文献速递关节外科运动医学

固定平台与活动平台全踝关节置换术患者步态力学是否存在差异?一项随机试验

Are There Differences in Gait Mechanics in Patients With A Fixed Versus Mobile Bearing Total Ankle Arthroplasty? A Randomized Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2017-06-06

该随机试验前瞻性招募40例终末期踝关节炎患者,比较固定平台与活动平台全踝关节置换术后1年疼痛与步态力学的改善差异,33例完成分析。结果显示两种假体在步态力学和疼痛改善上无统计学或临床意义差异,效应量分析提示差异小于1个标准差。

要点

  • 固定平台与活动平台全踝关节置换术后1年步态力学和疼痛改善无统计学或临床意义差异。
  • 效应量分析提示两种假体间结局变化差异小于1个标准差。
  • 检测最大观察效应需未来试验入组66例,检测最小观察效应需2336例。

核心结论

  • 基于本研究结果,固定平台与活动平台假体在全踝关节置换术后1年步态力学和疼痛方面无统计学或临床意义差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性随机试验,2011年11月至2013年6月从单一足踝骨科门诊招募40例终末期踝关节炎患者,随机分入固定平台组(n=20)或活动平台组(n=20),33例纳入分析。
  • 样本量可检测组间均值1.01个标准差的标准化位移,把握度80%,I型错误率5%。

主要发现

  • 固定平台组推进期垂直地面反作用力变化为0.1±0.1(范围0.0-1.0),活动平台组为0.0±0.1(范围0.0-0.0),p=0.051。
  • 固定平台组步行速度变化为0.2±0.3(范围0.1-0.4),活动平台组为0.2±0.3(范围0.0-0.3),p=0.742。
  • 两种假体间结局变化差异小于1个标准差。

局限性

  • 40例同意参与者中7例未纳入分析,包括每组各1例手术取消和5例失访(固定平台组4例,活动平台组1例)。
  • 检测最大观察效应需未来试验入组66例,检测最小观察效应需2336例。
  • 本研究统计把握度仅能检测大效应,并对观察到的效应量进行描述性分析。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) is an alternative to arthrodesis, but no randomized trial has examined whether a fixed bearing or mobile bearing implant provides improved gait mechanics. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We wished to determine if fixed- or mobile-bearing TAA results in a larger improvement in pain scores and gait mechanics from before surgery to 1 year after surgery, and to quantify differences in outcomes using statistical analysis and report the standardized effect sizes for such comparisons. METHODS: Patients with end-stage ankle arthritis who were scheduled for TAA between November 2011 and June 2013 (n = 40; 16 men, 24 women; average age, 63 years; age range, 35-81 years) were prospectively recruited for this study from a single foot and ankle orthopaedic clinic. During this period, 185 patients underwent TAA, with 144 being eligible to participate in this study. Patients were eligible to participate if they were able to meet all study inclusion criteria, which were: no previous diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis, a contralateral TAA, bilateral ankle arthritis, previous revision TAA, an ankle fusion revision, or able to walk without the use of an assistive device, weight less than 250 pounds (114 kg), a sagittal or coronal plane deformity less than 15°, no presence of avascular necrosis of the distal tibia, no current neuropathy, age older than 35 years, no history of a talar neck fracture, or an avascular talus. Of the 144 eligible patients, 40 consented to participate in our randomized trial. These 40 patients were randomly assigned to either the fixed (n = 20) or mobile bearing implant group (n = 20). Walking speed, bilateral peak dorsiflexion angle, peak plantar flexion angle, sagittal plane ankle ROM, peak ankle inversion angle, peak plantar flexion moment, peak plantar flexion power during stance, peak weight acceptance, and propulsive vertical ground reaction force were analyzed during seven self-selected speed level walking trials for 33 participants using an eight-camera motion analysis system and four force plates. Seven patients were not included in the analysis owing to cancelled surgery (one from each group) and five were lost to followup (four with fixed bearing and one with mobile bearing implants). A series of effect-size calculations and two-sample t-tests comparing postoperative and preoperative increases in outcome variables between implant types were used to determine the differences in the magnitude of improvement between the two patient cohorts from before surgery to 1 year after surgery. The sample size in this study enabled us to detect a standardized shift of 1.01 SDs between group means with 80% power and a type I error rate of 5% for all outcome variables in the study. RESULTS: This randomized trial did not reveal any differences in outcomes between the two implant types under study at the sample size collected. In addition to these results, effect size analysis suggests that changes in outcome differ between implant types by less than 1 SD. Detection of the largest change score or observed effect (propulsive vertical ground reaction force [Fixed: 0.1 ± 0.1; 0.0-1.0; Mobile: 0.0 ± 0.1; 0.0-0.0; p = 0.0.051]) in this study would require a future trial to enroll 66 patients. However, the smallest change score or observed effect (walking speed [Fixed: 0.2 ± 0.3; 0.1-0.4; Mobile: 0.2 ± 0.3; 0.0-0.3; p = 0.742]) requires a sample size of 2336 to detect a significant difference with 80% power at the observed effect sizes. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first randomized study to report the observed effect size comparing improvements in outcome measures between fixed and mobile bearing implant types. This study was statistically powered to detect large effects and descriptively analyze observed effect sizes. Based on our results there were no statistically or clinically meaningful differences between the fixed and mobile bearing implants when examining gait mechanics and pain 1 year after TAA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Queen RM, Franck CT, Schmitt D, et al. Are There Differences in Gait Mechanics in Patients With A Fixed Versus Mobile Bearing Total Ankle Arthroplasty? A Randomized Trial. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28589334. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5405-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。