文献速递脊柱外科

全国范围内初次椎间盘切除术后翻修椎间盘切除术的发生率如何

What is the Rate of Revision Discectomies After Primary Discectomy on a National Scale?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2017-08-28

研究利用Medicare 5%全国样本行政数据库与Humana公司大型全国数据库,对7520例因椎间盘移位行腰椎椎间盘切除术且随访至少5年的患者进行生存分析,评估翻修手术率。结果显示7年时翻修手术率分别为5.6%和6.2%,所有队列生存率均大于93%,年龄小于65岁患者生存率较低,不同地理区域和支付类型间无差异。

要点

  • 7年翻修椎间盘切除术率:HORTHO数据库5.6%(147例),SAF5数据库6.2%(305例)。
  • 所有队列7年生存率均大于93%(95%CI 91%-98%)。
  • 年龄小于65岁患者生存率低于65岁及以上患者(93% vs 95%,p=0.02)。

核心结论

  • 研究显示以翻修椎间盘切除术为终点的初次腰椎椎间盘切除术后累积生存率。
  • 作者希望这些数据能让医生为各年龄段患者提供关于初次手术后5至7年内翻修手术风险的准确建议,以促进脊柱手术中的共享决策。
  • 这些数据也将帮助公共政策制定者和责任医疗组织准确分配稀缺资源给有症状的腰椎间盘突出患者。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究使用Medicare 5%全国样本行政数据库(SAF5)和Humana公司大型全国数据库(HORTHO)进行生存分析。
  • 共纳入7520例因椎间盘移位行腰椎椎间盘切除术且随访至少5年的患者,其中HORTHO数据库2613例,SAF5数据库4907例。
  • 通过相关ICD-9编码和现行 procedural 术语(CPT)编码识别患者,包括ICD-9 72210(腰椎间盘移位)诊断椎间盘突出。
  • 翻修手术率分别针对65岁及以上和65岁以下患者以及每个数据库进行计算,并按美国四个不同地理区域分析。
  • 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。

主要发现

  • HORTHO数据库2613例患者中147例(5.6%;95%CI 1.8%-9.2%)在初次椎间盘切除术后7年时接受翻修手术,SAF5数据库4907例患者中305例(6.2%;95%CI 3.5%-8.9%)接受翻修手术。
  • 生存分析显示所有队列初次椎间盘切除术后至7年生存率均大于93%(95%CI 91%-98%)。
  • 年龄小于65岁患者生存率较低(93% [95%CI 87%-99%,1016/1091] vs 95% [95%CI 90%-100%,1450/1522],p=0.02)。
  • 当纳入非椎间盘切除的腰椎手术时,年龄小于65岁患者生存率仍较低(83% [95%CI 76%-89%,902/1091] vs 87% [95%CI 82%-92%,1324/1522],p=0.02)。
  • 7年时不同地理区域翻修椎间盘切除术率无差异(p=0.41),非椎间盘切除的额外腰椎手术率也无差异(p=0.68)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 7年翻修椎间盘切除术率:HORTHO数据库5.6%(95%CI 1.8%-9.2%),SAF5数据库6.2%(95%CI 3.5%-8.9%)。
  • 7年生存率大于93%(95%CI 91%-98%)适用于所有队列。
  • 年龄小于65岁患者生存率93%(95%CI 87%-99%)低于65岁及以上患者95%(95%CI 90%-100%),p=0.02。
  • 纳入非椎间盘切除腰椎手术时,年龄小于65岁患者生存率83%(95%CI 76%-89%)低于65岁及以上患者87%(95%CI 82%-92%),p=0.02。

临床怎么用

  • 作者希望这些数据能让医生为各年龄段患者提供关于初次手术后5至7年内翻修手术风险的准确建议,以促进脊柱手术中的共享决策。
  • 这些数据也将帮助公共政策制定者和责任医疗组织准确分配稀缺资源给有症状的腰椎间盘突出患者。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Lumbar discectomy has been shown to be clinically beneficial in numerous studies for appropriately selected patients. Some patients, however, undergo revision discectomy, with previously reported estimates of revisions ranging from 5.1% to 7.9%. No study to date has been able to precisely quantify the rate of revision surgery over numerous years on a national scale. QUESTIONS/PURPOSE: We performed a survival analysis for lumbar discectomy on a national scale using a life-table analysis to answer the following questions: (1) What is the rate of revision discectomy on a national scale over 5 to 7 years for patients undergoing primary discectomy alone? (2) Are there differences in revision discectomy rates based on age of patient, region of the country, or the payer type? METHODS: The Medicare 5% National Sample Administrative Database (SAF5) and a large national database from Humana Inc (HORTHO) were used to catalog the number of patients undergoing a lumbar discectomy. Both of these databases have been cited in numerous peer-reviewed publications during the previous 5 years and routinely are audited by PearlDiver Inc. We identified patients using relevant ICD-9 codes and Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes, including ICD-9 72210 (lumbar disc displacement) for disc herniation. We used appropriate CPT codes to identify patients who had a lumbar discectomy. We analyzed patients undergoing additional surgery including those who had repeat discectomy (CPT-63042: laminotomy, reexploration single interspace, lumbar) and patients who had additional more-extensive decompressive procedures with or without fusion after their primary procedure. Revision surgery rates were calculated for patients 65 years and older and those younger than 65 years and for each database (Humana Inc and Medicare). Patients from the two databases also were analyzed based on four distinct geographic regions in the United States where their surgery occurred. There were a total of 7520 patients who underwent a lumbar discectomy for an intervertebral disc displacement with at least 5 years of followup in the HORTHO and SAF5 databases. We used cumulative incidence of revision surgery to estimate the survivorship of these patients. RESULTS: In the HORTHO (2613 patients) and SAF5 (4907 patients) databases, 147 patients (5.6%; 95% CI, 1.8%-9.2%) and 305 patients (6.2%; 95% CI, 3.5%-8.9%) had revision surgery at 7 years after the index discectomy respectively. Survival analysis showed survival rates greater than 93% (95% CI, 91%-98%) for all of the cohorts for a primary discectomy up to 7 years after the surgery. The survivorship was lower for patients younger than 65 years (93% [95% CI, 87%-99%, 1016 of 1091] versus 95% [95% CI, 90%-100%, 1450 of 1522], p = 0.02). When nondiscectomy lumbar surgeries were included, the survivorship of patients younger than 65 years remained lower (83% [95% CI, 76%-89%, 902 of 1091] versus 87% [95% CI, 82%-92%, 1324 of 1522], p = 0.02). There was no difference in revision discectomy rates across geographic regions (p = 0.41) at 7 years. Similarly, there was no difference in additional nondiscectomy lumbar surgery rates (p = 0.68) across geographic regions at 7 years. There was no difference in survivorship rates between patients covered by Medicare (94% [95% CI, 91%-97%], 4602 of 4907) versus Humana Inc (94% [95% CI, 90%-98%], 2466 of 2613) (p = 0.31). CONCLUSIONS: Our study shows rates of cumulative survival after an index lumbar discectomy with revision discectomy as the endpoint. We hope these data allow physicians to offer accurate advice to patients regarding the risk of revision surgery for patients of all ages during 5 to 7 years after their index procedure to enhance shared decision making in spinal surgery. These data also will help public policymakers and accountable care organizations accurately allocate scarce resources to patients with symptomatic lumbar disc herniation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Virk SS, Diwan A, Phillips FM, et al. What is the Rate of Revision Discectomies After Primary Discectomy on a National Scale? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28849429. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5467-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。