文献速递运动医学关节外科

ACL-SPORTS试验男性患者临床与功能主要结局报告:接受二级预防联合或不联合扰动训练的男性在ACL重建后1年和2年结局相似

Report of the Clinical and Functional Primary Outcomes in Men of the ACL-SPORTS Trial: Similar Outcomes in Men Receiving Secondary Prevention With and Without Perturbation Training 1 and 2 Years After ACL Reconstruction.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2017-01-01

该单盲随机临床试验纳入40名完成ACL重建康复的男性运动员,随机分为SAP组和SAP+PERT组,比较术后1年和2年的股四头肌力量、单腿跳跃对称性、患者报告结局、正常膝关节功能比例及通过重返运动标准的时间。结果显示两组间多数结局无显著差异,仅2年时SAP+PERT组正常膝关节功能人数较少(SAP 17/17 vs SAP+PERT 14/19,p=0.03)。作者认为扰动训练可能未对SAP基础方案带来额外获益。

要点

  • 两组股四头肌对称性和单腿跳跃对称性在1年和2年时均无显著差异。
  • 患者报告结局无临床意义差异。
  • 2年时SAP+PERT组正常膝关节功能比例较低(SAP 17/17 vs SAP+PERT 14/19,p=0.03)。

核心结论

  • 该随机试验发现,包含力量、敏捷性和二级预防的ACL康复方案与在此基础上增加扰动训练的方案之间差异很少。
  • 在膝关节功能和自我报告结局测量方面组间缺乏临床意义差异的情况下,结果表明扰动训练可能不会对ACL-SPORTS训练方案的力量、敏捷性和二级预防基础带来额外获益。

研究设计与样本

  • 单盲随机临床研究(ACL-SPORTS试验),纳入40名完成ACL重建康复并符合入组标准的男性(术后3-9个月,股四头肌力量肢体对称性>80%,无痛,全范围活动度,少量积液),随机分为SAP组或SAP+PERT组。
  • 由对分组设盲的研究者在术后1年和2年收集股四头肌力量、单腿跳跃、IKDC 2000主观膝关节表单、KOOS运动与娱乐及KOOS生活质量子量表。
  • 根据IKDC评分将运动员在每个时间点分类为正常或异常膝关节功能,并记录通过严格重返运动标准的时间。
  • 使用t检验、卡方检验和方差分析识别治疗组间随时间变化的差异。

主要发现

  • 股四头肌对称性组间无差异:1年时SAP=101%±14%,SAP+PERT=101%±14%;2年时SAP=103%±11%,SAP+PERT=98%±14%;1年组间平均差异0.4[-9.0至9.8],2年组间平均差异4.5[-4.3至13.1];1年至2年间平均差异:SAP=-1.0[-8.6至6.6],SAP+PERT=3.0[-4.3至10.3],p=0.45。
  • 单腿跳跃测试肢体对称性组间无差异。
  • 任何患者报告结局测量均无临床意义差异。
  • 1年时达到正常膝关节功能的运动员比例组间无差异(SAP 14/19,SAP+PERT 18/20,比值比0.31[0.5-19.0];p=0.18);然而2年时SAP+PERT组正常膝关节功能的运动员较少(SAP 17/17,SAP+PERT 14/19,p=0.03)。
  • 通过重返运动标准的时间组间无差异(SAP=325±199天,SAP+PERT=233±77天;平均差异92[-9至192],p=0.09)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Athletes often are cleared to return to activities 6 months after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction; however, knee function measures continue to improve up to 2 years after surgery. Interventions beyond standard care may facilitate successful return to preinjury activities and improve functional outcomes. Perturbation training has been used in nonoperative ACL injury and preoperative ACL reconstruction rehabilitation, but has not been examined in postoperative ACL reconstruction rehabilitation, specifically return to sport rehabilitation. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: The purpose of this study was to determine whether there were differences at 1 and 2 years after ACL reconstruction between the male SAP (strengthening, agility, and secondary prevention) and SAP+PERT (SAP protocol with the addition of perturbation training) groups with respect to (1) quadriceps strength and single-legged hop limb symmetry; (2) patient-reported knee outcome scores; (3) the proportion who achieve self-reported normal knee function; and (4) the time from surgery to passing return to sport criteria. METHODS: Forty men who had completed ACL reconstruction rehabilitation and met enrollment criteria (3-9 months after ACL reconstruction, > 80% quadriceps strength limb symmetry, no pain, full ROM, minimal effusion) were randomized into the SAP or SAP+PERT groups of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament-Specialised Post-Operative Return to Sports trial (ACL-SPORTS), a single-blind randomized clinical study of secondary prevention and return to sport. Quadriceps strength, single-legged hopping, the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) 2000 subjective knee form, Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS)-sports and recreation, and KOOS-quality-of-life subscales were collected 1 and 2 years after surgery by investigators blind to group. Athletes were categorized as having normal or abnormal knee function at each time point based on IKDC score, and the time until athletes passed strict return-to-sport criteria was also recorded. T-tests, chi square tests, and analyses of variance were used to identify differences between the treatment groups over time. RESULTS: There were no differences between groups for quadriceps symmetry (1 year: SAP = 101% ± 14%, SAP+PERT = 101% ± 14%; 2 years: SAP = 103% ± 11%, SAP+PERT = 98% ± 14%; mean differences between groups at 1 year: 0.4 [-9.0 to 9.8], 2 years = 4.5 [-4.3 to 13.1]; mean difference between 1 and 2 years: SAP = -1.0 [-8.6 to 6.6], SAP+PERT = 3.0 [-4.3 to 10.3], p = 0.45) or single-legged hop test limb symmetry. There were no clinically meaningful differences for any patient-reported outcome measures. There was no difference in the proportion of athletes in each group who achieved normal knee function at 1 year (SAP 14 of 19, SAP+PERT 18 of 20, odds ratio 0.31 [0.5-19.0]; p = 0.18); however, the SAP+PERT group had fewer athletes with normal knee function at 2 years (SAP 17 of 17, SAP+PERT 14 of 19, p = 0.03). There were no differences between groups in the time to pass return to sport criteria (SAP = 325 ± 199 days, SAP+PERT = 233 ± 77 days; mean difference 92 [-9 to 192], p = 0.09). CONCLUSIONS: This randomized trial found few differences between an ACL rehabilitation program consisting of strengthening, agility, and secondary prevention and one consisting of those elements as well as perturbation training. In the absence of clinically meaningful differences between groups in knee function and self-reported outcomes measures, the results indicate that perturbation training may not contribute additional benefit to the strengthening, agility, and secondary prevention base of the ACL-SPORTS training program. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Arundale AJH, Cummer K, Capin JJ, et al. Report of the Clinical and Functional Primary Outcomes in Men of the ACL-SPORTS Trial: Similar Outcomes in Men Receiving Secondary Prevention With and Without Perturbation Training 1 and 2 Years After ACL Reconstruction. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28224443. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5280-2

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。