SPOT GRADE:一种可重复定量评估手术伤口出血的新方法
本研究利用台式模型和前瞻性外科医生视频测试,创建了表面出血严重程度量表SPOT GRADE(SG),用于定量评估目标出血部位(TBS)的失血量。14名来自四个专科的外科医生经过培训后测试,结果显示SG具有较高的评定者间和评定者内信度,能可靠区分适合未来临床试验的出血与非适合出血。
要点
- SPOT GRADE(SG)是一个六级出血严重程度量表,用于定量评估手术伤口出血。
- 评定者间相关系数为0.89840(95%CI:0.85771,1),评定者内相关系数为0.93673(95%CI:0.89603,1)。
- 外科医生在98%的病例中正确识别适合未来临床试验的出血(评分=1、2或3),在91%的病例中正确识别非适合出血(评分=4或5)。
核心结论
- SG具有可重复性和可靠性,为教育外科医生评估TBS失血量提供了基础,似乎可作为评估伤口失血量的新标准。
研究设计与样本
- 采用台式模型进行前瞻性外科医生视频测试,创建了36个培训视频和108个测试视频,使用不同出血严重程度(基于六级SG:无、极小、轻度、中度、重度、极重度)和TBS大小(1、10和50 cm)。
- 14名来自四个专科(心胸外科、腹部外科、脊柱外科和骨科下肢)的外科医生接受培训并测试,以评估SG的特征,包括评定者间和评定者内信度。
主要发现
- 评定者间相关系数估计为0.89840(95%CI:0.85771,1),评定者内相关系数估计为0.93673(95%CI:0.89603,1)。
- 在98%的病例中(95%CI:0.9736,0.9927),外科医生正确识别了适合未来临床试验的出血(评分=1、2或3)。
- 在91%的病例中(95%CI:0.8895,0.9344),外科医生正确识别了非适合出血(评分=4或5)。
- 在98.6%的病例中(95%CI:0.9777,0.9945),医生正确识别了真正的止血(评分=0)。
- 基于这些数据,医生将出血错误评为止血(评分=0)的概率估计为1.51%(95%CI:0.0061,0.0363)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Benchtop model with prospective surgeon video testing. OBJECTIVE: To create a surface bleeding severity scale, the SPOT GRADE (SG), for quantitative assessment of target bleeding site (TBS) blood loss. This is of particular interest for spinal surgery due to epidural bleeding and an inability to use diathermy and radiofrequency cautery close to nerve roots. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: A novel apparatus perfusable at known flow rates and simulating different sized wounds was used to create movies to educate surgeons on specific degrees of bleeding. METHODS: Training (36) and testing (108) videos were created using a benchtop apparatus employing different bleeding severities based on the six-level SG (none, minimal, mild, moderate, severe, and extreme) and TBS sizes (1, 10, and 50 cm). Fourteen surgeons in four specialties (cardiothoracic, abdominal, spine, and orthopedic lower extremity) were trained and tested to evaluate SG characteristics including inter-rater and intrarater reliability. RESULTS: The interclass correlation coefficient was estimated to be 0.89840 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.85771, 1), whereas the intraclass correlation coefficient was estimated to be 0.93673 (95% CI: 0.89603, 1). In 98% of cases (95% CI: 0.9736, 0.9927), surgeons correctly identified eligible bleeds for a future clinical trial (scores = 1, 2, or 3) and in 91% of cases (95% CI: 0.8895, 0.9344), surgeons correctly identified noneligible bleeds (scores = 4 or 5). In 98.6% of cases (95% CI: 0.9777, 0.9945), physicians correctly identified true hemostasis (score = 0). Based upon these data the probability of a physician rating a bleed incorrectly as hemostasis (score = 0) is estimated to be 1.51% (95% CI: 0.0061, 0.0363). CONCLUSION: This SG is reproducible and reliable providing a basis for educating surgeons on TBS blood loss. It appears to be a new standard for evaluating wound blood loss. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2.
引用
- Spotnitz WD, Zielske D, Centis V, et al. The SPOT GRADE: A New Method for Reproducibly Quantifying Surgical Wound Bleeding. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2018. PMID: 29019803. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000002447
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。