超声监测磁控生长棒撑开的学习曲线
本研究为前瞻性相关性分析,纳入2013年2月19日至2015年3月31日因脊柱侧凸接受磁控生长棒治疗的患者,共分析379次撑开事件。超声与X线测量撑开长度的平均差异为右侧棒-0.3 mm、左侧棒-0.1 mm;相关性随时间改善,在第二聚类(2013年10月16日至2014年5月20日)达到平台期,对应97至146次棒测量。
要点
- 超声与X线测量撑开长度的平均差异为右侧棒-0.3 mm、左侧棒-0.1 mm。
- 超声与X线测量的相关性随时间改善,在第二聚类达到平台期。
- 平台期对应97至146次棒测量,之后超声测量更可靠。
核心结论
- 超声与X线测量的相关性初始即合理,但随时间改善。
- 初始使用时,成功的撑开应与临床手感及超声确认相一致。
- 超声测量绝对值可能不准确并可能需要X线确认,但随着时间和经验积累,超声测量可更可靠。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性相关性分析,纳入接受磁控生长棒治疗脊柱侧凸的患者。
- 研究期为2013年2月19日至2015年3月31日,所有受试者以前瞻性方式连续招募。
- 仅纳入同时进行X线和超声测量的撑开事件进行分析,共分析379次撑开事件。
主要发现
- 超声与X线测量每次撑开事件的平均差异为右侧棒-0.3 mm、左侧棒-0.1 mm。
- 第一聚类(2013年2月19日至2013年10月15日)相关性为右侧棒0.612、左侧棒0.795。
- 第二聚类(2013年10月16日至2014年5月20日)相关性为右侧棒0.879、左侧棒0.918。
- 第三聚类(2014年5月21日至2015年3月31日)相关性为右侧棒0.956、左侧棒0.932。
- 在第二聚类观察到平台期,对应97至146次棒测量。
关键数值与推荐
- 超声与X线测量撑开长度的平均差异:右侧棒-0.3 mm,左侧棒-0.1 mm。
- 相关性第一聚类:右侧棒0.612,左侧棒0.795;第二聚类:右侧棒0.879,左侧棒0.918;第三聚类:右侧棒0.956,左侧棒0.932。
- 平台期出现在第二聚类,对应97至146次棒测量。
临床怎么用
- 初始使用超声监测时,成功的撑开应与临床手感及超声确认相一致。
- 超声测量绝对值可能不准确,可能需要X线确认。
- 随着时间和经验积累,超声测量可更可靠。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Prospective study. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether a learning curve exists for ultrasound measurement of magnetically controlled growing rod (MCGR) distractions. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: For patients managed by MCGRs, close monitoring of interval distraction length gains is important to determine whether the distractions are translating into actual spine growth. Radiographs are the criterion standard for measuring length gains, but ultrasound has been shown to be effective in monitoring distraction lengths without radiation exposure. It is, however, an operator-dependent tool and thus the accuracy of ultrasound measurement of distracted length may improve with experience. METHODS: This is a prospective correlation analysis of patients who underwent MCGR treatment for scoliosis. The study period was inclusive of 19th February 2013 to 31st March 2015. All subjects were consecutively recruited in a prospective manner. Data regarding date of the distraction visit, and the interval radiograph and ultrasound measurements of the distracted lengths were collected. Only those episodes with both radiograph and ultrasound performed were used for analysis. The mean differences in change of radiograph and ultrasound measurements were plotted to determine correlation differences and to observe for a learning curve. RESULTS: A total of 379 distraction episodes were analyzed. The mean differences between ultrasound and radiograph measurements per distraction episode were -0.3 mm for the right rod and -0.1 mm for the left rod. For learning curve analysis, there were three distinct timepoints in which the difference of correlation became significantly better and were described as clusters. The correlation in the first cluster (19th February 2013 to 15th October 2013) was 0.612 (right rod) and 0.795 (left rod), the second cluster (16th October 2013 to 20th May 2014) was 0.879 (right rod) and 0.918 (left rod), and the third cluster (21st May 2014 to 31st March 2015) was 0.956 (right rod) and 0.932 (left rod). Thus, a plateau was observed at the second cluster, which translated to 97 to 146 rod measurements. CONCLUSION: Correlation between radiograph and ultrasound measurements is reasonable to begin with but improves with time. During initial use, successful distractions should correlate between the clinical feel and ultrasound confirmation. Although the absolute value may not be accurate and may require radiographs to confirm, with time and experience, ultrasound measurements can then be more reliable. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3.
引用
- Cheung JPY, Yiu KKL, Bow C, et al. Learning Curve in Monitoring Magnetically Controlled Growing Rod Distractions With Ultrasound. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2017. PMID: 28187066. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000002114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。