指南与共识运动医学创伤骨科关节外科

肌肉骨骼软组织损伤与疾患临床实践指南的系统评价与评估

A Systematic Review and Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Musculoskeletal Soft Tissue Injuries and Conditions.
指南 / 共识 · Am J Sports Med · 2016-10-17

该系统评价由2名评审独立筛选2014年1月1日前发表的肌肉骨骼软组织损伤与疾患临床实践指南,最终纳入17部指南,由6名不同临床背景的评审使用AGREE II工具评分。总体质量参差不齐但多数(16/17)未达缺陷水平(>50%),仅在「适用性」和「编辑独立性」领域存在缺陷;美国骨科医师学会(AAOS)指南得分显著高于总均分。

要点

  • 17部指南中16部总体质量未达缺陷水平(>50%),但「适用性」与「编辑独立性」领域存在缺陷。
  • AAOS指南评分显著高于总均分(141.4 vs 108.0)。
  • 多数指南集中于膝、踝或肩,其他解剖部位指南尚缺。

核心结论

  • 运动医学临床实践指南总体质量参差不齐但一般未达缺陷水平,仅在适用性和编辑独立性方面存在缺陷。
  • 编辑独立性差导致的偏倚是值得关注的问题。
  • 作者建议未来指南作者关注这些领域,并使用现有最高质量指南或AGREE II工具作为模板。
  • 需要针对膝、踝、肩以外解剖部位的指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统评价:2名评审独立筛选2014年1月1日前发表的临床实践指南,排除聚焦受伤工人、放射学标准、内科病理或中轴骨骼(背/颈)的指南。
  • 最终纳入17部指南,由6名不同临床背景的评审使用AGREE II工具评分,低于50%视为缺陷。
  • 评分按发布机构和解剖部位分层,采用Kruskal-Wallis检验比较,Spearman相关系数评估评审者间一致性范围。

主要发现

  • 评审者间一致性较强(r=0.548-0.740),非手术评审者平均总分107.8与手术评审者109.3之间无统计学差异。
  • 17部指南中16部总体质量>50%(未达缺陷水平),但「适用性」和「编辑独立性」领域存在缺陷。
  • 膝、肩、足/踝或慢性病指南之间未发现差异。
  • AAOS指南评分显著高于总均分(141.4 vs 108.0)。

关键数值与推荐

  • AGREE II评分低于50%判定为缺陷。
  • 非手术评审者平均总分107.8 vs 手术评审者109.3,无统计学差异。
  • 评审者间一致性r=0.548-0.740。
  • AAOS指南评分141.4 vs 总均分108.0,AAOS显著更高。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) are published by several sports medicine institutions. A systematic evaluation can help identify the highest quality CPGs for clinical use and identify any deficiencies that remain. PURPOSE: To identify and appraise CPGs relevant to clinical sports medicine professionals. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review. METHODS: Predetermined selection criteria were utilized by 2 reviewers who independently identified published CPGs before January 1, 2014. CPGs were excluded if they focused on injured workers, radiological criteria, medical pathology, or the axial skeleton (back/neck). The remaining guidelines were scored by 6 reviewers with different clinical backgrounds using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II). Scores lower than 50% indicated deficiency. Scores were also stratified by the publishing institution and anatomic location and compared using Kruskal-Wallis tests. The Spearman correlation coefficient was used to assess the range of interobserver agreement between the evaluators. RESULTS: Seventeen CPGs met the inclusion criteria. The majority of guidelines pertained to the knee, ankle, or shoulder. Interobserver agreement was strong ( r = 0.548-0.740), and mean total scores between nonsurgical (107.8) and surgical evaluators (109.3) were not statistically different. Overall guideline quality was variable but not deficient for 16 of 17 guidelines (>50%), except regarding clinical "applicability" and "editorial independence." No difference was found between CPGs of the knee, shoulder, foot/ankle, or chronic conditions. However, CPG publishing institutions had significantly different scores; the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) guidelines scored significantly higher (141.4) than the total mean score (108.0). CONCLUSION: The overall quality of sports medicine CPGs was variable but generally not deficient, except regarding applicability and editorial independence. Bias through poor editorial independence is a concern. To improve future guideline quality, authors should pay particular attention to these areas and use existing highest quality guidelines, or the AGREE II instrument, as templates. CPGs dedicated to anatomic areas other than the knee, ankle, and shoulder are needed.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pincus D, Kuhn JE, Sheth U, et al. A Systematic Review and Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Musculoskeletal Soft Tissue Injuries and Conditions. Am J Sports Med. 2016. PMID: 28298051. doi:10.1177/0363546516667903

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。