ACL-SPORTS试验男性步态力学主要结局报告:伴或不伴扰动训练的二级预防在ACL重建后1年或2年未恢复步态对称性
40名男性ACL重建后随机分入SAP组或SAP+PERT组,在术后1年和2年进行步态分析。两组在生物力学步态变量上无差异,步态不对称在两组中均持续存在,从1年到2年虽有改善但仍有意义的持续不对称。
要点
- SAP与SAP+PERT组在术后1年和2年的生物力学步态变量上无差异。
- 两组在术后1年和2年均持续存在有临床意义的步态不对称。
- 从术后1年到2年步态不对称有改善,但两组仍有意义的不对称持续存在。
核心结论
- 包含或不包含扰动训练的综合渐进性重返运动训练方案在ACL重建后1年或2年未能恢复男性下肢对称性。
- 尽管步态不对称从术后1年到2年有改善,但两组中仍有意义的不对称持续存在。
- 为恢复ACL重建后的步态对称性,可能需要额外的干预措施。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,40名男性在ACL重建后随机分入SAP组或SAP+PERT组,于术后1年和2年进行步态分析。
- 入组条件包括达到≥80%股四头肌力量对称、少量膝关节积液、全范围活动度、无疼痛报告、完成跑步进阶(均在术后3至9个月之间)。
- 在评估的94名潜在合格男性运动员中,54名因预设原因被排除。
主要发现
- SAP组与SAP+PERT组在生物力学步态变量上无差异。
- SAP组支撑中期患肢膝关节活动度:1年15°±5°,2年16°±5°;SAP+PERT组:1年16°±5°,2年15°±4°;组间1年平均差异-1°(95%CI -5°至2°,p=0.49),2年平均差异1°(95%CI -2°至4°,p=0.54)。
- 术后1年,SAP组18例中11例、SAP+PERT组20例中11例在承重期出现膝关节活动度截断(OR 0.8,p=0.70);支撑中期SAP组18例中12例、SAP+PERT组20例中12例(OR 0.8,p=0.67)。
- 术后2年,承重期膝关节活动度截断SAP组17例中7例、SAP+PERT组19例中8例(OR 1.0,p=0.96);支撑中期SAP组17例中5例、SAP+PERT组19例中11例(OR 3.3,p=0.09)。
- 两组在步态不对称消除方面无差异,术后1年和2年两组步态不对称均大量持续存在。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,为恢复ACL重建后的步态对称性,可能需要额外的干预措施。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Movement asymmetries during walking are common after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and reconstruction and may influence the early development of posttraumatic osteoarthritis. Preoperative neuromuscular training (like perturbation training, which is neuromuscular training requiring selective muscle activation in response to surface perturbations) improves gait asymmetries and functional outcomes among people who are ACL-deficient, but the effect of postoperative perturbation training on gait mechanics after ACL reconstruction is unknown. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Among men undergoing ACL reconstruction, we sought to compare strength, agility, and secondary prevention (SAP) treatment with SAP plus perturbation training (SAP+PERT) with respect to (1) gait mechanics; and (2) elimination of gait asymmetries 1 and 2 years after ACL reconstruction. METHODS: Forty men were randomized into a SAP group or a SAP+PERT group after ACL reconstruction and before returning to preinjury activities. Participants were required to achieve ≥ 80% quadriceps muscle strength symmetry, minimal knee effusion, full ROM, no reports of pain, and completion of a running progression (all between 3 and 9 months postoperatively) before enrollment. Of 94 potentially eligible athletic male patients evaluated < 9 months after ACL reconstruction, 54 were excluded for prespecified reasons. Participants underwent motion analysis during overground walking at 1 and 2 years postoperatively. Variables of interest included (1) sagittal and frontal plane hip and knee angles and moments at peak knee flexion angle; (2) sagittal plane hip and knee angles and moments at peak knee extension angle; (3) sagittal plane hip and knee excursion during weight acceptance; and (4) sagittal plane hip and knee excursion during midstance. We also calculated the proportion of athletes in each group who walked with clinically meaningful interlimb asymmetry in sagittal plane hip and knee variables and compared these proportions using odds ratios. There was no differential loss to followup between groups. RESULTS: There were no differences between the SAP or SAP+PERT groups for the biomechanical gait variables. The involved limb's knee excursion during midstance for the SAP (mean ± SD: 1 year: 15° ± 5°; 2 years: 16° ± 5°) and SAP+PERT (1 year: 16° ± 5°; 2 years: 15° ± 4°) athletes was not different between groups at 1 year (mean difference: -1°; 95% confidence interval [CI], -5° to 2°; p = 0.49) or 2 years (mean difference: 1°; 95% CI, -2° to 4°; p = 0.54). There were no differences between SAP and SAP+PERT athletes regarding the elimination of gait asymmetries, and gait asymmetries persisted to a large degree in both groups 1 and 2 years postoperatively. At 1 year, 11 of 18 SAP and 11 of 20 SAP+PERT athletes walked with truncated knee excursions during weight acceptance (odds ratio: 0.8, p = 0.70) and midstance (SAP 12 of 18, SAP+PERT 12 of 20; odds ratio: 0.8, p = 0.67), whereas at 2 years postoperatively, truncated knee excursions during weight acceptance (SAP seven of 17, SAP+PERT eight of 19; odds ratio: 1.0, p = 0.96) and midstance (SAP five of 17, SAP+PERT 11 of 19; odds ratio: 3.3, p = 0.09) remained prevalent. CONCLUSIONS: We found that a comprehensive, progressive return-to-sport training program with or without perturbation was not effective at restoring interlimb symmetry among men 1 or 2 years after ACL reconstruction. Although gait asymmetries improved from 1 to 2 years postoperatively, meaningful asymmetries persisted in both groups. To restore gait symmetry after ACL reconstruction, additional interventions likely are necessary. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.
引用
- Capin JJ, Zarzycki R, Arundale A, et al. Report of the Primary Outcomes for Gait Mechanics in Men of the ACL-SPORTS Trial: Secondary Prevention With and Without Perturbation Training Does Not Restore Gait Symmetry in Men 1 or 2 Years After ACL Reconstruction. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28224442. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5279-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。