高屈曲固定平台与高屈曲活动平台全膝关节置换术的比较——一项前瞻性随机研究
本研究纳入92例(184膝)同日行双侧全膝关节置换术的患者,前瞻性随机比较高屈曲固定平台与高屈曲活动平台假体。随访12年时两组在膝关节评分、功能评分、WOMAC评分、UCLA活动评分及影像学参数上均无显著差异,假体生存率分别为98%和99%。结论认为活动平台在高屈曲全膝关节置换术中未显示额外获益,需更长期随访验证。
要点
- 随访12年时两组膝关节评分(93 vs 92分,P=0.531)、功能评分(80 vs 80分,P=1.000)无显著差异。
- 两组WOMAC评分(14 vs 15分,P=0.972)和UCLA活动评分(6 vs 6分,P=1.000)无显著差异。
- 假体生存率固定平台组98%(95%CI 93-100),活动平台组99%(95%CI 94-100)。
核心结论
- 高屈曲活动平台全膝关节置换术在疼痛、功能、影像学及CT扫描结果和假体生存率方面未显示优于高屈曲固定平台全膝关节置换术的获益。
- 需要更长期随访以证明高屈曲活动平台全膝关节置换术相对于高屈曲固定平台全膝关节置换术的获益。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性随机研究,纳入92例(184膝)同日行双侧全膝关节置换术的患者。
- 其中男17例,女75例;行指数置换术时平均年龄61.5±8.3岁(范围52-65岁)。
- 平均体重指数26.2±3.3 kg/m²(范围23-34 kg/m²)。
- 平均随访11.2年(范围10-12年)。
主要发现
- 随访12年时膝关节协会膝关节评分固定平台组93分 vs 活动平台组92分(P=0.531),无显著差异。
- 膝关节协会功能评分固定平台组80分 vs 活动平台组80分(P=1.000),无显著差异。
- WOMAC评分固定平台组14分 vs 活动平台组15分(P=0.972),无显著差异。
- UCLA活动评分固定平台组6分 vs 活动平台组6分(P=1.000),无显著差异。
- 两组任何影像学及CT扫描参数均无差异。
局限性
- 原文指出需要更长期随访以证明高屈曲活动平台全膝关节置换术相对于高屈曲固定平台全膝关节置换术的获益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is none, to our knowledge, about comparison of high-flexion fixed-bearing and high-flexion mobile-bearing total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) in the same patients. The purpose of this study was to determine whether clinical results; radiographic and computed tomographic scan results; and the survival rate of a high-flexion mobile-bearing TKA is better than that of a high-flexion fixed-bearing TKA. METHODS: The present study consisted of 92 patients (184 knees) who underwent same-day bilateral TKA. Of those, 17 were men and 75 were women. The mean age at the time of index arthroplasty was 61.5 ± 8.3 years (range 52-65 years). The mean body mass index was 26.2 ± 3.3 kg/m2 (range 23-34 kg/m2). The mean follow-up was 11.2 years (range 10-12 years). RESULTS: The Knee Society knee scores (93 vs 92 points; P = .531) and function scores (80 vs 80 points; P = 1.000), WOMAC scores (14 vs 15 points; P = .972), and UCLA activity scores (6 vs 6 points; P = 1.000) were not different between the 2 groups at 12 years follow-up. There were no differences in any radiographic and CT scan parameters between the 2 groups. Kaplan-Meier survivorship of the TKA component was 98% (95% confidence interval, 93-100) in the high-flexion fixed-bearing TKA group and 99% (95% confidence interval, 94-100) in the high-flexion mobile-bearing TKA group 12 years after the operation. CONCLUSION: We found no benefit to mobile-bearing TKA in terms of pain, function, radiographic and CT scan results, and survivorship. Longer-term follow-up is necessary to prove the benefit of the high-flexion mobile-bearing TKA over the high-flexion fixed-bearing TKA.
引用
- Kim YH, Park JW, Kim JS, et al. Comparison of High-Flexion Fixed-Bearing and High-Flexion Mobile-Bearing Total Knee Arthroplasties-A Prospective Randomized Study. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28844767. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。