当前全膝设计:基板粗糙度或锁定机制设计是否影响聚乙烯背侧磨损?
该取回分析比较了5种胫骨基板/锁定机制设计的TKA聚乙烯衬垫背侧损伤与线性磨损率,每种设计取6例翻修取回的衬垫并按体内时间、年龄、BMI、性别、翻修次数与原因匹配。结果显示非抛光仅周缘捕获设计的总损伤评分与线性磨损率最高,抛光设计整体线性磨损率低于非抛光设计;作者指出样本量相对较小,需进一步取回分析及中长期研究确认。
要点
- 抛光基板加部分周缘捕获前约束设计的总损伤评分低于非抛光仅完整周缘锁定设计(中位12.5 vs 22.3,p=0.019)。
- 抛光舌槽锁定设计磨损条痕多于非抛光周缘捕获加抗旋岛设计(中位7.25 vs 0.75,p=0.016)。
- 抛光设计整体线性磨损率低于非抛光设计(0.0102±0.0044 vs 0.0224±0.0119 mm/年,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 非抛光仅周缘捕获设计的总体损伤评分和线性磨损率最高。
- 其他TKA设计之间在损伤和磨损方面无差异,但该发现应结合相对较小的样本量考虑。
- 作者认为在基板表面光洁度与锁定机制设计的复杂相互作用中,抛光基板配合稳健锁定机制的背侧损伤和线性磨损最低。
- 作者认为非抛光基板锁定机制设计的改进可能部分抵消抛光基板的某些优势。
- 作者提出需进一步取回分析确认这些发现,尤其分析当前交联聚乙烯,并需中期和长期研究比较因磨损和骨溶解导致的TKA翻修后再理解此类设计差异是否具有临床相关性。
研究设计与样本
- 取回分析,选取5种TKA植入物模型(4种现代设计和1种历史设计),具有不同胫骨基板和/或锁定机制设计。
- 每种TKA模型取6例翻修时取回的胫骨衬垫,按体内时间、TKA翻修时患者年龄、BMI、性别、翻修次数和翻修原因进行匹配。
- 每例衬垫背侧由两名观察者分析视觉总损伤评分和单项视觉损伤模式,组内相关系数为0.66(95%CI,0.39-0.92),并用微型CT测量线性磨损率。
- 在5组给定样本量下,以80%把握度可检测损伤评分10分差异和磨损率每年0.11 mm差异。
- 主要结局中位数在5种设计间进行比较。
主要发现
- 抛光胫骨设计配合部分周缘捕获锁定机制和前约束的总损伤评分低于非抛光胫骨设计仅配合完整周缘锁定机制(中位12.5;范围9.5-18.0;95%CI,9.58-16.42 vs 中位22.3;范围15.5-27.0;95%CI,17.5-26.5;p=0.019)。
- 抛光基板配合舌槽锁定机制的磨损条痕多于非抛光基板配合周缘捕获和抗旋岛(中位7.25;范围0.5-8.0;95%CI,2.67-8.99 vs 中位0.75;范围0-1.5;95%CI,0.20-1.47;p=0.016)。
- 凹坑是非抛光基板配合周缘捕获和抗旋岛(中位5.5;范围2.0-9.0;95%CI,2.96-8.38)以及仅周缘捕获(中位9.0;范围6.0-10.0;95%CI,7.29-10.38)特有的磨损模式。
- 抛光设计的整体线性磨损率低于非抛光设计(0.0102±0.0044 mm/年 vs 0.0224±0.0119 mm/年;p<0.001)。
- 两种抛光基板设计中,部分周缘捕获前约束设计(中位0.083 mm/年;范围0.0037-0.0111 mm/年;95%CI,0.0050-0.0107 mm vs 中位0.0245 mm/年;范围0.014-0.046 mm/年;95%CI,0.0130-0.0414 mm;p=0.008)和舌槽锁定机制(中位0.0085 mm/年;范围0.005-0.015 mm/年;95%CI,0.0045-0.0138 mm;p=0.032)的聚乙烯线性磨损率低于非抛光基板仅周缘捕获设计。
关键数值与推荐
- 总损伤评分:抛光部分周缘捕获前约束设计中位12.5(范围9.5-18.0;95%CI,9.58-16.42)vs 非抛光仅完整周缘锁定设计中位22.3(范围15.5-27.0;95%CI,17.5-26.5),p=0.019。
- 磨损条痕:抛光舌槽锁定设计中位7.25(范围0.5-8.0;95%CI,2.67-8.99)vs 非抛光周缘捕获加抗旋岛设计中位0.75(范围0-1.5;95%CI,0.20-1.47),p=0.016。
- 凹坑:非抛光周缘捕获加抗旋岛设计中位5.5(范围2.0-9.0;95%CI,2.96-8.38),非抛光仅周缘捕获设计中位9.0(范围6.0-10.0;95%CI,7.29-10.38)。
- 整体线性磨损率:抛光设计0.0102±0.0044 mm/年 vs 非抛光设计0.0224±0.0119 mm/年,p<0.001。
- 线性磨损率:抛光部分周缘捕获前约束设计中位0.083 mm/年(范围0.0037-0.0111 mm/年;95%CI,0.0050-0.0107 mm)vs 非抛光仅周缘捕获设计中位0.0245 mm/年(范围0.014-0.046 mm/年;95%CI,0.0130-0.0414 mm),p=0.008;抛光舌槽锁定中位0.0085 mm/年(范围0.005-0.015 mm/年;95%CI,0.0045-0.0138 mm),p=0.032。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为抛光基板配合稳健锁定机制具有最低的背侧损伤和线性磨损。
- 作者认为非抛光基板锁定机制设计的改进可能部分抵消抛光基板的某些优势。
- 作者提出需进一步取回分析确认这些发现,尤其分析当前交联聚乙烯,并需中期和长期研究比较因磨损和骨溶解导致的TKA翻修后再理解此类设计差异是否具有临床相关性。
局限性
- 作者指出该发现应结合相对较小的样本量考虑。
- 作者提出需进一步取回分析确认这些发现,尤其分析当前交联聚乙烯。
- 作者提出需中期和长期研究比较因磨损和骨溶解导致的TKA翻修后再理解此类设计差异是否具有临床相关性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tibial baseplate roughness and polyethylene-insert micromotion resulting from locking-mechanism loosening can lead to polyethylene backside wear in TKAs. However, many retrieval studies examining these variables have evaluated only older TKA implant designs. QUESTIONS: We used implant-retrieval analysis to examine if there were differences in: (1) backside damage scores, (2) backside damage modes, and (3) backside linear wear rates in five TKA implant designs owing to differing baseplate surface roughness and locking mechanisms. Additionally, we examined if (4) patient demographics influence backside damage and wear. METHODS: Five TKA implant models (four modern and one historical design) were selected with different tibial baseplate and/or locking mechanism designs. Six tibial inserts retrieved at the time of revision from each TKA model were matched for time in vivo, age of the patient at TKA