文献速递创伤骨科运动医学

第五跖骨琼斯骨折固定方法的生物力学比较

A Biomechanical Comparison of Fifth Metatarsal Jones Fracture Fixation Methods.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2018-02-21

研究在12对男性尸体足标本上模拟琼斯骨折,比较髓内螺钉与足底外侧钢板固定的力学强度。钢板组在循环载荷下失效周期数、峰值失效载荷均显著高于螺钉组,骨折间隙显著更小。作者指出该钢板构造在尸体模拟骨折中表现优于髓内螺钉,但尚需进一步临床对比研究评估其临床使用。

要点

  • 钢板组失效周期数63.9±27.0 vs 螺钉组37.3±36.9,P=0.01
  • 钢板组峰值失效载荷159.2±60.5 N vs 螺钉组96.5±45.8 N,P=0.01
  • 钢板组最终间隙宽度0.0±0.0 mm vs 螺钉组3.2±2.4 mm,P<0.01

核心结论

  • 在模拟琼斯骨折并暴露于悬臂弯曲的尸体足标本中,足底外侧钢板较髓内螺钉允许更大的失效周期数和峰值载荷,且间隙宽度更小。
  • 作者指出尚需进一步的临床对比研究来评估该构造的临床使用。

研究设计与样本

  • 受控实验室研究,使用12对男性尸体足,分钢板组与螺钉组进行左右侧对照比较测试。
  • 每组第五跖骨均用微矢状锯截骨模拟琼斯骨折。
  • 钢板组采用3.0 mm 4孔低切迹钛板足底外侧放置,配3枚锁定螺钉和1枚非锁定螺钉。
  • 螺钉组采用40或45 mm×5.5 mm部分螺纹实心钛髓内螺钉。
  • 固定后行梯度循环悬臂失效测试,正弦加载每10周期增加5.0磅力至机械失效,采用配对双尾t检验(α=0.05,P<.05为显著)。

主要发现

  • 两组失效模式均主要位于骨-植入物界面。
  • 钢板组失效周期数63.9±27.0 vs 螺钉组37.3±36.9,P=0.01。
  • 钢板组峰值失效载荷159.2±60.5 N vs 螺钉组96.5±45.8 N,P=0.01。
  • 钢板组最终间隙宽度0.0±0.0 mm vs 螺钉组3.2±2.4 mm,P<0.01。

临床怎么用

  • 作者在临床相关性中指出,运动员在琼斯骨折愈合前早期重返赛场与失败风险增加相关。
  • 作者指出该足底外侧钢板构造在尸体模拟琼斯骨折中表现优于髓内螺钉固定,但尚需进一步临床对比研究评估其临床使用。

局限性

  • 作者指出尚需进一步的临床对比研究来评估该构造的临床使用。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Fifth metatarsal base fractures of the metaphyseal-diaphyseal watershed junction (Jones fracture) are commonly treated with surgical fixation in athletes. Intramedullary screw fixation remains the most utilized construct, although plantar-lateral plating is an alternative. Purpose/Hypothesis: The purpose was to compare the mechanical strength of fracture fixation between an intramedullary screw and plantar-lateral plating. The hypothesis was that plantar-lateral plate fixation would allow for more cycles and higher peak loads before failure, as well as less fracture gapping, than would an intramedullary screw in cadaveric foot specimens with simulated Jones fractures exposed to cantilever bending. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Twelve pairs of male cadaver feet were separated into 2 groups (plate or screw) to conduct contralateral comparative testing of 2 devices with equally numbered right and left feet. For each fifth metatarsal, an osteotomy with a microsagittal saw was created to simulate a Jones fracture. The plate group underwent fixation with a 3.0-mm 4-hole low-profile titanium plate placed plantar-laterally with 3 locking screws and 1 nonlocking screw. The screw group underwent fixation with a 40- or 45-mm × 5.5-mm partially threaded solid titanium intramedullary screw. After fixation, the metatarsals were excised for biomechanical testing. Cyclic cantilever failure testing was conducted with a gradient-cycle method. Sinusoidal loading forces were applied, increasing by 5.0-pound-force increments per 10 cycles, until each specimen experienced mechanical failure of implant or bone. Failure mode, number of cycles to failure, peak failure load, gap width at the last mutual prefailure loading, and video data were recorded. Paired 2-tailed t test (α = 0.05) was used to compare groups ( P < .05 set for significance). RESULTS: Failure mode in both groups occurred predominantly at the bone-implant interface. Plate fixation resulted in significantly higher mean ± SD values for cycles to failure (63.9 ± 27.0 vs 37.3 ± 36.9, P = .01) and peak failure load (159.2 ± 60.5 N vs 96.5 ± 45.8 N, P = .01), with a significantly lower mean gap width (0.0 ± 0.0 mm vs 3.2 ± 2.4 mm, P < .01). CONCLUSION: As compared with intramedullary screw fixation, plantar-lateral plating allowed for greater cycles to failure and peak load before failure, as well as less gap width, when applied to cadaver foot specimens with simulated Jones fractures exposed to cantilever bending in a load frame. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Early return to play among athletes before Jones fracture union is associated with increased risk of failure. This study introduces a plantar-lateral plating construct that performed more favorably than intramedullary screw fixation when applied to simulated Jones fractures in cadaveric foot specimens. Further clinical comparative studies are needed to assess the clinical use of this construct.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Duplantier NL, Mitchell RJ, Zambrano S, et al. A Biomechanical Comparison of Fifth Metatarsal Jones Fracture Fixation Methods. Am J Sports Med. 2018. PMID: 29466679. doi:10.1177/0363546517753376

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。