文献速递运动医学关节外科

移植物类型是否影响前交叉韧带翻修重建的结局?32项研究的Meta分析

Does the type of graft affect the outcome of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction? a meta-analysis of 32 studies.
PubMed 文献 · Bone Joint J · 2017-01-01

该Meta分析纳入32项研究,比较自体移植物与同种异体移植物在翻修前交叉韧带重建中的结局。自体移植物在松弛度(KT-1000/2000测量)及并发症和再手术率方面优于同种异体移植物,但同种异体移植物的平均Lysholm和Tegner活动评分更好;排除辐照同种异体移植物后,两者结局不再有差异。

要点

  • 自体移植物翻修重建后的松弛度及并发症和再手术率优于同种异体移植物。
  • 同种异体移植物的平均Lysholm和Tegner活动评分优于自体移植物。
  • 排除辐照同种异体移植物后,自体与同种异体移植物的结局不再有差异。

核心结论

  • 自体移植物在翻修前交叉韧带重建中结局优于同种异体移植物,术后松弛度及并发症和再手术率更低。
  • 排除辐照同种异体移植物后,自体移植物与同种异体移植物的结局相似。
  • 翻修前交叉韧带重建的移植物选择应个体化,考虑术者偏好技术、是否需要联合重建、既往移植物类型、隧道是否扩大及同种异体移植物可得性等因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 检索Medline和Pubmed,检索词为「Anterior Cruciate Ligament」和「ACL」分别与「revision」「re-operation」「failure」组合。
  • 仅纳入报告至少两年随访结局的研究,由两位作者审阅文献,结局分为自体移植物和同种异体移植物,自体移植物再分为腘绳肌腱(HS)和骨-髌腱-骨(BPTB)。
  • 共32项研究符合纳入标准;5项研究使用HS自体移植物,8项报告使用BPTB自体移植物,2项使用股四头肌腱自体移植物,8项使用多种类型;7项研究报告使用同种异体移植物,其余2项同时使用BPTB自体移植物和同种异体移植物。

主要发现

  • 自体移植物组共1192例患者,平均年龄28.7岁(范围22.5至39),平均随访5.4年(范围2.0至9.6);同种异体移植物组共269例患者,平均年龄28.4岁(范围25至34.6),平均随访4.0年(范围2.3至6.0)。
  • 同种异体移植物中,2项研究使用2.5 mrad辐照,其余7项研究未辐照。
  • 自体移植物重建在KT-1000/2000测量的松弛度及并发症和再手术率方面优于同种异体移植物。
  • 同种异体移植物重建的平均Lysholm和Tegner活动评分优于自体移植物。
  • 排除辐照同种异体移植物后,自体移植物与同种异体移植物的结局不再有差异;比较自体移植物类型时,除HS移植物的国际膝关节文献委员会评分优于BPTB移植物外,其余结局相似。

关键数值与推荐

  • 纳入标准为报告至少两年随访结局的研究。
  • 同种异体移植物中2项研究使用2.5 mrad辐照,7项研究未辐照。

临床怎么用

  • 翻修前交叉韧带重建的移植物选择应个体化,考虑术者偏好技术、是否需要联合重建、既往移植物类型、隧道是否扩大及同种异体移植物可得性等因素。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: Our aim was to perform a meta-analysis of the outcomes of revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, comparing the use of different types of graft. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A search was performed of Medline and Pubmed using the terms "Anterior Cruciate Ligament" and "ACL" combined with "revision", "re-operation" and "failure". Only studies that reported the outcome at a minimum follow-up of two years were included. Two authors reviewed the papers, and outcomes were subdivided into autograft and allograft. Autograft was subdivided into hamstring (HS) and bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB). Subjective and objective outcome measures were analysed and odds ratios with confidence intervals were calculated. RESULTS: A total of 32 studies met the inclusion criteria. Five studies used HS autografts, eight reported using BPTB autografts, two used quadriceps tendon autografts and eight used various types. Seven studies reported using allografts, while the two remaining used both BPTB autografts and allografts. Overall, 1192 patients with a mean age of 28.7 years (22.5 to 39) and a mean follow-up of 5.4 years (2.0 to 9.6) were treated with autografts, while 269 patients with a mean age of 28.4 years (25 to 34.6) and a mean follow-up of 4.0 years (2.3 to 6.0) were treated with allografts. Regarding allografts, irradiation with 2.5 mrad was used in two studies while the graft was not irradiated in the seven remaining studies. Reconstructions following the use of autografts had better outcomes than those using allograft with respect to laxity, measured by KT-1000/2000 (MEDmetric Corporation) and the rates of complications and re-operations. Those following the use of allografts had better mean Lysholm and Tegner activity scores compared with autografts. If irradiated allografts were excluded from the analysis, outcomes no longer differed between the use of autografts and allografts. Comparing the types of autograft, all outcomes were similar except for HS grafts which had better International Knee Documentation Committee scores compared with BPTB grafts. CONCLUSION: Autografts had better outcomes than allografts in revision ACL reconstruction, with lower post-operative laxity and rates of complications and re-operations. However, after excluding irradiated allografts, outcomes were similar between autografts and allografts. Overall, the choice of graft at revision ACL reconstruction should be on an individual basis considering, for instance, the preferred technique of the surgeon, whether a combined reconstruction is required, the type of graft that was previously used, whether the tunnels are enlarged and the availability of allograft. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2017;99-B:714-23.

来源:Bone Joint J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Grassi A, Nitri M, Moulton SG, et al. Does the type of graft affect the outcome of revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction? a meta-analysis of 32 studies. Bone Joint J. 2017. PMID: 28566389. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.99B6.BJJ-2016-0929.R2

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。