带锚钉经骨等效缝线与无锚钉经骨缝线肩袖修复的生物力学对比:尸体模型分析
在20具新鲜冷冻人体尸体肩关节上制作25 mm冈上肌腱撕裂,随机分为带锚钉经骨等效(TOE)修复组与无锚钉经骨(AT)修复组各10例,进行循环加载和失败载荷测试。TOE组平均极限失败载荷显著高于AT组(578.5±123.8 N vs 468.7±150.9 N,P=.034),首次循环位移显著小于AT组(2.97±1.97 mm vs 4.70±2.04 mm,P=.046);两组循环伸长率和线性刚度无显著差异。TOE组主要失败模式为2型肌腱撕裂伴内侧肌腱断裂(7/10),AT组为1型肌腱撕裂伴外侧肌腱断裂(6/10)。
要点
- TOE组平均极限失败载荷显著高于AT组(578.5±123.8 N vs 468.7±150.9 N,P=.034)。
- TOE组平均首次循环位移显著小于AT组(2.97±1.97 mm vs 4.70±2.04 mm,P=.046)。
- TOE组主要失败模式为2型肌腱撕裂伴内侧肌腱断裂(7/10),AT组为1型肌腱撕裂伴外侧肌腱断裂(6/10)。
核心结论
- 在尸体模型中,TOE修复的平均失败载荷显著高于AT修复。
- TOE组最常见的失败模式为2型肌腱撕裂,AT组为1型肌腱撕裂。
研究设计与样本
- controll laboratory study,在20具新鲜冷冻人体尸体肩关节上制作25 mm冈上肌腱撕裂。
- 随机分为TOE组与AT组各10例,采用配对实验设计。
- 进行预加载、循环加载和失败载荷的生物力学测试,使用光学标记监测3个平面的间隙形成并记录失败模式。
- 采用配对t检验比较两组生物力学参数,采用多项逻辑回归比较两组失败模式,显著性水平设为.05。
主要发现
- TOE组平均(±SD)极限失败载荷为578.5±123.8 N,AT组为468.7±150.9 N(P=.034)。
- TOE组平均首次循环位移为2.97±1.97 mm,AT组为4.70±2.04 mm(P=.046)。
- 两组在循环加载期间的循环伸长率和线性刚度无显著差异。
- TOE组主要失败模式为2型肌腱撕裂伴内侧肌腱断裂(7/10),AT组为1型肌腱撕裂伴外侧肌腱断裂(6/10)。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,TOE较AT构造更高的平均失败载荷可能以锚钉内侧肌腱交界处较不利的失败模式为代价,可能使翻修困难。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The original approach for the repair of torn rotator cuffs involved an open technique with sutures passing through the greater tuberosity and tendon. The development of suture anchors allowed for an all-arthroscopic approach with anchor configurations attempting to re-create a transosseous fixation pattern. Presently, an arthroscopic approach can be combined with a transosseous suture configuration without using anchors. PURPOSE: To evaluate cyclic loading, ultimate load to failure, and the failure mechanisms of transosseous-equivalent (TOE) repair with anchors and anchorless transosseous (AT) repair of rotator cuff tears. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Supraspinatus tears (25 mm) were created in 20 fresh-frozen, human cadaveric shoulders, which were randomized to TOE or AT repair (10 in each group, paired experimental design). Biomechanical testing was performed with an initial preload, cyclic loading, and load to failure. Optical markers were used to monitor gap formation in 3 planes, and the failure mode was recorded. Paired t tests were used to make comparisons of biomechanical parameters between the groups. Multinomial logistic regression was used to compare failure modes between the groups. Significance was set to .05. RESULTS: The TOE group had a significantly higher mean (±SD) ultimate failure load (578.5 ± 123.8 N) than the AT group (468.7 ± 150.9 N) ( P = .034). The TOE group also had a significantly less mean first-cycle excursion (2.97 ± 1.97 mm) than the AT group (4.70 ± 2.04 mm) ( P = .046). There were no significant differences between the groups in cyclic elongation or linear stiffness during cyclic loading. Primary modes of failure were a type 2 tendon tear with medial tendon disruption in the TOE group (7/10) and a type 1 tendon tear with lateral tendon disruption in the AT group (6/10). CONCLUSION: TOE repair resulted in a significantly higher mean failure load compared with AT repair in a cadaveric model. The most common modes of failure were a type 2 tendon tear in the TOE group and a type 1 tendon tear in the AT group. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: A higher mean failure load in TOE versus AT constructs may come at the cost of a less favorable failure mode adjacent to medial anchors at the musculotendinous junction, potentially making revision difficult.
引用
- Kilcoyne KG, Guillaume SG, Hannan CV, et al. Anchored Transosseous-Equivalent Versus Anchorless Transosseous Rotator Cuff Repair: A Biomechanical Analysis in a Cadaveric Model. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28520458. doi:10.1177/0363546517706136
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。