FIFA 11+ 损伤预防计划能否降低男性足球运动员前交叉韧带损伤的发生率?
这项前瞻性整群随机对照试验在 61 支美国大学体育协会一级和二级男子足球队中开展一个赛季,评估 FIFA 11+ 动态热身计划对前交叉韧带损伤的影响。结果显示干预组前交叉韧带损伤比例低于对照组(RR 0.236,95%CI 0.193-0.93,p<0.001),需治疗人数为 70;二级联赛干预组损伤更少,但比赛与训练场景、场上位置、场地类型等分层比较多数未达统计学显著。
要点
- 干预组前交叉韧带损伤比例 16%(3/19)低于对照组 84%(16/19),RR 0.236,95%CI 0.193-0.93,p<0.001,需治疗人数 70。
- 二级联赛干预组前交叉韧带损伤 0.35%(1/10)低于对照组 1.35%(9/10),RR 0.12,95%CI 0.02-0.93,p=0.042。
- 比赛与训练场景、场上位置、一级联赛、草皮与人工草皮的分层比较多数未达统计学显著。
核心结论
- 作者认为,FIFA 11+ 计划若正确实施,有可能降低竞技足球运动员前交叉韧带损伤的发生率。
- 作者认为,该计划还可能促进损伤预防方案的开发与推广,并可能降低持续使用该计划的运动员的风险。
- 作者指出,需进一步研究分析该计划实施的成本效益以及 FIFA 11+ 在女大学生足球队列中的效果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为前瞻性整群随机对照试验,在一个竞技足球赛季内于 61 支美国大学体育协会一级和二级男子足球队中开展。
- FIFA 11+ 为 15 至 20 分钟的场上动态热身计划,于训练和比赛前使用,并在整个赛季作为干预措施。
- 共 65 支队伍被随机分组:对照组 34 支(850 名球员),干预组 31 支(675 名球员);4 支干预队伍未完成研究且未提交数据,符合方案分析降至 61 支队伍。
主要发现
- 干预组发生膝关节损伤的运动员比例 25%(34/136)低于对照组 75%(102/136),RR 0.42,95%CI 0.29-0.61,p<0.001。
- 前交叉韧带损伤方面,干预组 16%(3/19)低于对照组 84%(16/19),RR 0.236,95%CI 0.193-0.93,需治疗人数 70,p<0.001。
- 比赛场景干预组 1.055%(3/15)与对照组 1.80%(12/15)比较,RR 0.31,95%CI 0.09-1.11,p=0.073;训练场景干预组 0%(0/4)与对照组 0.60%(4/4)比较,RR 0.14,95%CI 0.01-2.59,p=0.186,均未达统计学显著。
- 按场上位置分层,前锋、中场、后卫、守门员的损伤发生率或损伤数在两组间均无差异(p=0.327)。
- 一级联赛干预组前交叉韧带损伤 0.70%(2/9)与对照组 1.05%(7/9)比较,RR 0.30,95%CI 0.06-1.45,p=0.136;二级联赛干预组 0.35%(1/10)低于对照组 1.35%(9/10),RR 0.12,95%CI 0.02-0.93,p=0.042。
局限性
- 4 支干预队伍因指出完成计划时间不足而未完成研究且未提交数据,符合方案分析样本因此减少至 61 支队伍。
- 比赛与训练场景、场上位置、一级联赛、草皮与人工草皮的分层比较多数未达统计学显著,原文作者以「With the numbers available」和「With the data that were available」限定。
- 作者在结论中指出需进一步研究分析该计划实施的成本效益以及 FIFA 11+ 在女大学生足球队列中的效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The FIFA 11+ injury prevention program has been shown to decrease the risk of soccer injuries in men and women. The program has also been shown to decrease time loss resulting from injury. However, previous studies have not specifically investigated how the program might impact the rate of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury in male soccer players. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purpose of this study was to examine if the FIFA 11+ injury prevention program can (1) reduce the overall number of ACL injuries in men who play competitive college soccer and whether any potential reduction in rate of ACL injuries differed based on (2) game versus practice setting; (3) player position; (4) level of play (Division I or II); or (5) field type. METHODS: This study was a prospective cluster randomized controlled trial, which was conducted in 61 Division I and Division II National Collegiate Athletic Association men's soccer teams over the course of one competitive soccer season. The FIFA 11+ is a 15- to 20-minute on-the-field dynamic warm-up program used before training and games and was utilized as the intervention throughout the entire competitive season. Sixty-five teams were randomized: 34 to the control group (850 players) and 31 to the intervention group (675 players). Four intervention teams did not complete the study and did not submit their data, noting insufficient time to complete the program, reducing the number for per-protocol analysis to 61. Compliance to the FIFA 11+ program, athletic exposures, specific injuries, ACL injuries, and time loss resulting from injury were collected and recorded using a secure Internet-based system. At the