严重失血性休克导致小鼠模型骨折愈合延迟及骨痂强度下降
本研究在小鼠股骨截骨外固定模型中分析严重失血性休克对骨折愈合的影响,发现联合创伤组在术后2周时骨密度降低、骨痂占骨量比例增加、最大弯曲力矩下降,但2周后组间无差异,作者认为失血性休克延缓骨折愈合早期阶段。
要点
- 联合创伤组术后2周骨密度低于单纯骨折组(1.17 g/cm³ vs 1.22 g/cm³,p=0.002)。
- 联合创伤组术后2周最大弯曲力矩低于单纯骨折组(7.10 Nmm vs 11.25 Nmm,p=0.026)。
- 两组在术后超过2周后未观察到差异,作者结论为失血性休克延缓骨折愈合早期阶段。
核心结论
- 作者结论:在该小鼠骨折在体模型中,失血性休克延缓骨折愈合过程的早期阶段。
研究设计与样本
- 研究将雄性C57BL/6NCrl小鼠随机分为五组、四个时间点(每组每时间点5至10只),仅分析右侧股骨。
- 创伤失血组经导管接受压力控制失血性休克,截骨组行右股骨截骨并植入外固定架,联合创伤组接受失血性休克加截骨外固定,假手术组置入导管和外固定架但无失血或截骨,对照组无干预。
- 术后2、3、4或6周处死动物,进行大体、X线、µCT及三点弯曲试验分析,统计显著性设为概率小于0.05,采用Mann-Whitney U检验或Kruskal-Wallis检验。
主要发现
- 截骨组术后2周截骨间隙稳定并桥接,而联合创伤组部分骨未发生稳定桥接,但组间未观察到差异。
- µCT显示联合创伤组术后2周骨密度(含骨痂)低于截骨组:联合创伤组1.17 g/cm³(IQR 0.04 g/cm³) vs 截骨组1.22 g/cm³(IQR 0.04 g/cm³),p=0.002,中位数差-0.048(95%CI -0.073至-0.029)。
- 联合创伤组术后2周骨痂占骨量体积比例高于截骨组:联合创伤组44.16%(IQR 8.66%) vs 截骨组36.73%(IQR 4.39%),p=0.015,中位数差7.634(95%CI 2.018至10.577)。
- 三点弯曲试验显示联合创伤组术后2周最大弯曲力矩低于截骨组:联合创伤组7.10 Nmm(IQR 11.25 Nmm) vs 截骨组11.25 Nmm(IQR 5.70 Nmm),p=0.026,中位数差-5.043(95%CI -10.867至-0.74)。
- 联合创伤组与截骨组在术后超过2周后未观察到差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,患者发生严重失血性休克可能导致初期骨折愈合延迟,需要特别关注。
- 作者计划开展前瞻性观察性临床研究,分析严重失血后患者是否发生骨折愈合延迟。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Multiple trauma is frequently associated with hemorrhagic shock and fractures of the extremities. Clinically, the rate of impaired fracture healing (delayed healing and nonunion) seems to be increased in patients with multiple injuries compared with patients with isolated fractures. As the underlying pathogenesis remains poorly understood, we aimed to analyze the biomechanical properties during fracture healing in a murine model. QUESTIONS: The aim of this study was to determine whether fracture healing after severe hemorrhagic shock results in (1) delayed bridging as determined by macroscopic and radiographic assessment, (2) altered conditions of callus components as determined by µCT, and (3) decreased maximum bending moment measured by a three-point-bending test compared with ordinary fracture healing. METHODS: Male C57BL/6NCrl mice were randomly assigned to five groups and four different times (five to 10 mice per group and time). Only the right femur from each mouse was used for analysis: the trauma hemorrhage (TH) group received a pressure-controlled hemorrhagic shock via catheter; the osteotomy (Fx) group underwent osteotomy and implantation of an external fixator on the right femur; the combined trauma (THFx) group received hemorrhagic shock and an external fixator with osteotomy; the sham group underwent implantation of a catheter and external fixator but had no blood loss or osteotomy, and the control group underwent no interventions. After 2, 3, 4, or 6 weeks, five to 10 animals of each group were sacrificed. Bones were analyzed macroscopically and via radiographs, µCT, and three-point-bending test. Statistical significance was set at a probability less than 0.05. Comparisons were performed using the Mann-Whitney U or the Kruskal-Wallis test. RESULTS: In the Fx group, the osteotomy gap was stable and bridged after 2 weeks in contrast to some bones in the THFx group where stable bridging did not occur. No difference was observed between the groups. µCT analysis showed reduced density of bone including callus (THFx: 1.17 g/cm3; interquartile range [IQR], 0.04 g/cm3; Fx: 1.22 g/cm3; IQR, 0.04 g/cm3; p = 0.002; difference of medians [DM], -0.048; 95% CI, -0.073 to -0.029) and increased share of callus per volume of bone mass (%) after 2 weeks in the THFx group compared with the Fx group (THFx: 44.16%; IQR, 8.66%; Fx: 36.73%; IQR, 4.39%; p = 0.015; DM, 7.634; 95% CI, 2.018-10.577). The three-point-bending test established a decreased maximum bending moment in the THFx group compared with the Fx group 2 weeks after surgery (THFx: 7.10 Nmm; IQR, 11.25 Nmm; Fx: 11.25 Nmm; IQR, 5.70 Nmm; p = 0.026; DM, -5.043; 95% CI, -10.867 to -0.74). No differences were observed between the THFx and Fx groups after more than 2 weeks. CONCLUSION: In this in vivo mouse fracture model, we conclude that hemorrhagic shock retards fracture healing during the early phase of the facture healing process. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: A severe hemorrhagic shock in patients could result in initial delayed fracture healing and needs special attention. We plan to conduct a prospective, observational clinical research study to analyze if delayed fracture healing occurs in patients after severe blood loss.
引用
- Bundkirchen K, Macke C, Reifenrath J, et al. Severe Hemorrhagic Shock Leads to a Delayed Fracture Healing and Decreased Bone Callus Strength in a Mouse Model. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28795328. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5473-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。