交通灯分级系统预测髋关节发育不良患者髋关节镜手术成功率
本研究为病例对照研究,纳入2008至2013年间111例接受髋关节镜手术的发育不良髋关节,随访平均4.5年,7年关节生存率为68%。作者基于髋臼指数和外侧中心边缘角结合关节磨损程度提出交通灯分级系统,绿区(AIf 0°-15°且LCEAf 15°-25°)保髋机会最大(OR 10,P<.001),红区(AIf 20°-100°且LCEAf 0°-10°)失败机会最大(OR 10,P<.001)。作者建议对严重发育不良(红区:AI>20°和/或LCEA<10°)考虑关节镜选项时应极其谨慎。
要点
- 发育不良髋关节镜术后7年关节生存率为68%,低于股骨髋臼撞击症报告的78%。
- 绿区(AIf 0°-15°且LCEAf 15°-25°)保髋机会最大,OR 10,P<.001。
- 红区(AIf 20°-100°且LCEAf 0°-10°)失败机会最大,OR 10,P<.001。
核心结论
- 发育不良髋关节镜术后7年髋关节生存率似乎低于股骨髋臼撞击症报告的78%。
- 轻度发育不良(绿区:AI=0°-15°,LCEA=15°-25°)且无关节磨损时,髋关节镜手术保髋机会极好。
- 作者建议对严重发育不良(红区:AI>20°和/或LCEA<10°)考虑关节镜选项时应极其谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照研究,证据等级3级。
- 2008至2013年间识别111例具有发育不良特征(髋臼指数AI>10°和/或外侧中心边缘角LCEA<25°)并接受关节镜手术的髋关节。
- 回顾临床、影像学和手术所见及所行手术类型。
- 影像学评估手术髋的AI、LCEA和挤出指数。
- 结局指标包括随访时髋关节是否保留(即未需关节置换)以及术前和术后非关节炎髋评分(NAHS)和髋关节残疾与骨关节炎结局评分(HOOS)。
主要发现
- 平均AI和LCEA分别为9.8°和18.0°。
- 平均随访4.5年(范围0.4-8.3年)时,33髋失败,需行髋关节置换。
- 7年关节生存率为68%。
- NAHS和HOOS平均改善分别为11分(P=.001)和22.8分(P<.001)。
- 保髋机会最大的区域为绿区(AIf 0°-15°且LCEAf 15°-25°),比值比10,P<.001;失败机会最大的区域为红区(AIf 20°-100°且LCEAf 0°-10°),比值比10,P<.001。
关键数值与推荐
- 发育不良特征定义为AI>10°和/或LCEA<25°。
- AIf=AI×(伦敦大学学院磨损分区数+1);LCEAf=LCEA/(伦敦大学学院磨损分区数+1)。
- 绿区:AIf 0°-15°且LCEAf 15°-25°,保髋机会最大,OR 10,P<.001。
- 红区:AIf 20°-100°且LCEAf 0°-10°,失败机会最大,OR 10,P<.001。
- 严重发育不良定义为AI>20°和/或LCEA<10°。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议对严重发育不良(红区:AI>20°和/或LCEA<10°)考虑关节镜选项时应极其谨慎。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The role of hip arthroscopic surgery in dysplasia is controversial. PURPOSE: To determine the 7-year joint preservation rate after hip arthroscopic surgery in hip dysplasia and identify anatomic and intraoperative features that predict the success of hip preservation with arthroscopic surgery, allowing the formulation of an evidence-based classification system. STUDY DESIGN: Case-control study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Between 2008 and 2013, 111 hips with dysplastic features (acetabular index [AI] >10° and/or lateral center-edge angle [LCEA] <25°) that underwent arthroscopic surgery were identified. Clinical, radiological, and operative findings and the type of procedure performed were reviewed. Radiographic evaluations of the operated hip (AI, LCEA, extrusion index) were performed. Outcome measures included whether the hip was preserved (ie, did not require arthroplasty) at follow-up and the preoperative and postoperative Non-Arthritic Hip Score (NAHS) and Hip disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (HOOS). The AI and LCEA were calculated, factored by a measure of articular wear (AIf and LCEAf, respectively), according to the University College Hospital, London (UCL) grading system as follows: AIf = AI × (number of UCL wear zones + 1), and LCEAf = LCEA / (number of UCL wear zones + 1). A contour plot of the resulting probability value of failure for every combination of AIf and LCEAf allowed for the determination of the zones with the lowest and highest incidences of failure to preserve the hip. RESULTS: The mean AI and LCEA were 9.8° and 18.0°, respectively. At a mean follow-up of 4.5 years (range, 0.4-8.3 years), 33 hips had failed, requiring hip arthroplasty. The 7-year joint survival rate was 68%. The mean improvements in the NAHS and HOOS were 11 ( P = .001) and 22.8 ( P < .001) points, respectively. The zone with the greatest chance of joint preservation (odds ratio, 10; P < .001) was the green zone, with an AIf of 0° to 15° and an LCEAf of 15° to 25°; in contrast, the zone with the greatest chance of failure (odds ratio, 10; P < .001) was the red zone, with an AIf of 20° to 100° and an LCEAf of 0° to 10°. CONCLUSION: Overall, the 7-year hip survival rate in hip dysplasia appears inferior compared with that reported in femoroacetabular impingement (78%). Hip arthroscopic surgery is associated with an excellent chance of hip preservation in mild dysplasia (green zone: AI = 0°-15°, LCEA = 15°-25°) and no articular wear. The authors advise that the greatest caution should be used when considering arthroscopic options in cases of severe dysplasia (red zone: AI >20° and/or LCEA <10°).
引用
- Grammatopoulos G, Davies OLI, El-Bakoury A, et al. A Traffic Light Grading System of Hip Dysplasia to Predict the Success of Arthroscopic Hip Surgery. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28654765. doi:10.1177/0363546517713176
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。