部分厚度软骨丢失患者行单髁膝关节置换术后中期随访结果不佳
该研究纳入2002年至2014年间94例因部分厚度软骨丢失行内侧单髁膝关节置换术(UKA)的连续病例,平均随访6年,并与全厚度软骨丢失的UKA按1:2倾向性评分匹配。结果显示部分厚度软骨丢失组术后1年、2年和5年功能结局显著更差,再手术率是全厚度丢失组的三倍,作者认为内侧UKA应仅用于股骨和胫骨均为全厚度软骨丢失的患者。
要点
- 部分厚度软骨丢失组UKA术后1、2、5年功能结局显著差于全厚度丢失组。
- 部分厚度丢失组再手术率为全厚度丢失组的三倍,其中四分之三为因持续疼痛行关节镜探查。
- 作者认为内侧UKA应仅用于股骨和胫骨均为全厚度软骨丢失的患者。
核心结论
- 作者认为内侧UKA应保留用于股骨和胫骨均为全厚度软骨丢失的患者。
- 部分厚度软骨丢失患者中虽有人获得良好结果,但目前无法识别这部分患者,且MRI无帮助且具有误导性。
研究设计与样本
- 2002年至2014年间,90例患者共94例因部分厚度软骨丢失行内侧UKA的连续病例,独立随访平均6年(1至13年)。
- 按年龄、性别和术前牛津膝关节评分(OKS)以1:2倾向性评分匹配全厚度软骨丢失的UKA。
- 36例(36膝)有术前MRI的部分厚度软骨丢失患者亚组用于分析MRI预测因素。
主要发现
- 部分厚度软骨丢失组术后1年、2年和5年功能结局显著差于全厚度丢失组。
- 部分厚度丢失组中四分之一结果为一般或差,五分之一未达到OKS从基线4分及以上的临床显著改善,为全厚度丢失组的两倍。
- 两组假体生存率无差异,但部分厚度丢失组再手术率高三倍,其中四分之三再手术为因持续疼痛行关节镜。
- 与获得优良结果者相比,获得一般或差结果的部分厚度软骨丢失患者更年轻且术前功能评分更差,其他基线人口学特征无差异。
- MRI所见全厚度软骨丢失、软骨下骨髓水肿、滑膜炎或积液未提供额外预后信息。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为内侧UKA应保留用于股骨和胫骨均为全厚度软骨丢失的患者。
- 作者指出部分厚度软骨丢失患者中虽有人获得良好结果,但目前无法识别,且此时MRI无帮助且具有误导性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: While medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) is indicated for patients with full-thickness cartilage loss, it is occasionally used to treat those with partial-thickness loss. The aim of this study was to investigate the five-year outcomes in a consecutive series of UKAs used in patients with partial thickness cartilage loss in the medial compartment of the knee. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 2002 and 2014, 94 consecutive UKAs were undertaken in 90 patients with partial thickness cartilage loss and followed up independently for a mean of six years (1 to 13). These patients had partial thickness cartilage loss either on both femur and tibia (13 knees), or on either the femur or the tibia, with full thickness loss on the other surface of the joint (18 and 63 knees respectively). Using propensity score analysis, these patients were matched 1:2 based on age, gender and pre-operative Oxford Knee Score (OKS) with knees with full thickness loss on both the femur and tibia. The functional outcomes, implant survival and incidence of re-operations were assessed at one, two and five years post-operatively. A subgroup of 36 knees in 36 patients with partial thickness cartilage loss, who had pre-operative MRI scans, was assessed to identify whether there were any factors identified on MRI that predicted the outcome. RESULTS: Knees with partial thickness cartilage loss had significantly worse functional outcomes at one, two and five years post-operatively compared with those with full thickness loss. A quarter of knees with partial thickness loss had a fair or poor result and a fifth failed to achieve a clinically significant improvement in OKS from a baseline of four points or more; double that seen in knees with full thickness loss. Whilst there was no difference in implant survival between the groups, the rate of re-operation in knees with partial thickness loss was three times higher. Most of the re-operations (three-quarters), were arthroscopies for persistent pain. Compared with those achieving good or excellent outcomes, patients with partial thickness cartilage loss who achieved fair or poor outcomes were younger and had worse pre-operative functional scores. However, there were no other differences in the baseline demographics. MRI findings of full thickness cartilage loss, subchondral oedema, synovitis or effusion did not provide additional prognostic information. CONCLUSION: Medial UKA should be reserved for patients with full thickness cartilage loss on both the femur and tibia. Whilst some patients with partial thickness loss achieve a good result we cannot currently identify which these will be and in this situation MRI is unhelpful and misleading. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2017;99-B:475-82.
引用
- Hamilton TW, Pandit HG, Inabathula A, et al. Unsatisfactory outcomes following unicompartmental knee arthroplasty in patients with partial thickness cartilage loss: a medium-term follow-up. Bone Joint J. 2017. PMID: 28385936. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.99B4.BJJ-2016-1061.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。