年轻患者理想的全髋关节置换承重面:氧化铝陶瓷对陶瓷与陶瓷对传统聚乙烯的前瞻性随机试验15年随访
58髋(57例,平均年龄42岁)随机接受陶瓷对陶瓷(CoC)或陶瓷对聚乙烯(CoP)全髋关节置换,前瞻性随访至少15年。两组Harris髋关节评分和St Michael髋关节评分(SMH)均较术前显著改善且组间无差异,聚乙烯磨损率CoP组为0.092毫米/年、CoC组为0.018毫米/年;CoP组5例翻修(4例因聚乙烯磨损和骨溶解),CoC组4例翻修(股骨头碎裂、不稳、感染、锥度腐蚀各1例)。结论认为两组生存率和功能相当,但聚乙烯磨损和骨溶解可能成为未来问题。
要点
- 两组Harris髋关节评分和SMH功能评分均较术前显著改善,且两种承重面之间无差异。
- CoP组聚乙烯磨损率为0.092毫米/年,CoC组为0.018毫米/年。
- CoP组5例翻修(4例因聚乙烯磨损和骨溶解),CoC组4例翻修(股骨头碎裂、不稳、感染、锥度腐蚀各1例)。
核心结论
- 两种承重面的生存率和功能仍然相当,但聚乙烯磨损和骨溶解可能成为未来的问题。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机试验,共58髋(57例患者,平均年龄42岁)随机接受陶瓷对陶瓷(CoC)或陶瓷对聚乙烯(CoP)全髋关节置换。
- 前瞻性随访生存率、功能结局(Harris髋关节评分和St Michael髋关节评分[SMH])及影像学结局。
主要发现
- 至少15年随访时,3例患者死亡但未翻修,7例失访。
- CoP组5例翻修(4例因聚乙烯磨损和骨溶解);CoC组4例翻修,股骨头碎裂、不稳、感染和锥度腐蚀各1例。
- CoP组SMH从15.6改善至21.5、Harris髋关节评分从48.8改善至88.7(P > .05);CoC组SMH从15.8改善至23.5、Harris髋关节评分从50.3改善至94.6(P > .05)。
- 聚乙烯平均磨损率为0.092毫米/年,CoC为0.018毫米/年。
- CoC组2例患者有髋臼骨溶解证据,CoP组3例;CoC组6例患者有股骨骨溶解,CoP组12例。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The optimum bearing surface for total hip arthroplasty remains debatable. We have previously published our outcome at 10 years and this represents the 15-year follow-up. METHODS: A total of 58 hips (in 57 patients with a mean age of 42 years) were randomized to receive either ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) or ceramic-on-polyethylene (CoP) total hip arthroplasty. We prospectively followed for survivorship, functional outcomes (using the Harris Hip Score and the St Michael's Hip Score [SMH]), and radiological outcomes. RESULTS: At a minimum of 15 years, 3 patients had died, but not been revised. Seven were lost to follow-up. Five cases from the CoP group were revised (4 for polyethylene wear and osteolysis). Four from the CoC were revised; one each for head fracture, instability, infection, and trunnionosis. Both groups showed statistically significant improvements in Harris Hip Score scores and SMH functional scores, with no difference between the 2 bearings. For the CoP group, there was an improvement from 15.6 to 21.5 in the SMH and from 48.8 to 88.7 (P > .05); and for CoC, this improvement was 15.8 to 23.5 and 50.3 to 94.6 (P > .05), respectively. Mean wear rate of the polyethylene was 0.092 mm/y and for the CoC was 0.018 mm/y. Two patients in the CoC group had evidence of acetabular osteolysis vs 3 in the CoP. Six patients had femoral osteolysis in the CoC group and 12 in the CoP group. CONCLUSION: Survivorship and function of the 2 bearing groups remains comparable; while the polyethylene wear and osteolysis may represent issues in the future.
引用
- Atrey A, Wolfstadt JI, Hussain N, et al. The Ideal Total Hip Replacement Bearing Surface in the Young Patient: A Prospective Randomized Trial Comparing Alumina Ceramic-On-Ceramic With Ceramic-On-Conventional Polyethylene: 15-Year Follow-Up. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 29422350. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.11.066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。