混合手术治疗双节段颈椎间盘退变时假体与混合策略的考量
本研究利用已验证的非线性有限元模型,在C4-C6双节段混合手术中分析Prodisc-C、PCM和DCI三种假体对颈椎生物力学的影响,比较ACDF/ACDR与ACDR/ACDF两种策略。结果显示每种假体各有优缺点,DCI在伸展时邻节段代偿更明显,Prodisc-C的性能易受混合策略影响;作者认为若仅有组合结构假体可用,应谨慎评估混合策略并推荐ACDF/ACDR构型以避免加速邻节段退变。
要点
- 前屈时邻节段活动度大于完整脊柱,PCM在ACDF/ACDR组最大增加80%。
- 伸展时PCM两种策略邻节段活动度与完整脊柱相似(变化<10%),DCI则增加14%至32%。
- DCI组下邻节段小关节应力显著增加,PCM和Prodisc-C仅在ACDR/ACDF组增加。
核心结论
- 每种假体各有优缺点;伸展时DCI较Prodisc-C和PCM在邻节段活动度、力矩和小关节应力方面表现出更多代偿。
- Prodisc-C的生物力学性能易受混合策略影响;若双节段混合手术(C4-C6)仅有组合结构假体可用,应谨慎评估混合策略,并推荐ACDF/ACDR构型以避免加速邻节段退变。
研究设计与样本
- 采用已验证的非线性有限元模型进行生物力学分析,证据等级为5。
- 在C4-C6混合手术的前屈和伸展工况下分析Prodisc-C、PCM和DCI三种假体。
- 比较两种混合手术构型:C4-C5行颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术、C5-C6行颈椎前路椎间盘置换术(ACDF/ACDR),以及ACDR/ACDF。
主要发现
- 前屈时邻节段活动度大于完整脊柱,PCM在ACDF/ACDR组最大增加80%。
- 伸展时PCM两种混合策略的邻节段活动度与完整脊柱相似(变化<10%),而DCI增加14%至32%。
- DCI的应变能储存能力与正常椎间盘相似。
- 下邻节段小关节应力在DCI两组均显著增加,而PCM和Prodisc-C仅在ACDR/ACDF组增加。
- 所有假体均在置换节段软骨上产生过载,Prodisc-C和PCM芯的应力高于超高分子量聚乙烯的屈服应力。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,若双节段混合手术(C4-C6)仅有组合结构假体可用,应谨慎评估混合策略,并推荐ACDF/ACDR构型以避免加速邻节段退变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Biomechanical analysis using a validated nonlinear finite element (FE) model. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to combine the strategy of two-level hybrid surgery (HS) to explore how prostheses affect cervical biomechanics. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Few FE studies have explored differences in biomechanical behavior between combined and stand-alone structured prostheses with HS. No FE studies have considered whether the prosthesis type and hybrid strategy influence two-level HS. METHODS: Three prostheses-Prodisc-C, PCM, and DCI-were analyzed in flexion and extension during HS at C4-C6. There were two HS constructs: anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) conducted at the C4-C5 levels and anterior cervical disc replacement (ACDR) conducted at C5-C6 levels (ACDF/ACDR); ACDR/ACDF. RESULTS: Flexion motion at adjacent levels was greater than that of intact spine. A maximum increase of 80% was observed with PCM in the ACDF/ACDR group. Extension motion at adjacent levels for both hybrid strategies with PCM, however, was similar to that of intact spine (<10% change), whereas it increased by 14% to 32% with DCI. The strain energy-storing capability with DCI tended to be similar to that of normal discs. Facet stress at the infra-adjacent level, however, significantly increased with DCI in both groups, whereas it increased with PCM and Prodisc-C only in the ACDR/ACDF group. All prostheses produced overloads on cartilage at the arthroplasty level. Prodisc-C and PCM cores showed stress above the yield stress of ultrahigh-molecular-weight polyethylene. CONCLUSION: Each prosthesis had advantages and disadvantages. In extension, DCI (vs. Prodisc-C and PCM) exhibited more compensation at adjacent levels in terms of motion, moments, and facet stress. The biomechanical performance of Prodisc-C was easily affected by the hybrid strategy. Thus, if only a combined-structure prosthesis is available for two-level HS (C4-C6 level), the hybrid strategy should be carefully evaluated and the ACDF/ACDR construct is recommended to avoid accelerating degeneration of adjacent segments. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 5.
引用
- Li Y, Fogel GR, Liao Z, et al. Prosthesis and Hybrid Strategy Consideration for Treating Two-level Cervical Disc Degeneration in Hybrid Surgery. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2018. PMID: 28678112. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000002316
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。