髋关节镜下选择性清创保留盂唇的狭窄适应证:至少5年随访与配对盂唇修复对照组比较
本研究为队列研究(证据等级3),纳入2008年2月至2011年9月期间接受初次髋关节镜手术的患者,评估狭窄适应证下选择性清创保留盂唇(SDLP)至少5年随访的疗效,并与1:1配对盂唇修复对照组比较。结果显示SDLP组所有患者报告结局评分均显著改善(P<.001),配对比较中SDLP组与盂唇修复组各项评分相当,仅SF-12心理评分SDLP组57.4 vs 对照组55.1(P=.031)。作者认为在稳定盂唇撕裂的特定病例中,SDLP可保留功能性盂唇,至少5年随访结果与配对盂唇修复组相当。
要点
- SDLP组101髋至少5年随访,mHHS从63.4改善至82.4,NAHS从57.4改善至83.6,HOS-SSS从44.2改善至74.5(P<.001)。
- 配对比较中SDLP组69髋与盂唇修复组1:1匹配,各项评分相当,仅SF-12心理评分SDLP组57.4 vs 对照组55.1(P=.031)。
- SDLP组4.0%患者接受二次镜手术(平均18.5个月),13.9%转为全髋关节置换(平均46.9个月)。
核心结论
- 在稳定盂唇撕裂的特定病例中,SDLP可能允许保留功能性盂唇。
- 至少5年随访时,采用狭窄适应证的SDLP产生了与配对盂唇修复组相当的有利结果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为队列研究,证据等级3。
- 数据收集自2008年2月至2011年9月期间所有接受初次髋关节镜手术的患者。
- 排除标准为髋臼或股骨头Outerbridge 4级软骨损伤、术前Tnnis分级≥2、工伤索赔、既往髋关节疾病、严重发育不良(外侧中心边缘角<18°)或同侧髋关节手术史。
- 纳入接受关节镜盂唇清创且有术前和至少5年患者报告结局评分的患者,评分包括改良Harris髋关节评分(mHHS)、非关节炎髋关节评分(NAHS)、髋关节结局评分-运动特定子量表(HOS-SSS)及疼痛视觉模拟量表(VAS)。
- 在嵌套配对比较中,SDLP组按年龄±5岁、体重指数±5 kg/m2、性别和Seldes撕裂类型与关节镜盂唇修复对照组1:1匹配。
主要发现
- 125髋符合纳入条件,其中101髋(80.8%)有至少5年随访。
- 末次随访时所有患者报告结局评分显著改善(P<.001):mHHS从63.4改善至82.4,NAHS从57.4改善至83.6,HOS-SSS从44.2改善至74.5。
- 平均VAS评分从5.8降至2.3(P<.001)。
- 平均患者满意度评分为8.1。
- 4例(4.0%)患者接受二次镜手术(平均18.5个月),14例(13.9%)患者转为全髋关节置换(平均46.9个月)。
关键数值与推荐
- 配对比较中SDLP组69髋与盂唇修复组1:1匹配,末次随访结果分别为:mHHS 83.0 vs 86.1(P=.084);NAHS 85.0 vs 85.4(P=.415);HOS-SSS 74.8 vs 76.8(P=.219);VAS 2.3 vs 2.0(P=.277);国际髋关节结局工具-12(iHOT-12)73.8 vs 76.4(P=.136);SF-12心理评分57.4 vs 55.1(P=.031);SF-12生理评分48.7 vs 48.9(P=.357);VR-12心理评分61.6 vs 59.8(P=.160);VR-12生理评分50.1 vs 50.2(P=.340);患者满意度8.0 vs 8.3(P=.211)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在稳定盂唇撕裂的特定病例中,SDLP可能允许保留功能性盂唇。
- 作者结论指出,至少5年随访时采用狭窄适应证的SDLP产生了与配对盂唇修复组相当的有利结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Arthroscopic labral debridement in the hip can be an effective treatment for labral tears but has demonstrated inferior outcomes compared with labral repair. Thus, the role for labral debridement has become unclear. Hypothesis/Purpose: The purpose was to evaluate the outcomes of a selective debridement with labral preservation (SDLP) group with a minimum 5-year follow-up. It was hypothesized that, with narrow indications, SDLP would produce statistically improved patient-reported outcome (PRO) scores, comparable with those of a matched-pair labral repair control group. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Data were collected on all patients undergoing primary hip arthroscopic surgery between February 2008 and September 2011. Exclusion criteria were acetabular or femoral head Outerbridge grade 4 chondral damage, preoperative Tnnis grade ≥2, workers' compensation claims, previous hip conditions, severe dysplasia (lateral center-edge angle <18°), or previous ipsilateral hip surgery. Patients who underwent arthroscopic labral debridement and had preoperative and minimum 5-year PRO scores, including the modified Harris Hip Score (mHHS), Non-Arthritic Hip Score (NAHS), and Hip Outcome Score-Sports-Specific Subscale (HOS-SSS) as well as the visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, were included. In a nested matched-pair comparison, the SDLP group was matched 1:1 to an arthroscopic labral repair control group based on age ±5 years, body mass index ±5 kg/m2, sex, and Seldes tear type. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-five hips were eligible for inclusion, of which 101 (80.8%) hips had a minimum 5-year follow-up. All PRO scores were significantly improved ( P < .001) at latest follow-up (mHHS, 63.4 to 82.4; NAHS, 57.4 to 83.6; HOS-SSS, 44.2 to 74.5). The mean VAS score decreased from 5.8 to 2.3 ( P < .001). The mean patient satisfaction score was 8.1. Four (4.0%) patients underwent second-look arthroscopic surgery (mean, 18.5 months), and 14 (13.9%) patients converted to total hip arthroplasty (mean, 46.9 months). In the matched-pair comparison, 69 in the SDLP group were matched 1:1 with those undergoing labral repair. Outcomes at latest follow-up of the SDLP group were comparable with those of the control group, respectively: mHHS, 83.0 vs 86.1 ( P = .084); NAHS, 85.0 vs 85.4 ( P = .415); HOS-SSS, 74.8 vs 76.8 ( P = .219); VAS, 2.3 vs 2.0 ( P = .277); international Hip Outcome Tool-12 (iHOT-12), 73.8 vs 76.4 ( P = .136); Short Form Health Survey-12 (SF-12) mental, 57.4 vs 55.1 ( P = .031); SF-12 physical, 48.7 vs 48.9 ( P = .357); Veterans RAND Health Survey-12 (VR-12) mental, 61.6 vs 59.8 ( P = .160); VR-12 physical, 50.1 vs 50.2 ( P = .340); and patient satisfaction, 8.0 vs 8.3 ( P = .211). CONCLUSION: In select cases of stable labral tears, SDLP may allow the preservation of a functional labrum. At a minimum 5-year follow-up, SDLP using narrow indications produced favorable outcomes comparable with a matched-pair labral repair group.
引用
- Chen AW, Yuen LC, Ortiz-Declet V, et al. Selective Debridement With Labral Preservation Using Narrow Indications in the Hip: Minimum 5-Year Outcomes With a Matched-Pair Labral Repair Control Group. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 29135288. doi:10.1177/0363546517739566
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。