风险筛查与优化后行两组同步快速通道双侧全膝关节置换术与单侧全膝关节置换术患者90天患病率与死亡率的比较——一项前瞻性研究
该前瞻性研究在高容量关节置换中心纳入风险筛查与优化后的患者,每臂连续招募1200例,比较两组同步快速通道双侧全膝关节置换术(SBTKA)与单侧全膝关节置换术(UTKA)的90天患病率与死亡率。SBTKA组90天死亡率0.58% vs UTKA组0.42%(P=.5646),总体手术相关并发症SBTKA组7.25% vs UTKA组4.42%(P=.0034),心血管并发症相对风险为UTKA组的6.5倍(1.08% vs 0.17%,P=.0136),神经系统并发症为9.5倍(1.58% vs 0.17%,P=.0024)。结论认为风险筛查与术前优化可降低SBTKA患者死亡率与总体并发症率,但总体手术相关并发症尤其是心血管与神经系统并发症在SBTKA患者中仍显著较高,建议采取谨慎态度。
要点
- 风险筛查与优化后SBTKA组90天死亡率0.58% vs UTKA组0.42%,差异无统计学显著(P=.5646)。
- SBTKA组总体手术相关并发症7.25% vs UTKA组4.42%,SBTKA组显著更高(P=.0034)。
- SBTKA组心血管并发症相对风险为UTKA组的6.5倍(1.08% vs 0.17%,P=.0136),神经系统并发症为9.5倍(1.58% vs 0.17%,P=.0024)。
核心结论
- 风险筛查与术前优化可降低SBTKA患者的死亡率与总体并发症率,但总体手术相关并发症尤其是心血管与神经系统并发症在SBTKA患者中仍显著较高,作者建议对SBTKA采取谨慎态度。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,在高容量关节置换中心纳入经风险筛查与优化的患者,SBTKA组与UTKA组每臂各连续招募1200例,比较90天患病率与死亡率。
主要发现
- 90天死亡率SBTKA组0.58% vs UTKA组0.42%(P=.5646)。
- 总体手术相关并发症SBTKA组7.25% vs UTKA组4.42%(P=.0034),SBTKA组显著更高。
- 心血管并发症相对风险SBTKA组为UTKA组的6.5倍(1.08% vs 0.17%,P=.0136)。
- 神经系统并发症SBTKA组为UTKA组的9.5倍(1.58% vs 0.17%,P=.0024)。
- 所有其他并发症两组相当。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为风险筛查与术前优化可降低SBTKA患者死亡率与总体并发症率,但总体手术相关并发症尤其是心血管与神经系统并发症仍显著较高,建议对SBTKA采取谨慎态度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Simultaneous bilateral total knee arthroplasty (SBTKA) offers significant socioeconomic benefits. However, retrospective studies and public health data show increased mortality and morbidity rates in patients undergoing SBTKA compared with those undergoing unilateral TKA (UTKA), and there have been recommendations against the use of SBTKA. High-volume centers, which feature careful patient selection and fast-tracked surgery, continue to perform SBTKA and have published their results in favor of the procedure. However, the quality of evidence remains poor. METHODS: We prospectively examined 90-day morbidity and mortality of SBTKA compared with UTKA in risk-screened and optimized patients in our high-volume joint replacement facility. A total of 1200 consecutive patients were recruited in each arm. RESULTS: Ninety-day mortality was higher in SBTKA patients than in UTKA patients (0.58% vs 0.42%, respectively; P = .5646). Overall procedure-related complications were significantly higher in the SBTKA group (7.25% vs 4.42%, respectively; P = .0034). The relative risk of cardiovascular complications in SBTKA patients was 6.5 times higher than that in UTKA patients (1.08% vs 0.17%, respectively; P = .0136). Neurological complications were 9.5 times more common in the SBTKA group (1.58% vs 0.17%, respectively; P = .0024). All other complications were comparable in the 2 groups. CONCLUSION: Risk screening and preoperative optimization reduce mortality and overall complication rates in SBTKA patients; however, overall procedure-related complications, specifically cardiovascular and neurological, remain significantly high in SBTKA patients, for which a guarded approach is recommended.
引用
- Kulshrestha V, Kumar S, Datta B, et al. Ninety-Day Morbidity and Mortality in Risk-Screened and Optimized Patients Undergoing Two-Team Fast-Track Simultaneous Bilateral TKA Compared With Unilateral TKA-A Prospective Study. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 29102512. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.09.068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。