患者体验:医师评分网站上骨科医生质量分析
研究分析了5个最繁忙的医师评分网站,评估网站细节、与共识核心指标差异及患者评价,并比较2016年美国新闻与世界报道排名前5的学术与非学术医院骨科医生。共纳入10所医院506名医生、27,792条患者评分与评论;无网站包含全部共识核心领域,骨科医生综合评分为5分中的4.1分,学术与非学术医生无显著差异,关节置换医生在2个网站上评论和评分数量更多。
要点
- 无医师评分网站包含全部共识核心领域,网站可靠性存疑。
- 两个网站未经同意自动生成医生档案。
- 骨科医生综合评分为5分中的4.1分。
核心结论
- 医师评分网站的可靠性存疑,因无网站包含全部共识核心领域;自动生成医生档案的现象存在;学术与非学术、关节置换与非关节置换医生之间未发现差异;机构自建网站可能有助于更好地推广和营销医生。
研究设计与样本
- 分析5个最繁忙的医师评分网站;3名评审员分析网站细节以与共识核心比较;评估2016年美国新闻与世界报道排名前5的学术和非学术医院的骨科医生,并分析机构自建评分网站;结果按学术与非学术、关节置换与非关节置换医生分层;共纳入10所学术和非学术附属医院的506名在职医生,产生27,792条患者评分和评论,涉及1404个账户。
主要发现
- 所有网站均具备的特征为执业地点、使用语言和患者体验。
- 两个网站未经同意自动生成医生档案。
- 无医师评分网站包含全部共识核心领域。
- 骨科医生综合评分为5分中的4.1分。
- 学术与非学术附属医生之间未发现显著差异;关节置换医生在2个网站上评论和评分数量更多。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: With the advent of the Consensus Core of Orthopedic Measures, arthroplasty surgeons are increasingly subjected to public performance reviews on physician-rating sites. Therefore, we evaluated (1) web site details of physician-rating sites, (2) differences between sites and the Consensus Core, (3) published patient experiences, (4) search rank among sites, and (5) differences between academic vs nonacademic and arthroplasty vs nonarthroplasty surgeons. METHODS: The 5 busiest physician-rating sites were analyzed. To compare physician-rating sites to the Consensus Core, 3 reviewers analyzed the web site details. To evaluate patient ratings and reviews, orthopedists from the top 5 academic and nonacademic hospitals (2016 US News & World Report) were analyzed. Institution-produced rating sites were also analyzed. Findings were stratified between academic vs nonacademic and arthroplasty vs nonarthroplasty surgeons. Five hundred and six staff surgeons across 10 academic and nonacademic affiliated hospitals yielded 27,792 patient-generated ratings and reviews for 1404 accounts. RESULTS: Features on all sites were practice location, languages spoken, and patient experience. Two sites autogenerated profiles of surgeons without consent. No physician-rating site contained all Consensus Core domains. The composite orthopedic surgeon rating was 4.1 of 5. No significant differences were found between academic and nonacademic affiliated surgeons. Arthroplasty surgeons had a greater number of reviews and ratings on 2 sites. CONCLUSION: Reliability of physician-rating sites is questionable, as none contained all Consensus Core domains. Autogeneration of surgeon profiles is occurring, and no differences between academic vs nonacademic or arthroplasty vs nonarthroplasty surgeons were found. Institution-produced sites may serve to better promote and market surgeons.
引用
- Ramkumar PN, Navarro SM, Chughtai M, et al. The Patient Experience: An Analysis of Orthopedic Surgeon Quality on Physician-Rating Sites. J Arthroplasty. 2017. PMID: 28455178. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2017.03.053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。