劳伦斯·D·多尔手术技术与技术奖:同日两手术室交替运行不损害关节置换术的结局或患者安全
该研究比较同一机构6名外科医生2006—2016年实施的16916例初次髋膝关节置换术中,连续单手术室手术(7002例)与两手术室交替运行手术(9914例)的并发症与翻修率。结果显示两组术中并发症、90天组件翻修率及90天并发症率均无显著差异,提示两手术室交替运行不损害患者安全或结局。
要点
- 两手术室交替运行组与连续单手术室组术中并发症率无显著差异(1.7% vs 1.6%,RR 1.082,95%CI 0.852–1.375,P=0.52)。
- 两组90天组件翻修率无显著差异(0.85% vs 0.66%,RR 1.290,95%CI 0.901–1.845,P=0.19)。
- 两组90天并发症率无显著差异(1.45% vs 1.33%,RR 1.094,95%CI 0.844–1.417,P=0.54)。
核心结论
- 这项纳入单机构多名外科医生、历时11年的大样本研究显示,与连续单手术室手术相比,两手术室交替运行手术的患者安全或结局未见损害。
研究设计与样本
- 单机构研究,6名外科医生于2006—2016年共实施16916例初次髋膝关节置换术。
- 其中连续单手术室手术7002例(41%),两手术室交替运行手术9914例(59%)。
- 比较两组术中并发症、组件翻修及术后90天内并发症。
主要发现
- 术中并发症率连续单手术室组1.6% vs 两手术室交替运行组1.7%,相对风险1.082,95%CI 0.852–1.375,P=0.52。
- 90天组件翻修率连续单手术室组0.66% vs 两手术室交替运行组0.85%,相对风险1.290,95%CI 0.901–1.845,P=0.19。
- 90天并发症率连续单手术室组1.33% vs 两手术室交替运行组1.45%,相对风险1.094,95%CI 0.844–1.417,P=0.54。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Scrutiny from the federal government and the media regarding the safety of 1 surgeon doing cases in 2 operating rooms (ORs) on the same day, prompted us to examine our own institutional data. Over the past 11 years, surgeons at our facility have operated consecutively in 1 OR on a given day or used 2 alternating ORs. This study compares these cases with a focus on revisions and complications in both groups. METHODS: Six surgeons performed a total of 16,916 primary hip and knee arthroplasties from 2006-2016. 7002 cases (41%) were consecutive cases (CCs) and 9914 cases (59%) were overlapping cases (OCs). Intraoperative complications, component revisions, and postoperative complications within 90 days of surgery were compared between the CC and OC groups. RESULTS: There was no difference in intraoperative complication rates between the two groups (CC 1.6% vs. OC 1.7%, relative risk 1.082, 95% confidence interval 0.852 to 1.375, P = .52). There was no difference in 90-day component revision rates among the CC and OC groups (0.66% vs. 0.85% respectively, relative risk = 1.290, 95% confidence interval 0.901 to 1.845, P = .19). There was also no difference in 90-day complication rates among the CC and OC groups (1.33% vs. 1.45% respectively, relative risk = 1.094, 95% confidence interval 0.844 to 1.417, P = .54). CONCLUSION: This large study of a single institution with multiple surgeons over an 11-year period shows no compromise in patient safety or outcomes when comparing cases done in either consecutive or overlapping rooms.
引用
- Hamilton WG, Ho H, Parks NL, et al. The Lawrence D. Dorr Surgical Techniques & Technologies Award: "Running Two Rooms" Does Not Compromise Outcomes or Patient Safety in Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 29452974. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.01.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。