concavity using proper humeral component positioning and soft tissue balance, by avoiding valgus positioning of the humeral component, and by managing glenoid disorders with a primary glenohumeral arthroplasty rather than a hemiarthroplasty alone. When durable security of the subscapularis, rotator cuff, and tuberosities is in question, the surgeon may consider a reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hackett DJ, Hsu JE, Matsen FA, et al. Primary Shoulder Hemiarthroplasty: What Can Be Learned From 359 Cases That Were Surgically Revised? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29470237. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000167

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。