桶柄状半月板修复与垂直半月板修复在至少2年随访后可获得可比的结果
本研究为队列研究(证据等级3),比较了由内向外垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状半月板撕裂(38例,平均11针)与非移位垂直半月板撕裂(32例,平均7针)的疗效,平均随访3.1年。两组术后患者报告结局评分均较术前显著改善,且两组间SF-12 PCS、MCS、WOMAC、Lysholm、Tegner及满意度评分均无显著差异。急性与慢性桶柄状撕裂的结果评分也无显著差异。作者认为,在可能的情况下支持用多针垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状半月板撕裂。
要点
- 桶柄状半月板撕裂(38例,平均11针)与非移位垂直撕裂(32例,平均7针)修复后平均随访3.1年,两组患者报告结局均显著改善。
- 两组间SF-12 PCS、MCS、WOMAC、Lysholm、Tegner及满意度评分均无显著差异。
- 急性与慢性桶柄状撕裂的结果评分无显著差异;作者认为在可能时支持多针垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状撕裂。
核心结论
- 由内向外技术用多针垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状半月板撕裂可获得改善的结果和低失败率,与非移位垂直半月板撕裂修复后的结果可比。
- 作者认为,本研究结果支持在可能的情况下用多针垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状半月板撕裂。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,证据等级3。
- 纳入接受由内向外修复桶柄状半月板撕裂或非移位垂直半月板撕裂且至少随访2年的患者。
- 排除诊断为半月板根部撕裂、同时行软骨损伤手术或同一半月板既往接受过手术治疗的患者。
- 垂直半月板撕裂组32例(平均7针),桶柄状半月板撕裂组38例(平均11针),平均随访3.1年(范围2-6年)。
- 术前和术后发放主观问卷,包括Lysholm评分、WOMAC、SF-12躯体成分总结(PCS)和心理成分总结(MCS)、Tegner活动量表及患者满意度。
主要发现
- 两组术前结局评分无显著差异。
- 两组患者报告结局评分从术前到术后均显著改善。
- 桶柄状撕裂组 vs 垂直撕裂组:SF-12 PCS 54.0 vs 51.6(P=0.244),无显著差异。
- 桶柄状撕裂组 vs 垂直撕裂组:SF-12 MCS 55.3 vs 52.5(P=0.165),WOMAC 8.1 vs 9.0(P=0.729),Lysholm 84.6 vs 80.8(P=0.276),均无显著差异。
- 桶柄状撕裂组 vs 垂直撕裂组:Tegner 5.5 vs 5.5(P=0.970),患者满意度 7.4 vs 7.7(P=0.570),均无显著差异;急性与慢性桶柄状撕裂的结果评分比较无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,本研究结果支持在可能的情况下用多针垂直褥式缝合修复桶柄状半月板撕裂。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Meniscal tears can lead to significant pain and disability, necessitating surgical treatment. Nondisplaced vertical tears are usually smaller in size and can be repaired in most cases; however, bucket-handle tears are usually larger and displaced, and the repair of these tears can be challenging. Purpose/Hypothesis: The purpose was to report the outcomes after inside-out vertical mattress suture meniscal repair of bucket-handle tears and to compare these outcomes with those of patients who underwent repair of nondisplaced vertical meniscal tears with a minimum of 2 years' follow-up. The hypothesis was that the outcomes of bucket-handle tear repair would be comparable with those of nondisplaced vertical meniscal tear repair. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Patients who underwent inside-out repair of a bucket-handle meniscal tear or a nondisplaced vertical meniscal tear with a minimum 2 years' follow-up were included in this study. Patients were excluded if they had a diagnosis of a meniscal root tear, underwent a concomitant procedure for a chondral injury, or underwent previous surgical treatment of the same meniscus. Subjective questionnaires were administered preoperatively and postoperatively, including the Lysholm score, the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), the Short Form-12 (SF-12) physical component summary (PCS) and mental component summary (MCS), the Tegner activity scale, and patient satisfaction. RESULTS: Thirty-two patients underwent repair for vertical meniscal tears (mean, 7 sutures), while 38 patients underwent repair for bucket-handle meniscal tears (mean, 11 sutures), with a mean follow-up of 3.1 years (range, 2-6 years). There were no significant differences in the preoperative outcome scores between the 2 groups. Significant improvements in patient-reported outcome scores from preoperatively to postoperatively were found in both groups. A direct comparison of the bucket-handle tear group to the vertical tear group did not exhibit significantly different SF-12 PCS scores (54.0 vs 51.6, respectively; P = .244), SF-12 MCS scores (55.3 vs 52.5, respectively; P = .165), WOMAC scores (8.1 vs 9.0, respectively; P = .729), Lysholm scores (84.6 vs 80.8, respectively; P = .276), Tegner scores (5.5 vs 5.5, respectively; P = .970), and patient satisfaction scores (7.4 vs 7.7, respectively; P = .570). Additionally, a comparison of acute and chronic bucket-handle tears demonstrated no significant difference in outcome scores. CONCLUSION: The repair of bucket-handle meniscal tears with multiple vertical mattress sutures using an inside-out technique yielded improved results and low failure rates, comparable with outcomes after repair of nondisplaced vertical meniscal tears. The findings of this study support repairing bucket-handle meniscal tears with multiple vertical mattress sutures when possible.
引用
- Moatshe G, Cinque ME, Godin JA, et al. Comparable Outcomes After Bucket-Handle Meniscal Repair and Vertical Meniscal Repair Can Be Achieved at a Minimum 2 Years' Follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28806092. doi:10.1177/0363546517719244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。