文献速递手外科与足踝外科创伤骨科

从手到肘部手术相关随机对照试验的质量:文献批判性分析

The quality of randomised controlled trials involving surgery from the hand to the elbow: a critical analysis of the literature.
PubMed 文献 · Bone Joint J · 2017-01-01

该研究基于五年平均影响因子选取六本常发表上肢手术研究的期刊,用期刊专属检索式纳入62项随机对照试验(RCT),由三名盲法评审员以Jadad量表和修订版Coleman方法学评分(RCMS)评估质量。Jadad量表评定28项为高质量、34项为低质量;低分试验的方法学缺陷包括未报告入组率、无功效分析、未描述退出或脱落、未使用经验证的结果评估并由独立研究者实施。作者结论认为大量手、腕、肘手术RCT质量欠佳,即使证据等级高也应批判性评估设计与执行,方法学缺陷可能引入偏倚并导致统计功效不足。

要点

  • 62项手外科RCT中Jadad量表评定28项高质量、34项低质量。
  • 低分试验缺陷包括未报告入组率、无功效分析、未描述退出或脱落。
  • 低分试验还表现为未使用经验证的结果评估并由独立研究者实施。

核心结论

  • 按RCMS和Jadad量表评判,大量手、腕、肘手术RCT质量欠佳。
  • 即使证据等级高,也应批判性评估RCT的研究设计与执行。
  • 方法学缺陷可能引入偏倚并导致统计功效不足的研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于五年平均影响因子选取六本常发表上肢手术研究的期刊。
  • 采用期刊专属检索式纳入62项符合纳入标准的RCT。
  • 由三名盲法评审员使用Jadad量表和修订版Coleman方法学评分(RCMS)评估稿件质量。

主要发现

  • Jadad量表评定28项研究为高质量、34项为低质量。
  • 低分试验的方法学缺陷包括未报告入组率、无功效分析、未描述退出或脱落。
  • 低分试验还表现为未使用经验证的结果评估并由独立研究者实施。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: Our purpose was to determine the quality of current randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in hand surgery using standardised metrics. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Based on five-year mean impact factors, we selected the six journals that routinely publish studies of upper extremity surgery. Using a journal-specific search query, 62 RCTs met our inclusion criteria. Then three blinded reviewers used the Jadad and revised Coleman Methodology Score (RCMS) to assess the quality of the manuscripts. RESULTS: Based on the Jadad scale, 28 studies were of high quality and 34 were of low quality. Methodological deficiencies in poorly scoring trials included the absence of rate of enrolment, no power analysis, no description of withdrawal or dropout, and a failure to use validated outcomes assessments with an independent investigator. CONCLUSION: A large number of RCTs in hand, wrist, and elbow surgery were of suboptimal quality when judged against the RCMS and Jadad scales. Even with a high level of evidence, study design and execution of RCTs should be critically assessed. Methodological deficiencies may introduce bias and lead to statistically underpowered studies. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2017;99-B:94-9.

来源:Bone Joint J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kim JM, Zimmerman RM, Jones CM, et al. The quality of randomised controlled trials involving surgery from the hand to the elbow: a critical analysis of the literature. Bone Joint J. 2017. PMID: 28053263. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.99B1.BJJ-2016-0400.R1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。