撞击力影响全髋关节置换术中锥度-桁架稳定性
研究用30个钛合金桁架与36毫米零偏距钴铬股骨头装配,以6 kN或14 kN单次或组合撞击后测试分离力。结果显示股骨头拉脱力约为撞击力的45%,单次14 kN撞击的拉脱力是6 kN组的两倍,相同力重复撞击未提高拉脱力,偏移量不影响拉脱力。
要点
- 股骨头拉脱力约为撞击力的45%。
- 单次14 kN撞击的拉脱力是6 kN组的两倍。
- 相同力重复撞击未提高拉脱力(6 kN组P=.90,14 kN组P=.90)。
核心结论
- 股骨头撞击力影响股骨头桁架-锥度稳定性,而偏移量不影响拉脱力。
- 只要单次撞击在锤头-撞击器界面达到14 kN力,多次撞击不增加额外稳定性。
- 撞击力不足可能导致桁架-锥度结合不充分。
研究设计与样本
- 研究将30个钛合金桁架与36毫米零偏距钴铬股骨头(对应锥度角)装配。
- 落塔以2.5 J或8.25 J撞击股骨头,分别产生6 kN或14 kN撞击力,采用单次撞击或6 kN+14 kN、14 kN+14 kN组合。
- 另将10个36毫米、-5和+5偏移的股骨头以连续14 kN+14 kN撞击。
- 随后用螺旋驱动机械测试架拆卸股骨头并记录峰值分离力。
主要发现
- 股骨头拉脱力为撞击力的45%。
- 单次14 kN撞击的股骨头拉脱力是6 kN组的两倍。
- 相同力两次撞击未提高拉脱力:6 kN组P=.90,14 kN组P=.90。
- 若两次撞击力不同但任一次为14 kN,拉脱力比6 kN或6 kN+6 kN撞击高51%。
- 股骨头偏移量在-5、0、+5之间未显著改变拉脱力(P=.37)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This study investigated the influence of femoral head impaction force, number of head strikes, the energy sequence of head strikes, and head offset on the strength of the taper-trunnion junction. METHODS: Thirty titanium-alloy trunnions were mated with 36-mm zero-offset cobalt-chromium femoral heads of corresponding taper angle. A drop tower impacted the head with 2.5J or 8.25J, resulting in 6 kN or 14 kN impaction force, respectively, in a single strike or combinations of 6 kN + 14 kN or 14 kN + 14 kN. In addition, ten 36-mm heads with -5 and +5 offset were impacted with sequential 14 kN + 14 kN strikes. Heads were subsequently disassembled using a screw-driven mechanical testing frame, and peak distraction force was recorded. RESULTS: Femoral head pull-off force was 45% the strike force, and heads struck with a single 14 kN impact showed a pull-off force twice that of the 6 kN group. Two head strikes with the same force did not improve pull-off force for either 6 kN (P = .90) or 14 kN (P = .90). If the forces of the 2 impactions varied, but either impact measured 14 kN, a 51% higher pull-off force was found compared to impactions of either 6 kN or 6 kN + 6 kN. Femoral head offset did not significantly change the pull-off force among -5, 0, and +5 heads (P = .37). CONCLUSION: Femoral head impaction force influenced femoral head trunnion-taper stability, whereas offset did not affect pull-off force. Multiple head strikes did not add additional stability, as long as a single strike achieved 14 kN force at the mallet-head impactor interface. Insufficient impaction force may lead to inadequate engagement of the trunnion-taper junction.
引用
- Danoff JR, Longaray J, Rajaravivarma R, et al. Impaction Force Influences Taper-Trunnion Stability in Total Hip Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2018. PMID: 29428467. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2018.01.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。