与划伤氧化锆股骨头对磨的衬垫聚乙烯磨损增加
该研究评估了2006至2013年间同一机构取出的42个与氧化锆股骨头对磨的高交联聚乙烯衬垫,用视觉评分评估损伤并用激光扫描测量尺寸变化,同时用12工位髋关节模拟器测试9个不同程度划伤的取出氧化锆股骨头和3个严重金属转移的陶瓷头对 pristine 衬垫的磨损。结果显示严重损伤的氧化锆头对应衬垫的磨损和嵌入碎屑评分更高,4个严重损伤头在模拟器中磨损率更高,而损伤较轻的氧化锆头和严重金属转移的陶瓷头未产生明显磨损。作者结论认为反复脱位和复位操作导致的氧化锆头表面划伤会增加交联聚乙烯的磨损。
要点
- 与严重损伤氧化锆头对磨的取出衬垫磨损评分更高(磨损评分均值0.4 vs 1.6,p=0.008)。
- 与严重损伤氧化锆头对磨的取出衬垫嵌入碎屑评分更高(均值0.4 vs 1.4,p=0.006)。
- 4个严重损伤氧化锆头在模拟器中首个百万循环后重量损失分别为37.7 mg、30.0 mg、14.4 mg和2.6 mg,并持续增加至5百万循环。
核心结论
- 反复脱位和复位操作导致的氧化锆股骨头表面划伤会增加作为轴承面的交联聚乙烯的磨损。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估了2006年至2013年间在同一机构收集的所有与氧化锆股骨头对磨的取出高交联聚乙烯衬垫,共42个。
- 两名观察者使用视觉主观评分系统评估42个取出衬垫表面的聚乙烯损伤,并对聚乙烯部件进行激光扫描以测量衬垫的尺寸变化。
- 使用12工位髋关节模拟器测量 pristine 衬垫与9个不同程度划伤的取出氧化锆股骨头及3个严重金属转移的取出陶瓷头对磨5百万循环的磨损。
主要发现
- 17个氧化锆股骨头显示严重损伤,其中14个头因脱位而翻修。
- 与损伤较轻的氧化锆头对磨的取出衬垫相比,与严重损伤头对磨的衬垫磨损评分更高(均值0.4 vs 1.6,p=0.008),嵌入碎屑评分更高(均值0.4 vs 1.4,p=0.006)。
- 4个严重损伤的氧化锆头在模拟器中磨损率高于其他头,首个百万循环后重量损失分别为37.7 mg、30.0 mg、14.4 mg和2.6 mg,并持续增加至5百万循环。
- 损伤较轻的氧化锆头和严重金属转移的陶瓷头均未产生明显磨损。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在存在氧化锆股骨头的情况下发生此类不稳定的患者应密切随访,以警惕更严重磨损的可能性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Oxidized zirconium (OxZr) femoral heads were introduced in hip arthroplasty to reduce wear of the polyethylene compared with metallic heads and to reduce fracture risk compared with ceramic heads. Severe scratches have been reported on OxZr heads in patients undergoing revision for instability, but whether these scratches contribute to increased acetabular polyethylene wear remains unclear. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How is the polyethylene of the acetabular liner affected by damage on the opposing OxZr head? (2) How does damage to the head affect the degree of polyethylene wear? METHODS: We assessed damage and deformation on all retrieved highly crosslinked liners that had articulated against OxZr heads collected at one institution between 2006 and 2013. Two observers used a visual subjective scoring system to assess polyethylene damage on the surface of the 42 retrieved liners. Polyethylene components were also laser scanned to measure dimensional changes to the liner. These outcomes were compared with the severity of scratching on the surface of the articulating OxZr head. We also used a 12-station hip simulator to measure wear over five million cycles (MCs) of pristine liners articulating against nine retrieved OxZr heads with varying degrees of scratching representing a spectrum of little to severe damage and three retrieved ceramic heads with severe metal transfer. RESULTS: Seventeen of the OxZr heads showed severe damage, of which 14 heads had been revised for dislocation. The retrieved liners that had articulated with these heads had greater damage scores for abrasion (mean score 0.4 versus 1.6; p = 0.008) and embedded debris (mean score 0.4 versus 1.4; p = 0.006) compared with liners that had articulated with less damaged heads. Four severely damaged OxZr heads wore at a higher rate than the others in the study with weight loss of 37.7 mg, 30.0 mg, 14.4 mg, and 2.6 mg after the first MC and a steady increase through testing to 5 MCs. Conversely, neither OxZr heads with less damage nor ceramic heads with severe metal transfer produced appreciable wear. CONCLUSIONS: Surface scratching of OxZr heads from recurrent dislocation and reduction maneuvers leads to increased wear of the crosslinked polyethylene used as a bearing surface. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Patients in whom such instability occurs in the presence of an OxZr head should be followed closely for the possibility of more severe wear.
引用
- Carli A, Koch CN, Esposito CI, et al. Polyethylene Wear Increases in Liners Articulating With Scratched Oxidized Zirconium Femoral Heads. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2018. PMID: 29389782. doi:10.1007/s11999.0000000000000040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。