文献速递脊柱外科

退变性腰椎手术指征的变异性:四国调查

Indication Variability in Degenerative Lumbar Spine Surgery: A Four-nation Survey.
PubMed 文献 · Spine (Phila Pa 1976) · 2018-01-01

该研究通过电子问卷调查美国、法国、西班牙和德国共52名骨科医生和50名神经外科医生,针对五种腰椎退变病例的手术治疗模式,计算每个国家的定性变异指数(IQV)和Fleiss kappa评估一致性。结果显示多节段和单节段狭窄的IQV分别为0.47和0.32(美国),欧洲国家更异质(所有IQV>0.70)且更常建议融合;退变性脊柱侧凸所有态度极异质(IQV>0.8);峡部裂性滑脱融合共识较高(所有IQV<0.63),但峡部裂溶解态度更异质(IQV 0.48-0.76),法国和美国分别有37%和19.2%建议前路入路。总体评估者间一致性轻微(神经外科医生Kappa=0.04,骨科医生Kappa=0.13,国家间Kappa<0.13,年龄组间Kappa<0.1)。

要点

  • 美国医生对狭窄病例更倾向减压(多节段IQV=0.47,单节段=0.32),欧洲国家更异质(所有IQV>0.70)且更常建议融合。
  • 退变性脊柱侧凸所有态度极异质(IQV>0.8),峡部裂性滑脱融合共识较高(所有IQV<0.63)。
  • 总体评估者间一致性轻微:神经外科医生Fleiss Kappa=0.04,骨科医生Kappa=0.13,国家间Kappa<0.13,年龄组间Kappa<0.1。

核心结论

  • 本研究发现在某些脊柱疾病中存在实质性共识,但在另一些中变异度高:观察到国内和国际变异,反映文献共识缺乏。

研究设计与样本

  • 电子问卷调查,提交给来自美国、法国、西班牙和德国的52名骨科医生和50名神经外科医生,针对五个 vignette 病例(多节段狭窄、单节段狭窄、溶骨性滑脱、峡部裂溶解和退变性脊柱侧凸)。
  • 使用定性变异指数(IQV=0:无变异,1:最大变异)计算每个国家的变异性,并使用Fleiss kappa(范围从-1差到1几乎完美)评估专业、国家和年龄组之间的一致性。

主要发现

  • 对于两个狭窄病例,美国医生更可能建议减压(IQV多节段=0.47,单节段=0.32),而欧洲国家更异质(所有IQV>0.70)且更频繁建议融合。
  • 关于退变性脊柱侧凸,所有态度极异质,IQV>0.8。
  • 峡部裂性滑脱的融合共识较高(所有IQV<0.63),但峡部裂溶解态度更异质(IQV范围0.48至0.76),法国(37%)和美国(19.2%)建议前路入路。
  • 总体评估者间一致性轻微,不仅神经外科医生(Fleiss Kappa=0.04)和骨科医生(Kappa=0.13),而且国家间(Kappa<0.13)和年龄组间(Kappa<0.1)也如此。

关键数值与推荐

  • 狭窄病例:美国医生建议减压的IQV多节段=0.47,单节段=0.32;欧洲国家所有IQV>0.70。
  • 退变性脊柱侧凸:所有态度IQV>0.8。
  • 峡部裂性滑脱:所有IQV<0.63;峡部裂溶解:IQV 0.48至0.76,法国37%和美国19.2%建议前路入路。
  • 总体一致性:神经外科医生Fleiss Kappa=0.04,骨科医生Kappa=0.13,国家间Kappa<0.13,年龄组间Kappa<0.1。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY DESIGN: Electronic survey. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify the international nuances in surgical treatment patterns for severals lumbar degenerative conditions, specifically, to identify differences in responses in each country groupand different treatment trends across countries. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Significant variations in treatment of lumbar degenerative conditions exist among spine surgeons, related to the lack of established consensus in the literature. METHODS: An online survey with preformulated answers was submitted to 52 orthopedic surgeons, 50 neurosurgeons from four different countries (United States, France, Spain, and Germany) regarding five vignette-cases. Cases included: multilevel stenosis, monolevel stenosis, lytic spondylolisthesis, isthmic lysis, and degenerative scoliosis. The variability for each country was calculated according to the Index of Qualitative Variation (IQV = 0: no variability and 1: maximal variability). We used Fleiss kappa (range: from -1, poor agreement, to 1, almost perfect agreement) for assessing the reliability of agreement between the participants concerning specialties, countries, and age groups. RESULTS: For the two stenosis cases, US surgeons were more likely to propose decompression (IQV multilevel = 0.47 and monolevel = 0.32) comparing with European countries more heterogeneous (all IQV >0.70) and more frequently proposing fusion. As regards degenerative scoliosis, all attitudes were extremely heterogeneous with IQV >0.8. Fusion for isthmic spondylolisthesis was more consensual (all IQV <0.63), but attitudes were more heterogeneous for isthmic lysis (IQV ranged from 0.48 to 0.76) with anterior approach proposed in France (37%) and United States (19.2%).The overall interrater agreement was equally slight not only for neurosurgeons (Fleiss Kappa = 0.04) and orthopedic surgeons (Kappa = 0.13), but also for countries (Kappa <0.13) and age groups (Kappa <0.1). CONCLUSION: In this study, we found substantial agreement for some spinal conditions but a high variability in some others: intranational and international variations were observed, reflecting the lack of literature consensus. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2.

来源:Spine (Phila Pa 1976),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Debono B, Lonjon G, Galovich LA, et al. Indication Variability in Degenerative Lumbar Spine Surgery: A Four-nation Survey. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2018. PMID: 28604486. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000002272

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。