双切口与迷你后路全髋关节置换术随机临床试验:10年差异持续存在
本研究报告既往在本机构开展的随机临床试验中71例患者的10年随访结果,比较双切口与迷你后路全髋关节置换术的临床结局、翻修、再手术和假体生存率。末次随访时双切口组平均Harris髋关节评分85分,迷你后路组87分(P=0.4);双切口组4例翻修和2例再手术(16%),迷你后路组1例翻修和3例再手术(11%)(P=0.5);10年无无菌性翻修或再手术生存率双切口组77% vs 迷你后路组90%(P=0.15)。结论认为双切口技术未改善早期或中期临床结局,但双切口全髋关节置换术组无菌性翻修率有临床升高趋势。
要点
- 10年随访时双切口组与迷你后路组Harris髋关节评分分别为85分和87分(P=0.4)。
- 双切口组翻修和再手术共6例(16%),迷你后路组共4例(11%)(P=0.5)。
- 10年无无菌性翻修或再手术生存率双切口组77% vs 迷你后路组90%(P=0.15)。
核心结论
- 双切口技术未改善早期或中期临床结局。
- 双切口全髋关节置换术组无菌性翻修率有临床升高趋势。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为对既往在本机构开展的随机临床试验中71例患者的回顾性分析,比较双切口与迷你后路全髋关节置换术。
- 既往随机临床试验在2年时显示35例双切口全髋关节置换术恢复较36例迷你后路全髋关节置换术慢。
主要发现
- 末次随访时双切口组平均Harris髋关节评分为85分,迷你后路组为87分(P=0.4)。
- 双切口组有4例翻修和2例再手术(16%),迷你后路组有1例翻修和3例再手术(11%)(P=0.5)。
- 10年无无菌性翻修或再手术生存率双切口组为77%,迷你后路组为90%(P=0.15)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A previous randomized clinical trial at our institution demonstrated slower recovery of 35 2-incision total hip arthroplasties (THAs) when compared with 36 mini-posterior THAs at 2 years. The primary aim of the present study was to report concise 10-year follow-up results. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the 71 patients in the previous randomized clinical trial, comparing clinical outcomes, revisions, reoperations, and implant survivorship between the 2-incision and the mini-posterior THAs. RESULTS: At the most recent follow-up, the mean Harris hip score was 85 in the 2-incision group and 87 in the mini-posterior group (P = .4). There were 4 revisions and 2 reoperations (16%) in the 2-incision group vs 1 revision and 3 reoperations (11%) in the mini-posterior group (P = .5). Ten-year survivorship free of aseptic revision or reoperation was 77% in the 2-incision group vs 90% in the mini-posterior group (P = .15). CONCLUSION: There were no improvements in early or midterm clinical outcomes with the 2-incision technique. However, there was a clinical trend toward a higher rate of aseptic revisions in the 2-incision THA group.
引用
- Abdel MP, Chalmers BP, Trousdale RT, et al. Randomized Clinical Trial of 2-Incision vs Mini-Posterior Total Hip Arthroplasty: Differences Persist at 10 Years. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28487089. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.04.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。