骨科创伤协会开放性骨折分类与Gustilo-Anderson分类的观察者间信度比较
研究纳入任何年龄首次就诊的开放性长骨骨折患者,向八名骨科外科医生提供标准X线片、伤口照片和简短临床描述,分别用Gustilo-Anderson(GA)分类和骨科创伤协会开放性骨折分类(OTA-OFC)独立评估,用Cohen kappa比较变异性。总体观察者间一致性GA为ĸ=0.44,OTA-OFC为ĸ=0.49,均属中等一致。作者认为OTA-OFC虽与GA一致性相似且能更详细描述开放性骨折,但可能仍需进一步发展才能成为可靠稳健的工具。
要点
- GA分类总体观察者间一致性ĸ=0.44,OTA-OFC为ĸ=0.49,均属中等一致(0.41至0.60)。
- OTA-OFC五个类别一致性:皮肤ĸ=0.55(中等)、肌肉ĸ=0.44(中等)、动脉损伤ĸ=0.74(高度)、污染ĸ=0.35(一般)、骨缺损ĸ=0.41(中等)。
- 作者认为OTA-OFC虽更详细,但可能仍需进一步发展才能成为可靠稳健的工具。
核心结论
- OTA-OFC与GA分类的观察者间一致性相似,但OTA-OFC能更详细描述开放性骨折,作者认为可能仍需进一步发展才能成为可靠稳健的工具。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入任何年龄首次就诊的开放性长骨骨折患者,向八名骨科外科医生提供标准X线片、伤口照片和简短临床描述,分别用GA分类和OTA-OFC独立评估,用Cohen kappa比较变异性。
主要发现
- GA分类总体观察者间一致性ĸ=0.44,OTA-OFC为ĸ=0.49,均属中等一致(0.41至0.60)。
- OTA-OFC皮肤类别ĸ=0.55(中等),肌肉类别ĸ=0.44(中等),动脉损伤类别ĸ=0.74(高度),污染类别ĸ=0.35(一般),骨缺损类别ĸ=0.41(中等)。
关键数值与推荐
- GA分类总体观察者间一致性ĸ=0.44,OTA-OFC为ĸ=0.49,中等一致范围为0.41至0.60。
- OTA-OFC皮肤ĸ=0.55(中等),肌肉ĸ=0.44(中等),动脉损伤ĸ=0.74(高度),污染ĸ=0.35(一般),骨缺损ĸ=0.41(中等)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 作者认为OTA-OFC可能仍需进一步发展才能成为可靠稳健的工具。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To evaluate interobserver reliability of the Orthopaedic Trauma Association's open fracture classification system (OTA-OFC). PATIENTS AND METHODS: Patients of any age with a first presentation of an open long bone fracture were included. Standard radiographs, wound photographs, and a short clinical description were given to eight orthopaedic surgeons, who independently evaluated the injury using both the Gustilo and Anderson (GA) and OTA-OFC classifications. The responses were compared for variability using Cohen's kappa. RESULTS: The overall interobserver agreement was ĸ = 0.44 for the GA classification and ĸ = 0.49 for OTA-OFC, which reflects moderate agreement (0.41 to 0.60) for both classifications. The agreement in the five categories of OTA-OFC was: for skin, ĸ = 0.55 (moderate); for muscle, ĸ = 0.44 (moderate); for arterial injury, ĸ = 0.74 (substantial); for contamination, ĸ = 0.35 (fair); and for bone loss, ĸ = 0.41 (moderate). CONCLUSION: Although the OTA-OFC, with similar interobserver agreement to GA, offers a more detailed description of open fractures, further development may be needed to make it a reliable and robust tool. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2018;100-B:242-6.
引用
- Ghoshal A, Enninghorst N, Sisak K, et al. An interobserver reliability comparison between the Orthopaedic Trauma Association's open fracture classification and the Gustilo and Anderson classification. Bone Joint J. 2018. PMID: 29437068. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.100B2.BJJ-2017-0367.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。