翻修前交叉韧带重建的中期失败率如何?一项系统综述
该系统综述检索了PubMed/Medline、EMBASE和CENTRAL,纳入15篇文章(共16个病例系列),评估平均随访至少5年的翻修前交叉韧带重建的累积失败率。结果显示,仅以移植物再断裂定义的失败率范围0%-25%,而结合客观临床标准后累积失败率范围0%-83%。结论认为仅以再断裂作为失败终点可能低估真实失败率。
要点
- 翻修前交叉韧带重建的再断裂率范围0%-25%,仅4个系列超过5%,仅1个系列超过10%。
- 客观临床失败率范围0%-82%,15个系列超过5%,12个系列超过10%,5个系列超过20%。
- 累积失败率范围0%-83%,除1个系列外均超过5%,12个系列超过10%,5个系列超过20%。
核心结论
- 仅以再断裂作为翻修前交叉韧带重建的失败终点可能低估真实失败率,因为当同时考虑客观临床标准时失败比例明显增加。
- 评估膝关节功能、活动水平、满意度和疼痛的患者报告和主观评分是否也有助于定义失败,可能是未来研究的重点。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed/Medline、EMBASE和CENTRAL数据库。
- 纳入报告翻修前交叉韧带重建临床评估(Lachman试验、轴移试验、KT-1000/2000关节计侧-侧差值)且平均随访至少5年的研究。
- 排除未完整报告上述结果、仅报告再断裂或非英语语言的研究。
- 663项筛选研究中纳入15篇文章,因一项研究报告两组不同治疗的患者,共评估16个病例系列。
- 证据等级为IV级,治疗性研究。
主要发现
- 再断裂比例范围为0%-25%,16个系列中仅4个超过5%,仅1个超过10%。
- 客观临床失败比例范围为0%-82%,16个系列中15个超过5%,12个超过10%,5个超过20%。
- 累积失败比例范围为0%-83%,除1个系列外均超过5%,16个系列中12个超过10%,5个系列超过20%。
- 最常见的并发症是膝关节僵硬和前膝疼痛,再手术主要为清创和半月板切除术。
- 并发症和再手术因报告不一致和人群异质性未进行合并分析。
关键数值与推荐
- 客观临床失败定义为膝关节满足以下终点之一:Lachman试验II至III级、轴移试验II至III级、KT-1000/2000差值>5mm、或国际膝关节文献委员会(IKDC)分级C或D。
- 累积失败定义为再断裂和客观临床失败的比例之和。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 并发症和再手术因报告不一致和人群异质性未进行合并分析。
- 患者报告和主观评分是否有助于定义失败可能是未来研究的重点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction fails, a revision procedure may be performed to improve knee function, correct instability, and allow return to activities. The results of revision ACL reconstruction have been reported to produce good but inferior patient-reported and objective outcomes compared with primary ACL reconstruction, but the degree to which this is the case varies widely among published studies and may be influenced by heterogeneity of patients, techniques, and endpoints assessed. For those reasons, a systematic review may provide important insights. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In a systematic review, we asked: (1) What is the proportion of revision ACL reconstruction cumulative failures defined as rerupture or objective failure using prespecified clinical criteria at mean followup of at least 5 years? (2) What are the most common complications of revision ACL reconstruction? METHODS: A systematic review was performed by searching PubMed/Medline, EMBASE, and CENTRAL. We included studies that reported the clinical evaluation of revision ACL reconstruction with Lachman test, pivot shift test, side-to-side difference with KT-1000/2000 arthrometer, and with a mean followup of at least 5 years. We excluded studies that incompletely reported these outcomes, that reported only reruptures, or that were not in the English language. Extracted data included the number of graft reruptures and objective clinical failure, defined as a knee that met one of the following endpoints: Lachman test Grade II to III, pivot shift Grade II to III, KT-1000/2000 > 5-mm difference, or International Knee Documentation Committee Grade C or D. For each study, we determined the proportion of patients who had experienced a rupture of the revision ACL graft as well as the proportion of patients who met one or more of our clinical failure endpoints. Those proportions were summed for each study to generate a percentage of patients who met our definition of cumulative failure. Complications and reoperations were recorded but not pooled as a result of inconsistency of reporting and heterogeneity of populations across the included studies. Of the 663 screened studies, 15 articles were included in the systematic review. Because one study reported two separate groups of patients with different treatments, 16 case series were considered in the evaluation. RESULTS: The proportion of reruptures (range, 0%-25%) was > 5% in only four of 16 series and > 10% in only one of them. The objective clinical failures (range, 0%-82%) was > 5% in 15 of 16 series and > 10% in 12 of them. The proportion exceeded 20% in five of 16 series. The cumulative failures (range, 0%-83%) was > 5% in all except one series and > 10% in 12 of 16 series; five series had a cumulative failure proportion > 20%. The most frequent complications were knee stiffness and anterior knee pain, whereas reoperations were primarily débridement and meniscectomies. CONCLUSIONS: Considering rerupture alone as a failure endpoint in patients who have undergone revision ACL reconstruction likely underestimates the real failure rate, because the percentage of failures noticeably increases when objective criteria are also considered. Whether patient-reported and subjective scores evaluating knee function, level of activity, satisfaction, and pain might also contribute to the definition of failure may be the focus of future studies. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Grassi A, Kim C, Marcheggiani Muccioli GM, et al. What Is the Mid-term Failure Rate of Revision ACL Reconstruction? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28493217. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5379-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。