绵羊模型中肩袖肌腱松解和/或去神经支配相关的肌肉退变
研究在18只瑞士高山绵羊的冈下肌模型上,比较肌腱松解、肩胛上神经切断或两者联合后16周的肌肉退变模式。神经切断组和联合组肌肉体积下降较单纯肌腱松解组更显著,但三组肌内脂肪含量无显著差异。去神经支配导致羽状角减小、肌纤维横截面积降低及慢-快型转化,整体萎缩更显著。
要点
- 神经切断后冈下肌体积降至原始的47%±7%,显著低于单纯肌腱松解组的78%±11%。
- 三组术后16周肌内脂肪含量无显著差异(肌腱松解组50%±9%、神经切断组40%±11%、联合组46%±10%)。
- 去神经支配导致肌纤维羽状角减小、横截面积降低及慢-快型转化,萎缩更显著。
核心结论
- 尚不清楚哪一实验组(单纯肌腱松解或肌腱松解联合神经切断)最能准确反映特定病例的临床情景,但这些发现为临床区分去神经支配或肩袖肌腱病变所致的肌肉改变提供了基线信息。
研究设计与样本
- 控制性实验室研究,从18只瑞士高山绵羊的冈下肌获取活检标本,术前及术后16周进行组织学分析。
- 动物分为三组:肌腱松解组(n=6)、肩胛上神经切断组(n=6)、肌腱松解+神经切断组(n=6)。
- 采用MRI和CT评估回缩程度(CT)、肌肉密度(CT)、体积(MRI T2)和脂肪分数(MRI Dixon),并用弹簧秤测量冈下肌硬度。
主要发现
- 术后16周,神经切断组冈下肌平均体积降至原始体积的47%±7%(P=0.001),联合组降至48%±13%(P=0.005),均较单纯肌腱松解组(78%±11%)下降更显著。
- 术后16周,三组肌内脂肪含量(CT/MRI Dixon)无显著差异:肌腱松解组50%±9%,神经切断组40%±11%,联合组46%±10%。
- 肌腱松解组与联合组的平均肌腱-肌肉回缩程度(CT)无显著差异(分别为5.8±1.0 cm和6.4±0.4 cm,P=0.26)。
- 附加神经切断后硬度增加最明显;去神经支配导致拉长的肌纤维羽状角减小、混合肌纤维平均横截面积降低、慢-快型转化及杂交纤维面积百分比增加,整体萎缩显著更重。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出尚不清楚哪一实验组(单纯肌腱松解或肌腱松解联合神经切断)最能准确反映特定病例的临床情景。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The effect of an additional neurological injury (suprascapular nerve traction injury) to a chronically retracted rotator cuff muscle is incompletely understood and warrants clarification. PURPOSE: To investigate the microscopic and macroscopic muscle degeneration patterns caused by tendon release and/or muscle denervation in a sheep rotator cuff model. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Infraspinatus muscle biopsy specimens (for histological analysis) were obtained from 18 Swiss alpine sheep before and 16 weeks after release of the infraspinatus tendon (tenotomy [T] group; n = 6), transection of the suprascapular nerve (neurectomy [N] group; n = 6), or tendon release plus nerve transection (tenotomy + neurectomy [T&N] group; n = 6). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) were used to assess retraction (CT), muscle density (CT), volume (MRI T2), and fat fraction (MRI Dixon). Stiffness of the infraspinatus was measured with a spring scale. RESULTS: At 16 weeks postoperatively, the mean infraspinatus muscle volume had decreased significantly more after neurectomy (to 47% ± 7% of the original volume; P = .001) and tenotomy plus neurectomy (48% ± 13%; P = .005) than after tenotomy alone (78% ± 11%). Conversely, the mean amount of intramuscular fat (CT/MRI Dixon) was not significantly different in the 3 groups (T group: 50% ± 9%; N group: 40% ± 11%; T&N group: 46% ± 10%) after 16 weeks. The mean myotendinous retraction (CT) was not significantly different in the T and T&N groups (5.8 ± 1.0 cm and 6.4 ± 0.4 cm, respectively; P = .26). Stiffness was, however, most increased after additional neurectomy. In contrast to muscle changes after tendon release, denervation of the muscle led to a decrease in the pennation angle of lengthened muscle fibers, with a reduced mean cross-sectional area of pooled muscle fibers, a slow- to fast-type transformation, and an increase in the area percentage of hybrid fibers, leading to overall significantly greater atrophy of the corresponding muscle. CONCLUSION: Although it is unclear which experimental group (T or T&N) most accurately reflects the clinical scenario in a given case, these findings provide baseline information for clinical differentiation between muscle changes caused by denervation or rotator cuff tendon lesions. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The findings of this study help to understand how and to which extent a neurological lesion of the supplying suprascapular nerve could influence the pattern of anatomic-physiological muscular changes after rotator cuff tendon tears.
引用
- Gerber C, Meyer DC, Flück M, et al. Muscle Degeneration Associated With Rotator Cuff Tendon Release and/or Denervation in Sheep. Am J Sports Med. 2016. PMID: 28272927. doi:10.1177/0363546516677254
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。