髋部骨折手术治疗后行髋关节置换术:髓内与髓外固定装置的比较
本研究纳入2000至2010年间111例因股骨转子间骨折术后失败而转为髋关节置换的患者,其中70例原使用髓外固定装置(EFD),41例使用髓内髋螺钉(IMHS)。结果显示两组住院时间、手术时间、并发症总发生率及5年假体生存率均相似,但IMHS组术中股骨骨折风险更高(12% vs 1%,P = .02)。
要点
- 转子间骨折术后转为髋关节置换的短期假体生存率优良,5年无翻修生存率EFD组95%、IMHS组94%(P = 1.0)。
- IMHS组术中股骨骨折发生率显著高于EFD组(12% vs 1%,P = .02)。
- 两组总体并发症发生率相似(EFD组21% vs IMHS组27%,P = .51)。
核心结论
- 无论原始骨折固定方式如何,转子间骨折手术治疗后转为髋关节置换的短期假体生存率均优良。
- 若能尽量减少早期并发症(尤其是假体周围骨折),成功结局的可能性较高。
- 与EFD相比,从IMHS转为髋关节置换时术中股骨骨折的风险更高。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2000年至2010年间111例因股骨转子间骨折术后失败而转为髋关节置换的患者。
- 70髋原使用髓外固定装置(EFD),41髋原使用髓内髋螺钉(IMHS)。
主要发现
- 住院时间和手术时间两组相似:EFD组6天、206分钟 vs IMHS组6天、208分钟(P > .7)。
- 末次临床随访时Trendelenburg步态两组相似:EFD组37% vs IMHS组38%。
- 5年无翻修生存率:EFD组95% vs IMHS组94%(P = 1.0)。
- 总体并发症发生率两组相似:EFD组21% vs IMHS组27%(P = .51)。
- 最常见并发症:EFD组为晚期假体周围骨折(6% vs IMHS组0%,P = .29);IMHS组为术中股骨骨折(12% vs EFD组1%,P = .02)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although use of intramedullary hip screws (IMHS) for intertrochanteric (IT) hip fractures has become more common, limited data have suggested difficulties in conversion to hip arthroplasty. The present study investigates whether conversion of failed IT fracture fixation with an intramedullary vs extramedullary device leads to different rates or types of complications or decreased arthroplasty survivorship. METHODS: One hundred eleven patients were converted to hip arthroplasty after previous surgical treatment of an IT fracture from 2000 to 2010. Seventy hips had been treated with an extramedullary fixation device (EFD) and 41 with an IMHS. RESULTS: Length of hospital stay and operative times were similar (6 days and 206 minutes for EFD vs 6 days and 208 minutes for IMHS; P > .7). The presence of a Trendelenburg gait at last clinical follow-up was similar between groups (37% in EFD group and 38% in IMHS group). Five-year survivorship free of revision was 95% in the EFD group and 94% in the IMHS group (P = 1.0). The overall complication rate was similar (21% for EFD vs 27% for IMHS; P = .51) between groups. The most common complication was late periprosthetic fracture in the EFD patients (6% vs 0% in IMHS; P = .29) and intraoperative femoral fracture in the IMHS patients (12% vs 1% in EFD; P = .02). CONCLUSION: The short-term survivorship of conversion hip arthroplasty after surgical treatment of an IT fracture is excellent regardless of original fracture fixation method. If early complications, particularly periprosthetic fractures, can be minimized, the likelihood of a successful outcome is high. The risk of intraoperative femoral fracture was greater during conversion from an IMHS compared to an EFD.
引用
- Yuan BJ, Abdel MP, Cross WW, et al. Hip Arthroplasty After Surgical Treatment of Intertrochanteric Hip Fractures. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28712800. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.06.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。