儿童肱骨近端肿瘤切除后肱骨锁骨重建术是否具有价值
该多中心研究评估8例8至18岁儿童肱骨近端恶性肿瘤切除后采用肱骨锁骨重建术的效果,平均随访40个月。所有患者均无肿瘤复发,但无菌性近端假关节形成为主要并发症(5例),MSTS评分中位23/30,TESS中位82%。作者认为该技术可获得局部肿瘤控制并提供稳定、无痛、有功能的生物学重建,但需要更长随访。
要点
- 8例儿童肱骨近端恶性肿瘤切除后行肱骨锁骨重建术,均无肿瘤复发。
- 无菌性近端假关节形成为主要并发症,发生于5例患者。
- MSTS评分中位23/30,TESS评分中位82%,7例中3例对美观不满意。
核心结论
- 肱骨锁骨重建术在儿童肱骨近端肿瘤切除重建后实现了肿瘤局部控制。
- 尽管愈合时间约2年且部分患者需其他移植物增强,该技术最终提供牢固、无痛、生物学稳定重建并形成活动的肩锁关节和总体良好的功能。
- 近端连接处不愈合是该技术的主要并发症。
- 作者认为该技术可能是选择性儿童肱骨近端肉瘤患者可考虑的有用重建选项,但无法直接与其他重建选项比较且需要更长随访。
研究设计与样本
- 四所大学医院于2006年6月至2014年2月间对8例8至18岁儿童实施肱骨锁骨重建术。
- 该期间该方法的普遍指征包括所有8岁以上儿童肱骨近端恶性肿瘤的重建。
- 所有患者平均随访40个月(范围25-86个月),1例患者在2年随访前失访。
- 证据等级为Level IV,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 所有患者均无肿瘤复发,1例患者在2年随访前死于肺转移。
- 7例患者中近端和远端骨连接分别在10个月前无额外手术情况下达到2例和6例。
- 发生14例局部并发症导致9次翻修手术,主要并发症为无菌性近端假关节形成(5例患者)。
- 其他并发症包括1例近端连接处骨折、1例锁骨骨折合并锁骨骨溶解、1例远端连接处骨折、1例腓骨自体移植物皮瓣坏死、1例肩锁关节骨化、1例远端假关节形成合并该远端连接处骨折。
- MSTS评分中位23/30(范围11-27),TESS评分中位82%(范围75%-92%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 骨连接定义为10个月前骨愈合,经正侧位X线片上截骨处消失评估。
- 肿瘤切除在所有患者中移除肩袖肌肉,5例移除盂肱关节,3例移除三角肌。
- 切除后骨缺损中位长度20 cm(范围7-25 cm),锁骨旋转后减少至9 cm(范围0-17 cm)或总肱骨长度的27%(范围0%-64%)。
- 必要时采用直接骨接合(1例)、诱导膜技术(1例)或血管化腓骨自体移植(6例)完成锁骨旋转后的缺损。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
- 作者认为该技术可能是选择性儿童肱骨近端肉瘤患者可考虑的有用重建选项。
局限性
- 作者指出无法将该技术与其他重建选项直接比较,且需要更长随访。
- 1例患者在2年随访前失访。
- 7例患者中3例报告对美观不满意。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There are several options for reconstruction of proximal humerus resections after wide resection for malignant tumors in children. The clavicula pro humero technique is a biologic option that has been used in the past, but there are only scant case reports and small series that comment on the results of the procedure. Because the longevity of children mandates a reconstruction with potential longevity not likely to be achieved by other techniques, the clavicula pro humero technique may be a potential option in selected patients. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How successful is the clavicula pro humero procedure in achieving local tumor control? (2) What is the frequency of nonunion? (3) What are the complications of the procedure? (4) What scores do patients achieve (on the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS) and the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score (TESS) after this procedure? METHODS: Four university hospitals performed the clavicula pro humero technique in eight children aged 8 to 18 years between June 2006 and February 2014. During that period, general indications for this approach included all reconstructions of the proximal humerus for malignant tumors in children older than 8 years. All patients were followed for a mean of 40 months (range, 25-86 months); one patient was lost to followup before 2 years. The tumor resections removed the rotator cuff muscles in all patients, glenohumeral joint in five, and deltoid muscle in three. The median length of the bone defect after resection was 20 cm (range, 7-25 cm). It was reduced to 9 cm (range, 0-17 cm) or 27% (range, 0%-64%) of the total humerus length after clavicular rotation. Direct osteosynthesis (one patient), induced membrane technique (one patient), or vascularized fibular autograft (six patients) was used to complete the defect after rotation of the clavicle if necessary. Presence of union (defined as bone healing before 10 months, as assessed by disappearance of the osteotomy on AP and lateral view radiographs), and complications were determined by chart review performed by a surgeon not involved in patient care. Function assessed by the MSTS and the TESS scores were determined by the patients with their families. RESULTS: None of the patients had tumor recurrence. One patient died of pulmonary metastases before the 2-year followup. Proximal and distal bone unions were achieved before 10 months without an additional surgical procedure in two and six of seven patients, respectively. Fourteen local complications occurred resulting in nine revision operations. The main complication was aseptic proximal pseudarthrosis (five patients); other complications included one proximal junction fracture, one clavicle fracture complicated by clavicle osteolysis, one distal junction fracture, one necrosis of the skin paddle of the fibular autograft, one glenoclavicular ossification, and one distal pseudarthrosis complicated by a fracture of this distal junction. Function, as assessed by the MSTS score, was a median of 23 of 30 (range, 11-27). The median TESS score was 82% (range, 75%-92%). Shoulder ROM (median; range) in abduction, front elevation, and external and internal rotations were 70°(30°-90°), 75°(30°-85°), 10°(0°-20°), and 80°(80°-100°), respectively. Three of the seven patients reported dissatisfaction with the cosmetic appearance. CONCLUSIONS: The clavicula pro humero technique achieved oncologic local control after resection and reconstruction of proximal humerus tumors in children. Although union times are approximately 2 years and some patients underwent augmentation with other grafts, it eventually provides a solid, painless, biologic, and stable reconstruction and creates a mobile acromioclavicular joint and generally good function. Nonunion of the proximal junction is the main complication of this technique. We cannot directly compare this technique with other reconstruction options, and longer followup is needed, but this may be a useful reconstruction option to consider in select pediatric patients with sarcomas of the proximal humerus. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Barbier D, De Billy B, Gicquel P, et al. Is the Clavicula Pro Humero Technique of Value for Reconstruction After Resection of the Proximal Humerus in Children? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28699149. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5438-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。