revision, BMI, sex, revision number, and revision reason. Each insert backside was analyzed for: (1) visual total damage score and (2) individual visual damage modes, both by two observers and with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.66 (95% CI, 0.39-0.92), and (3) linear wear rate measured by micro-CT. Median primary outcomes were compared among the five designs. For our given sample size among five groups we could detect with 80% power a 10-point difference in damage score and an 0.11-mm per year difference in wear rate. RESULTS: The polished tibial design with a partial peripheral capture locking mechanism and anterior constraint showed a lower total damage score compared with the nonpolished tibial design with only a complete peripheral-rim locking mechanism (median, 12.5; range, 9.5-18.0; 95% CI, 9.58-16.42 versus median, 22.3; range, 15.5-27.0; 95% CI, 17.5-26.5; p = 0.019). The polished baseplate with a tongue-in-groove locking mechanism showed more abrasions than the nonpolished baseplate with a peripheral-rim capture and antirotational island (median, 7.25; range, 0.5-8.0; 95% CI, 2.67-8.99 versus median, 0.75; range, 0-1.5; 95% CI, 0.20-1.47; p = 0.016)). Dimpling was a unique wear mode to the nonpolished baseplates with the peripheral-rim capture and antirotational island (median, 5.5; range, 2.0-9.0; 95% CI, 2.96-8.38) and the peripheral-rim capture alone (median, 9.0; range, 6.0-10.0; 95% CI, 7.29-10.38). Overall, the linear wear rate for polished designs was lower than for nonpolished designs (0.0102 ± 0.0044 mm/year versus 0.0224 ± 0.0119 mm/year; p < 0.001). Two of the polished baseplate designs, the partial peripheral capture with anterior constraint (median, 0.083 mm/year; range, 0.0037-0.0111 mm/year; 95% CI, 0.0050-0.0107 mm versus median, 0.0245 mm/year; range, 0.014-0.046 mm/year; 95% CI, 0.0130-0.0414 mm; p = 0.008) and the tongue-in-groove locking mechanism (median, 0.0085 mm/year; range, 0.005-0.015 mm/year; 95% CI, 0.0045-0.0138 mm; p = 0.032) showed lower polyethylene linear wear rates compared with the nonpolished baseplate design with only a peripheral-rim capture. CONCLUSIONS: Total damage scores and linear wear rates were highest involving the nonpolished design with only a peripheral rim capture. There were no differences among the other TKA designs regarding damage and wear, but this finding should be considered in the setting of a relatively small sample size. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Our study showed that in the complex interplay between baseplate surface finish and locking mechanism design, a polished baseplate with a robust locking mechanism had the lowest backside damage and linear wear. However, improvements in locking mechanism design in nonpolished baseplates potentially may offset some advantages of a polished baseplate. Further retrieval analyses need to be done to confirm such findings, especially analyzing current crosslinked polyethylene. Additionally, we need mid- and long-term studies comparing TKA revisions attributable to wear and osteolysis among implants before understanding if such design differences are clinically relevant.
引用
- Sisko ZW, Teeter MG, Lanting BA, et al. Current Total Knee Designs: Does Baseplate Roughness or Locking Mechanism Design Affect Polyethylene Backside Wear? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28905208. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5494-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。