end of the season, the data in the injury surveillance system were crosshatched with each individual institution's internal database. At that time, the certified athletic trainer signed off on the injury collection data to confirm their accuracy and completeness. RESULTS: A lower proportion of athletes in the intervention group experienced knee injuries (25% [34 of 136]) compared with the control group (75% [102 of 136]; relative risk [RR], 0.42; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.29-0.61; p < 0.001). When the data were stratified for ACL injury, fewer ACL injuries were reported in the intervention group (16% [three of 19]) compared with the control group (84% [16 of 19]), accounting for a 4.25-fold reduction in the likelihood of incurring ACL injury (RR, 0.236; 95% CI, 0.193-0.93; number needed to treat = 70; p < 0.001). With the numbers available, there was no difference between the ACL injury rate within the FIFA 11+ group and the control group with respect to game and practice sessions (games-intervention: 1.055% [three of 15] versus control: 1.80% [12 of 15]; RR, 0.31; 95% CI, 0.09-1.11; p = 0.073 and practices-intervention: 0% [zero of four] versus control: 0.60% [four of four]; RR, 0.14; 95% CI, 0.01-2.59; p = 0.186). With the data that were available, there were no differences in incidence rate (IR) or injury by player position for forwards (IR control = 0.339 versus IR intervention = 0), midfielders (IR control = 0.54 versus IR intervention = 0.227), defenders (IR control = 0.339 versus IR intervention = 0.085), and goalkeepers (IR control = 0.0 versus IR intervention = 0.0) (p = 0.327). There were no differences in the number of ACL injuries for the Division I intervention group (0.70% [two of nine]) compared with the control group (1.05% [seven of nine]; RR, 0.30; CI, 0.06-1.45; p = 0.136). However, there were fewer ACL injuries incurred in the Division II intervention group (0.35% [one of 10]) compared with the control group (1.35% [nine of 10]; RR, 0.12; CI, 0.02-0.93; p = 0.042). There was no difference between the number of ACL injuries in the control group versus in the intervention group that occurred on grass versus turf (Wald chi square [1] = 0.473, b = 0.147, SE = 0.21, p = 0.492). However, there were more ACL injuries that occurred on artificial turf identified in the control group (1.35% [nine of 10]) versus the intervention group (0.35% [one of 10]; RR, 0.14; 95% CI, 0.02-1.10; p = 0.049). CONCLUSIONS: This program, if implemented correctly, has the potential to decrease the rate of ACL injury in competitive soccer players. In addition, this may also enhance the development and dissemination of injury prevention protocols and may mitigate risk to athletes who utilize the program consistently. Further studies are necessary to analyze the cost-effectiveness of the program implementation and to analyze the efficacy of the FIFA 11+ in the female collegiate soccer cohort. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.
引用
- Silvers-Granelli HJ, Bizzini M, Arundale A, et al. Does the FIFA 11+ Injury Prevention Program Reduce the Incidence of ACL Injury in Male Soccer Players? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28389864. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5342-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。