不愈合的肩袖撕裂进展对肩部疼痛和功能有何影响
回顾性分析442例关节镜下肩袖修复患者,术后6个月MRI评估愈合与撕裂大小变化,随访至少2年。愈合组肩部功能与肌力优于未愈合组,疼痛无差异;未愈合组中撕裂缩小者功能与肌力优于撕裂增大者,但差异未达临床重要差异。
要点
- 愈合组肩部功能与肌力优于未愈合组,但疼痛无显著差异。
- 未愈合组中撕裂缩小者功能与肌力优于撕裂增大者,但未达临床重要差异。
- 撕裂增大者术后6个月至末次随访屈曲与外旋肌力无改善。
核心结论
- 关节镜下肩袖修复后肌腱愈合者肩部功能优于未愈合者。
- 未愈合者中术后6个月MRI显示撕裂缩小者肩部功能与肌力优于撕裂增大者,但差异未达临床重要差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,2008年5月至2012年12月本院647例全层肩袖撕裂行关节镜下修复,442例(68%)具备完整MRI与临床资料纳入,随访至少2年(平均33±4个月,范围24-43个月)。
- 术后6个月MRI评估肌腱愈合与撕裂大小变化,82/442(19%)未愈合,其中45例(55%)撕裂缩小、37例(45%)撕裂增大。
主要发现
- 愈合组 vs 未愈合组:ASES评分93±5 vs 89±8(均差4,95%CI 3-5,p<0.001),Constant评分91±5 vs 85±8(均差6,95%CI 4-7,p<0.001)。
- 愈合组 vs 未愈合组肌力:屈曲96%±7% vs 85%±12%(均差11%,95%CI 9%-13%,p<0.001),外旋92%±8% vs 80%±12%(均差11%,95%CI 9%-14%,p<0.001),内旋97%±8% vs 92%±8%(均差5%,95%CI 3%-7%,p<0.001)。
- 愈合组 vs 未愈合组VAS疼痛评分0.9±0.8 vs 1.0±0.8(均差0.2,95%CI 0.0-0.4,p=0.226),无显著差异。
- 撕裂缩小组 vs 撕裂增大组:ASES评分91±6 vs 86±8(p=0.001),Constant评分88±6 vs 82±9(p=0.003),屈曲肌力91%±9% vs 78%±11%(p<0.001),外旋肌力86%±10% vs 73%±11%(p<0.001)。
- 撕裂增大组术后6个月至末次随访:屈曲肌力78%±11% vs 78%±11%(p=0.806),外旋肌力74%±12% vs 73%±11%(p=0.149),均无改善。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There have been numerous reports of clinical outcomes associated with tendon healing after repair that suggest a nonhealed tendon has a negative effect on postoperative clinical outcomes. However, to our knowledge, there has been no report on the relationship between tear size progression of nonhealed tendons and clinical outcomes. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Do patients with healed arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs have better outcomes, less pain, and more strength than patients whose repair did not heal? (2) In patients with nonhealed rotator cuff tendons, does tear size progression (increase or decrease) affect outcomes, pain, and strength? (3) Is there continued improvement beyond 6 months in outcomes, pain, and strength; and how do the improvements differ based on whether the tear size has increased or decreased? METHODS: Between May 2008 and December 2012, 647 patients underwent arthroscopic rotator cuff repair for full-thickness tears at our institution. Of those, 442 patients (68%) had all MRI and clinical information available to permit inclusion in this retrospective study at a minimum of 2 years followup (mean, 33 ± 4 months; range, 24-43 months). Healing of the repaired tendon and tear size progression were assessed using MRI at 6 months postoperatively. Eighty-two of 442 tears (19%) were not healed. Of the nonhealed tears, 45 (55%) had a decrease and 37 (45%) had an increase in tear size. Shoulder function outcomes using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeon (ASES) and Constant scores and pain severity using VAS scores were evaluated preoperatively, at 6 months postoperatively, and at the latest followup. Isometric muscle strength was measured at 6 months postoperatively and at the latest followup. RESULTS: Compared with patients with nonhealed tendons after arthroscopic rotator cuff repair, patients with healed repairs had improved ASES scores (healed, 93 ± 5; nonhealed, 89 ± 8; mean difference, 4; 95% CI, 3-5; p < 0.001), better Constant scores (healed, 91 ± 5; nonhealed, 85 ± 8; mean difference, 6; 95% CI, 4-7; p < 0.001), and greater strength ([flexion: healed, 96% ± 7%; nonhealed, 85% ± 12%; mean difference, 11%; 95% CI, 9%-13%; p < 0.001]; [external rotation: healed, 92% ± 8%; nonhealed, 80% ± 12%; mean difference, 11%; 95% CI, 9%-14%; p < 0.001]; [internal rotation: healed, 97% ± 8%; nonhealed, 92% ± 8%; mean difference, 5%; 95% CI, 3%-7%; p < 0.001]); however there was no difference in pain level based on VAS scores (healed, 0.9 ± 0.8; nonhealed, 1.0 ± 0.8; mean difference, 0.2; 95% CI, 0.0-0.4; p = 0.226). Compared with patients with increased tear size, patients with decreased tear size had better ASES scores (decreased, 91 ± 6; increased, 8 6 ± 8; p = 0.001), improved Constant scores (decreased, 88 ± 6; increased, 82 ± 9; p = 0.003), greater flexion strength (decreased, 91% ± 9%; increased, 78% ± 11%; p < 0.001), and greater external rotation strength (decreased, 86% ± 10%; increased, 73% ± 11%; p < 0.001). However, the difference does not seem to meet a minimal clinically important difference. Patients with increased tear size differed from those with decreased tear size with respect to flexion and external rotation strength where the former had no improvement. There was no improvement in flexion (6 months, 78% ± 11%; latest followup, 78% ± 11%; p = 0.806) and external rotation strength (6 months, 74% ± 12%; latest followup, 73% ± 11%; p = 0.149). CONCLUSIONS: Patients who had healed tendons after arthroscopic rotator cuff repair had better shoulder function than patients who had nonhealed tendons. Among patients with nonhealed rotator cuff tendons after surgery, those with decreased tear size, observed on their 6-month postoperative MRI, compared with their initial tear size, showed better shoulder function and muscle strength than those with increased tear size beyond 6 months. Although results are statistically different, they seem insufficient to achieve clinically important differences. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Jeon YS, Kim RG, Shin SJ, et al. What Influence Does Progression of a Nonhealing Rotator Cuff Tear Have on Shoulder Pain and Function? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28290117. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5251-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。