文献速递运动医学关节外科

我们应如何固定移植的半月板?一项Meta分析

How Should We Secure Our Transplanted Meniscus? A Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2017-08-17

该Meta分析纳入38项研究共1637例半月板同种异体移植(MAT),评估总体结局并比较根部分软组织缝合固定与骨固定的差异。MAT患者Lysholm评分和疼痛显著改善,撕裂率9%、失败率12.6%;两种固定技术在撕裂率、失败率、Lysholm评分、VAS评分和半月板挤出方面均无显著差异。

要点

  • MAT患者Lysholm评分从57.8分改善至81.4分(SMD 1.5,P<.001),VAS疼痛评分从56分降至21分(SMD 1.8,P<.001)。
  • 总体队列半月板撕裂率为9%,失败率为12.6%。
  • 软组织缝合固定组与骨固定组在撕裂率、失败率、Lysholm评分、VAS评分和半月板挤出方面均无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 该Meta分析显示MAT患者临床结局显著改善,撕裂率和失败率低;数据未显示软组织缝合固定与骨固定在根部分固定上存在差异,提示根部分固定技术对临床结局、疼痛缓解、挤出或MAT寿命可能无明显影响;需进一步前瞻性试验。

研究设计与样本

  • Meta分析,系统评价当前所有报告MAT患者结局的研究,纳入38项研究共1637例MAT(81%为男性),平均年龄34岁(范围20-48岁),平均随访60个月(范围25-168个月)。

主要发现

  • 总体队列Lysholm评分从57.8分改善至81.4分(SMD 1.5,P<.001),VAS疼痛评分从56分降至21分(SMD 1.8,P<.001)。
  • 总体队列撕裂率为9%,失败率为12.6%。
  • 软组织缝合固定组(485例MAT)与骨固定组(489例MAT)的撕裂率分别为13.4% vs 14.9%,失败率分别为17.6% vs 18.8%,均无显著差异。
  • 软组织缝合固定组Lysholm评分从52.3分改善至82.4分(SMD 2.0),骨固定组从60.7分改善至82.9分(SMD 1.7);软组织缝合固定组VAS评分从65分降至18分(SMD 2.6),骨固定组从63分降至13分(SMD 3.1),均P<.001。
  • 半月板挤出加权平均百分比在软组织缝合固定组为40.2%,骨固定组为43.1%,两组相似。

局限性

  • 需进一步前瞻性试验。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Meniscal allograft transplant (MAT) is a salvage procedure for young patients with symptomatic meniscal deficiency. Although many studies report good outcomes, MAT remains controversial, and an optimal fixation technique for the meniscus roots is debated. PURPOSE: To assess the overall outcome of MAT and compare the results of different meniscal root fixation techniques. STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analysis. METHODS: Following specific guidelines, we systematically evaluated all current literature for studies reporting on the outcomes of patients who underwent MAT. Using random effect models of proportions, we determined the tear and failure rates. Standardized mean differences (SMDs) were calculated to determine the improvement in clinical outcomes and pain level. Data were then stratified by root fixation method into 2 groups: fixation that preserved the graft's root insertions on the allograft bone (bone fixation group) and suture fixation of the root soft tissue without the allograft bone (soft tissue suture group). RESULTS: A total of 38 studies (1637 MATs, 81% men) involving subjects with a mean age of 34 years (range, 20-48 years) and a mean follow-up of 60 months (range, 25-168 months) met inclusion criteria. This overall cohort had significant improvements in Lysholm scores (from 57.8 to 81.4 points; SMD 1.5, P < .001) and pain level (visual analog scale [VAS], from 56 to 21 points; SMD 1.8, P < .001). The cohort had a tear rate of 9% and a failure rate of 12.6%. No significant differences were found between the soft tissue suture (485 MATs) and bone fixation (489 MATs) groups in terms of meniscal allograft tear rates (13.4% vs 14.9%), failure rates (17.6% vs 18.8%), Lysholm scores (from 52.3 to 82.4, SMD 2.0, and from 60.7 to 82.9, SMD 1.7; respectively), and VAS scores (from 65 points to 18 points, SMD 2.6, and from 63 points to 13 points, SMD 3.1; both P < .001). Meniscal extrusion was similar, with a weighted mean percentage of extrusion of 40.2% in the soft tissue suture group and 43.1% in the bone fixation group. CONCLUSION: This meta-analysis demonstrated significant improvements in clinical outcomes for MAT patients with low tear and failure rates. The data do not demonstrate a difference between soft tissue suture and bone fixation for MAT root fixation. This suggests that the technique of root fixation may not have an appreciable influence on clinical outcome, pain reduction, extrusion, or MAT longevity. Further prospective trials are needed.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jauregui JJ, Wu ZD, Meredith S, et al. How Should We Secure Our Transplanted Meniscus? A Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28816515. doi:10.1177/0363546517720183

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。