短柄髋关节假体的生存率:临床研究与国家关节登记系统的对比分析
该研究评估短柄髋关节假体的总体翻修率,数据来自2006至2016年发表的临床文献和澳大利亚国家关节登记系统。共纳入52项研究56个队列,临床研究10年翻修率中位数为4.8%,保留股骨颈型假体显著较差,依赖性与独立性研究间翻修率无显著差异,登记系统10年翻修率为6.6%。
要点
- 短柄髋假体10年翻修率中位数4.8%,澳大利亚登记系统为6.6%。
- 保留股骨颈型假体翻修率显著劣于保留股骨颈型及损伤股骨颈型。
- 依赖性与独立性临床研究的翻修率差异未达统计学显著。
核心结论
- 保留股骨颈型和损伤股骨颈型短柄假体的翻修率相近且较低。
- 依赖性研究在短柄髋关节假体寿命方面似乎不存在偏倚。
- 未来研究需要更长的临床随访时间和关节登记系统中更详细的信息。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2006年至2016年间所有关于短柄髋关节假体的临床研究,并以翻修率(每100组件年)为主要指标进行评估。
- 短柄假体分为保留股骨颈型、保留股骨颈型(不保留股骨颈)和损伤股骨颈型三类。
- 将已发表文献分为依赖性研究和独立性研究,并与澳大利亚国家关节登记系统数据进行比较。
- 共纳入52项研究、56个队列。
主要发现
- 所有临床研究10年翻修率中位数为4.8%。
- 保留股骨颈型(不保留股骨颈)和损伤股骨颈型短柄假体表现相当,而保留股骨颈型假体显著较差。
- 独立性研究翻修率高于依赖性研究,但差异未达统计学显著。
- 澳大利亚登记系统显示10年翻修率为6.6%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 未来研究需要更长的临床随访时间和关节登记系统中更详细的信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The primary aim was to evaluate the outcome of short-stem hip prostheses in terms of overall revision rates. Data were taken from published literature and national arthroplasty registers. The second study aim was to evaluate a potentially superior outcome of dependent compared to independent clinical studies. METHODS: All clinical studies on short-stem hip prostheses between 2006 and 2016 were reviewed and evaluated with a special interest on revision rates. Revision rate was calculated as "revision per 100 component years." Short stems were divided into femoral neck retaining (NR), neck sparing (NS), and neck harming (NH) prostheses. Published literature was further classified into dependent and independent studies, and data were compared to the Australian National Arthroplasty Register. RESULTS: Fifty-two studies with 56 cohorts met the inclusion criteria and were therefore included in our study. All clinical studies showed a median revision rate of 4.8% after 10 years. NS and NH stems performed equally, whereas neck retaining prostheses were significantly inferior. Independent showed higher revision rates compared to dependent data without being statistically significant. The Australian register revealed a revision rate of 6.6% after one decade. CONCLUSION: Similar low revision rates for NS and NH short-stem prostheses were found in the included data. Dependent studies seem not to be biased with regard to the longevity of short-stem hip replacement. Longer follow-up periods in clinical studies and more detailed information in arthroplasty registers would be desirable for future studies.
引用
- Hauer G, Vielgut I, Amerstorfer F, et al. Survival Rate of Short-Stem Hip Prostheses: A Comparative Analysis of Clinical Studies and National Arthroplasty Registers. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 29428465. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.01.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。