全膝关节置换术中外科医生的偏好:对属性、改变原因及改变障碍的定量考察
本研究通过跨国电子调查347名实施全膝关节置换术的骨科医生,考察其对假体的偏好、偏好改变原因及永久改变偏好的障碍。结果显示评价最高的属性为结果可重复性、最佳功能结果和更好的运动学,最低的为关键意见领袖或导师使用及新或创新;最低翻修风险仅排第10位,19.9%的医生表示其不影响偏好;成本不影响52.1%的医生,33.7%同意其机构或系统限制了偏好。作者认为驱动偏好的原因、偏好改变原因及改变障碍是多因素、多样且复杂的,翻修风险并非评价最高的属性。
要点
- 评价最高的属性为结果可重复性、最佳功能结果和更好的运动学。
- 最低翻修风险排第10位,19.9%的医生表示其不影响偏好。
- 成本不影响52.1%的医生,33.7%同意机构或系统限制其偏好。
核心结论
- 作者认为,理解外科医生为何偏好某些全膝关节置换假体或技术而非其他可行替代方案,对减少不必要变异至关重要。
- 本研究表明,驱动外科医生偏好的自评原因、偏好改变原因及改变障碍是多因素、多样且复杂的,翻修风险并非评价最高的属性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用跨国电子调查,研究347名实施全膝关节置换术的骨科医生。
- 调查使用匿名强制回答、互斥封闭选项、多选屏蔽、自动题干随机化、Likert量表加权且无中立选项。
主要发现
- 17项属性中评价最高的为结果可重复性、最佳功能结果和更好的运动学。
- 评价最低的为关键意见领袖或导师使用及新或创新。
- 最低翻修风险排第10位,19.9%的医生表示其不影响偏好。
- 成本不影响52.1%的医生,33.7%同意其机构或系统限制了偏好。
- 外科医生人口学特征及偏好假体或技术改变了部分属性评分,包括手术量、执业国家、偏好植入物类型;但翻修风险评分未被任何因素改变。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The reasons why surgeons prefer a particular total knee replacement (TKR) to other viable options with lower cost or lower revision risk remain uncertain. This study examined the concept of surgeon's preference in TKR; including the self-assigned utility of their preferred prosthesis, reasons to alter usual preference and barriers to permanently changing preference. METHODS: Using a multinational electronic survey, 347 TKR performing orthopedic surgeons were studied using anonymous mandatory responses, mutually exclusive closed options, multiple responses blocking, automatic stem randomization, Likert scale weighting, and an absence of neutral options. RESULTS: The highest rated of the 17 attributes were "reproducibility of outcome," "best functional outcome," and "better kinematics." The lowest rated were a "key-opinion leader or mentor uses it" and "new or innovative." "Lowest revision risk" ranked 10th, with 19.9% of surgeons stating it did not influence their preference. Cost did not influence 52.1% of surgeons and 33.7% agreed that their institution or system limited their preference. Surgeon's demographics and preferred prosthesis or technique altered some attribute ratings including surgical volume, country of practice, type of preferred implant; however, revision risk rating was not altered by any factor. Cost considerations altered rating of barriers to technique change. CONCLUSION: Understanding why surgeons prefer certain TKR prostheses or techniques to other viable alternatives is vital to reduce unwarranted variation. This study suggests that the self-assigned reasons driving surgeon's preferences, reasons for preference alteration, and barriers to change are multifactorial, diverse, and complex, with revision risk not being the highest rated attribute.
引用
- Vertullo CJ, Grimbeek PM, Graves SE, et al. Surgeon's Preference in Total Knee Replacement: A Quantitative Examination of Attributes, Reasons for Alteration, and Barriers to Change. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28552448. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.04.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。