「红-黄-绿」:一项引导外科医生选择骨科植入物的举措的效果
本研究在本机构为6种常用骨科创伤装置建立「红-黄-绿」植入物选择工具,按成本将各装置选项分为绿色(首选供应商)、黄色(中间档)和红色(用于患者特定需求),并张贴于各骨科创伤手术室。实施后植入物使用从红色30%、黄色56%、绿色14%变为红色9%、黄色21%、绿色70%(p<0.0001),与供应商重新谈判后平均价格下降1.1%至22.4%,6种植入物平均支出下降20%,每年节省216,495美元。
要点
- 「红-黄-绿」工具实施后绿色植入物使用从14%升至70%,红色从30%降至9%(p<0.0001)。
- 实施后与供应商重新谈判,平均价格下降1.1%至22.4%。
- 研究期间6种植入物平均支出下降20%,每年节省216,495美元。
核心结论
- 在本机构设计并实施了「红-黄-绿」这一简单工具,引导外科医生选择较低成本植入物,同时不违反供应商保密条款、不限制外科医生可选择的植入物范围、不要求外科医生辨别复杂构造的价格。
- 实施后医院植入物支出下降,原因是外科医生增加首选供应商使用以及供应商之间竞争加剧导致总体价格降低。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究在本机构针对4家供应商为6种常用骨科创伤装置创建类似构造并确定成本,据此将每种装置可选方案分为绿色(首选供应商)、黄色(中间档)、红色(用于患者特定需求),并将「红-黄-绿」图表张贴于每间骨科创伤手术室。
- 研究比较了植入物选择工具实施前后的植入物使用模式,并评估了供应商合同价格变化及对本机构的总体节省。
主要发现
- 植入物使用从干预前红色30%、黄色56%、绿色14%显著变为干预后红色9%、黄色21%、绿色70%(p<0.0001)。
- 实施后与供应商重新谈判,观察到平均价格下降范围为1.1%至22.4%。
- 研究期间这6种植入物的平均支出下降20%,相当于每年节省216,495美元。
关键数值与推荐
- 植入物使用从干预前红色30%、黄色56%、绿色14%变为干预后红色9%、黄色21%、绿色70%(p<0.0001)。
- 实施后与供应商重新谈判,平均价格下降范围为1.1%至22.4%。
- 研究期间6种植入物平均支出下降20%,每年节省216,495美元。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic procedures are expensive, and devices account for a large proportion of the overall costs. Hospitals have employed a variety of strategies to decrease implant costs, but many center on restricting surgeon choice. At our institution, we developed an implant selection tool that guides surgeons toward more cost-effective implants, while minimally restricting choice. The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of this tool on preferred implant usage rates, vendor attitudes toward pricing structure, and hospital implant expenditures. METHODS: For 6 commonly used orthopaedic trauma devices, similar constructs were created for the 4 vendors used at our hospital, and the costs were determined. On the basis of these costs, the available options for each device type were categorized as "green" (preferred vendor), "yellow" (midrange), or "red" (used for patient-specific requirements). The "Red-Yellow-Green" chart was posted on the wall of each orthopaedic trauma operating room. To assess the effect of the tool, we compared implant usage patterns before and after implementation of the implant selection tool. We also assessed changes in vendor contract prices, as well as overall savings to our institution. RESULTS: Implant usage changed significantly from 30% "red," 56% "yellow," and 14% "green" prior to the intervention, to 9% "red," 21% "yellow," and 70% "green" after the intervention (p < 0.0001). As a result of price renegotiation with vendors following implementation, we observed average price decreases that ranged from 1.1% to 22.4%. Average expenditures on these 6 implants decreased 20% during the study period, which represented a savings of $216,495 per year. CONCLUSIONS: At our institution, we designed and implemented "Red-Yellow-Green," a simple tool that guides surgeons toward the selection of lower-cost implants without violating vendor confidentiality clauses, limiting the implants from which surgeons can choose, or requiring surgeons to discern the prices of complex constructs. Following implementation, hospital implant expenditures decreased as a result of a combination of increased preferred vendor usage by surgeons, as well as increased competition among vendors, which resulted in lower overall prices.
引用
- Okike K, Pollak R, O'Toole RV, et al. "Red-Yellow-Green": Effect of an Initiative to Guide Surgeon Choice of Orthopaedic Implants. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017. PMID: 28375897. doi:10.2106/JBJS.16.00271
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。