文献速递运动医学创伤骨科

损伤后运动与富血小板血浆治疗改善大鼠骨骼肌愈合但联合应用无协同作用

Postinjury Exercise and Platelet-Rich Plasma Therapies Improve Skeletal Muscle Healing in Rats But Are Not Synergistic When Combined.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2017-04-28

研究将40只骨骼肌损伤大鼠分为5组,分别接受单次超声引导下肌内注射富血小板血浆(PRP)、每日运动训练或两者联合,并设未治疗与生理盐水注射对照。PRP与运动均改善肌肉力量、促进再生并减少瘢痕形成,但联合应用无协同效应,PRP未对运动疗法产生额外益处。

要点

  • PRP注射与运动训练均改善损伤骨骼肌的肌力恢复、再生标志物与瘢痕形成。
  • 运动训练在肌力恢复、肌纤维横截面积增加与瘢痕减少方面优于PRP注射。
  • PRP与运动联合应用无协同效应,PRP未对运动疗法产生额外益处。

核心结论

  • 肌内注射PRP与尤其是跑台运动可改善模拟运动员运动性肌肉损伤的大鼠模型损伤骨骼肌的组织学结果与力量恢复。
  • 两种治疗联合应用时无协同效应,提示PRP在运动疗法治疗损伤骨骼肌中未增加任何有益效应。

研究设计与样本

  • 对照实验室研究。
  • 共40只大鼠随机分为5组:损伤后接受单次PRP注射组、每日运动训练组、PRP注射联合每日运动训练组、未治疗对照组及肌内注射生理盐水对照组。
  • 损伤模型为内侧腓肠肌损伤;伤后24小时行超声引导下肌内PRP注射,运动训练持续2周;伤后2周测定肌力并取肌肉行组织学与免疫荧光显微镜评估。

主要发现

  • PRP组血小板浓度较全血高4.8倍;PRP组、PRP-联合组与运动组分别约18%、20%和30%的大鼠最大强直力(TetF)改善。
  • PRP组、PRP-联合组与运动组肌纤维横截面积分别增加1.5倍、2倍和2.5倍;瘢痕形成分别减少20%、34%和41%。
  • 运动治疗组(PRP-联合组与运动组)发育型肌球蛋白重链(dMHC)阳性再生纤维百分比显著降低,dMHC表达分别下降35%和47%。
  • 肌肉再生标志物dMHC与瘢痕标志物I型胶原显示所受治疗加速大鼠肌肉愈合过程。

临床怎么用

  • 作者指出本研究证明早期主动康复方案或单次肌内PRP注射对肌肉恢复的有效性。
  • 作者指出联合应用时PRP注射对早期主动康复的结果产生不利影响,或可解释PRP在坚持早期主动 mobilization 康复方案的随机临床试验中失败的原因。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Skeletal muscle injuries are the most common sports-related injury and a major concern in sports medicine. The effect of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections on muscle healing is still poorly understood, and current data are inconclusive. PURPOSE: To evaluate the effects of an ultrasound-guided intramuscular PRP injection, administered 24 hours after injury, and/or posttraumatic daily exercise training for 2 weeks on skeletal muscle healing in a recently established rat model of skeletal muscle injury that highly mimics the muscle trauma seen in human athletes. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: A total of 40 rats were assigned to 5 groups. Injured rats (medial gastrocnemius injury) received a single PRP injection (PRP group), daily exercise training (Exer group), or a combination of a single PRP injection and daily exercise training (PRP-Exer group). Untreated and intramuscular saline-injected animals were used as controls. Muscle force was determined 2 weeks after muscle injury, and muscles were harvested and evaluated by means of histological assessment and immunofluorescence microscopy. RESULTS: Both PRP (exhibiting 4.8-fold higher platelet concentration than whole blood) and exercise training improved muscle strength (maximum tetanus force, TetF) in approximately 18%, 20%, and 30% of rats in the PRP, PRP-Exer, and Exer groups, respectively. Specific markers of muscle regeneration (developmental myosin heavy chain, dMHC) and scar formation (collagen I) demonstrated the beneficial effect of the tested therapies in accelerating the muscle healing process in rats. PRP and exercise treatments stimulated the growth of newly formed regenerating muscle fibers (1.5-, 2-, and 2.5-fold increase in myofiber cross-sectional area in PRP, PRP-Exer, and Exer groups, respectively) and reduced scar formation in injured skeletal muscle (20%, 34%, and 41% of reduction in PRP, PRP-Exer, and Exer groups, respectively). Exercise-treated muscles (PRP-Exer and Exer groups) had significantly reduced percentage of dMHC-positive regenerating fibers (35% and 47% decrease in dMHC expression, respectively), indicating that exercise therapies accelerated the muscle healing process witnessed by the more rapid replacement of the embryonic-developmental myosin isoform by mature muscle myosin isoforms. CONCLUSION: Intramuscular PRP injection and, especially, treadmill exercise improve histological outcome and force recovery of the injured skeletal muscle in a rat injury model that imitates sports-related muscle injuries in athletes. However, there was not a synergistic effect when both treatments were combined, suggesting that PRP does not add any beneficial effect to exercise-based therapy in the treatment of injured skeletal muscle. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This study demonstrates the efficacy of an early active rehabilitation protocol or single intramuscular PRP injection on muscle recovery. The data also reveal that the outcome of the early active rehabilitation is adversely affected by the PRP injection when the two therapies are combined, and this could explain why PRP therapies have failed in randomized clinical trials where the athletes have adhered to postinjection rehabilitation protocols based on the principle of early, active mobilization.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Contreras-Muñoz P, Torrella JR, Serres X, et al. Postinjury Exercise and Platelet-Rich Plasma Therapies Improve Skeletal Muscle Healing in Rats But Are Not Synergistic When Combined. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28453295. doi:10.1177/0363546517702864

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。