前瞻性随机外科医生盲法比较标准放大率假设与放大标记用于全髋关节置换术前模板制作的准确性
这项前瞻性随机外科医生盲法研究将100例连续全髋关节置换术随机分为使用25毫米放大标记组(50例)与标准21%放大率组(50例),比较术前模板预测假体尺寸的准确性。结果显示两组在股骨和髋臼假体尺寸预测准确率上无统计学显著差异,作者认为标准21%放大率同样准确,且可节省时间和费用。
要点
- 两组体重指数(28.9 vs 27.9,P=0.26)和性别(P=0.69)具有可比性。
- 放大标记组预测股骨尺寸在1个尺寸内的比例为80%,髋臼为94%;标准21%放大率组分别为90%和96%。
- 两组准确率无统计学显著差异(股骨:χ2 P=0.16,OR=2.3,95%CI 0.7-7.1;髋臼:χ2 P=0.65,OR=1.5,95%CI 0.3-9.6)。
核心结论
- 比较两种方法选择假体尺寸的准确性,未检测到一种方法优于另一种方法的统计学显著差异。
- 由于使用放大标记增加了术前X线采集的时间和费用,作者认为使用标准21%放大率是同样准确的技术。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、随机、外科医生盲法研究,纳入100例连续全髋关节置换术,随机分为放大标记组(50例)和标准21%放大率组(50例)。
主要发现
- 两组体重指数(28.9 vs 27.9,P=0.26)和性别(P=0.69)具有可比性。
- 放大标记组预测股骨尺寸在1个尺寸内的比例为80%,髋臼假体为94%。
- 标准21%放大率组预测股骨尺寸在1个尺寸内的比例为90%,髋臼假体为96%。
- 两组准确率无统计学显著差异(股骨:χ2 P=0.16,OR=2.3,95%CI 0.7-7.1;髋臼:χ2 P=0.65,OR=1.5,95%CI 0.3-9.6)。
关键数值与推荐
- 放大标记组预测股骨尺寸在1个尺寸内的比例为80%,髋臼为94%。
- 标准21%放大率组预测股骨尺寸在1个尺寸内的比例为90%,髋臼为96%。
- 股骨尺寸准确率比较:χ2 P=0.16,OR=2.3,95%CI 0.7-7.1;髋臼尺寸准确率比较:χ2 P=0.65,OR=1.5,95%CI 0.3-9.6。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,由于放大标记增加术前X线采集的时间和费用,使用标准21%放大率是同样准确的技术。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We undertook this prospective, randomized, surgeon-blinded study to compare the accuracy of using of a magnification marker on preoperative radiographs for templating vs using a standard 21% magnification. METHODS: One hundred consecutive total hip arthroplasties were randomized to preoperative templating using a 25-mm magnification marker (50 patients) or a standard 21% magnification (50 patients). Intraoperative data were collected regarding the actual and predicted size of the femoral and acetabular components. RESULTS: The 2 groups were found to be comparable with respect to body mass index (28.9 vs 27.9, P = .26) and gender (P = .69). In the magnification marker group, we predicted the femoral size within 1 size in 80% of the cases and the acetabular component in 94%. In the group of a standard 21% magnification, we predicted the femoral size within 1 size in 90% of the cases and the acetabular component in 96%. These proportions did not statistically differ (femur: χ2P = .16, odds ratio = 2.3, 95% confidence interval = 0.7-7.1; acetabulum: χ2P = .65, odds ratio = 1.5, 95% confidence interval = 0.3-9.6). CONCLUSION: We did not detect a statistically significant difference in accuracy by using one method over the other when comparing the accuracy of component size selection. As the use of the magnification marker adds to the time and expense of preoperative radiographic acquisition, we feel using a standard 21% magnification is an equally accurate technique.
引用
- Archibeck MJ, Tripuraneni KR, Carothers JT, et al. Prospective, Randomized, Surgeon-Blinded Comparison of Standard Magnification Assumption vs Magnification Marker Usage for Preoperative Templating in Total Hip Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28602530. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.05.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。