自体软骨细胞植入「三明治」技术对比自体骨移植治疗膝关节深部骨软骨损伤
该队列研究比较了自体软骨细胞植入(ACI)三明治技术联合自体骨移植(ABG)与单纯ABG治疗症状性深部(>8 mm)骨软骨损伤的中长期疗效。ACI三明治组24例,ABG组17例,ACI三明治组5年生存率87%优于ABG组的54%(P = .0025),功能评分和患者满意度更高,且无显著骨关节炎进展。
要点
- ACI三明治组失败3例(13%),ABG组失败8例(62%),5年生存率87% vs 54%(P = .0025)。
- ACI三明治组所有功能评分显著改善,ABG组仅VAS评分显著改善。
- ACI三明治组超过90%患者报告膝关节良好或优秀并满意手术。
核心结论
- ACI三明治技术相比单纯ABG提供了优异且更优的生存率,并在中长期随访中显示显著改善。
- 该独特治疗为自然进展为骨关节炎并最终需要人工关节置换的病变提供了自体关节保留。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- ACI三明治组为2001年至2013年间连续接受ABG联合ACI三明治技术的24例患者。
- ABG组为1995年至2002年间由同一术者连续行单纯ABG的17例历史对照患者。
- 纳入症状性深部(>8 mm)骨软骨损伤且随访至少2年的患者。
主要发现
- ABG组17例中13例(76%)获得随访,平均术后随访15.7年(范围5-21年)。
- ACI三明治组24例全部获得随访,平均术后随访7.8年(范围2-15年)。
- 两组在年龄、性别、手术侧别、体重指数、病变类型、病变大小、病变深度、病变位置或需行力线截骨方面无显著差异。
- ABG组8例(62%)判定为失败,ACI三明治组3例(13%)判定为失败。
- ACI三明治组5年生存率87% vs ABG组54%(P = .0025),ACI三明治组显著更优。
关键数值与推荐
- 失败终点定义为无临床改善、移植物失败或转为人工关节置换。
- 功能评估采用改良Cincinnati膝关节评分系统、WOMAC骨关节炎指数、VAS、SF-36及患者满意度调查。
- 生存分析采用Kaplan-Meier法。
- 骨关节炎进展采用Kellgren-Lawrence(K-L)分级评估。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Treating symptomatic osteochondral defects is challenging, especially in young adults with deep (>8-10 mm) empty defects after osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) or collapsed condyles secondary to avascular necrosis (AVN). For this population, osteoarthritis (OA) is inevitable if articular congruence is not restored. PURPOSE: To describe the autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) "sandwich" technique with autologous bone grafting (ABG) and compare it with ABG alone for restoration of the osteochondral unit. The midterm to long-term outcomes in patients after the treatment for OCD and AVN will be reported and compared. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: The outcomes for a consecutive cohort of 24 patients who underwent combined ABG with the ACI sandwich technique between 2001 and 2013 (ACI sandwich group) was compared with a historical control group of 17 consecutive patients who underwent ABG alone between 1995 and 2002 (ABG group) by a single surgeon for symptomatic deep (>8 mm) osteochondral lesions. Patients who were followed up with a minimum of 2 years were included in this study. The modified Cincinnati Knee Rating System, the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index, a visual analog scale (VAS), the Short Form-36, and a patient satisfaction survey were used to evaluate clinical outcomes. Survival analysis was performed using the Kaplan-Meier method, with no clinical improvement, graft failure, or conversion to prosthetic arthroplasty as the endpoint (failure). Kellgren-Lawrence (K-L) grading to assess OA progression was also performed. RESULTS: In the ABG group, 13 of 17 patients (76%) were available with a mean follow-up of 15.7 years postoperatively (range, 5-21 years). In the ACI sandwich group, all 24 patients were available with a mean follow-up of 7.8 years postoperatively (range, 2-15 years). No significant differences were observed between the groups in terms of age, sex, side of the operated knee, body mass index, lesion type, lesion size, lesion depth, lesion location, or the need for realignment osteotomy. Eight patients (62%) were considered failures in the ABG group, while 3 patients (13%) were considered failures in the ACI sandwich group. The survival rate was significantly better in the ACI sandwich group than the ABG group (87% vs 54% at 5 years, respectively; P = .0025). All functional scores in patients with retained grafts significantly improved in the ACI sandwich group, whereas only the VAS score showed significant improvement in the ABG group. The patient satisfaction survey showed a very high satisfaction rate in the ACI sandwich group, with over 90% of patients reporting their knees as good or excellent and being satisfied with the procedure. In the ACI sandwich group, K-L grading demonstrated no significant OA progression from preoperatively to a mean 5.1 years postoperatively. CONCLUSION: Our study showed that the ACI sandwich technique provided excellent and superior survival rates compared to ABG alone and significant improvements over midterm to long-term follow-up. This unique treatment offers native joint preservation for conditions that naturally will progress to OA and eventually require prosthetic arthroplasty.
引用
- Minas T, Ogura T, Headrick J, et al. Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation "Sandwich" Technique Compared With Autologous Bone Grafting for Deep Osteochondral Lesions in the Knee. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 29125919. doi:10.1177/0363546517738000
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。