前交叉韧带重建膝合并前外侧结构损伤是否需要前外侧韧带重建?旋转稳定性的机器人分析
研究利用六自由度机器人模拟器,在7具新鲜冷冻尸体膝关节上测试完整、前交叉韧带切断、前交叉韧带重建、前外侧韧带/髂胫束切断及前外侧韧带重建五种状态。结果显示前外侧韧带重建可纠正高屈曲角度下内旋限度的轻度异常,但对轴移试验中胫股间室移位无限制作用,仅适度降低前交叉韧带移植物受力,因此对常规附加前外侧韧带重建以纠正轴移异常的建议提出质疑。
要点
- 前外侧韧带/髂胫束切断后,5 N·m内旋扭矩下60°和90°屈曲内旋分别增加5.1°和6.7°。
- 轴移试验中外侧间室移位增加小于2 mm。
- 前外侧韧带重建对轴移试验中胫股间室移位无限制作用,仅适度降低移植物受力。
核心结论
- 前外侧韧带重建虽纠正了高屈曲角度下内旋限度的轻度异常改变,但对轴移试验中胫股间室移位无限制作用,且仅适度降低前交叉韧带移植物受力;因此,为纠正轴移异常而常规行前外侧韧带重建的建议受到质疑。
研究设计与样本
- 采用六自由度机器人模拟器,对7具新鲜冷冻尸体膝关节标本在5种测试条件下进行测试:完整、前交叉韧带切断、前交叉韧带重建、前外侧韧带/髂胫束切断及前外侧韧带重建。
- 在Lachman试验条件、5 N·m内旋扭矩及2种轴移模拟下测量内外侧胫股间室移位和内旋角度。
- 统计等效界值定义为2 mm和2°,以P < .05为等效。
主要发现
- 单束前交叉韧带重建恢复了Lachman试验下的中心胫骨移位和5 N·m内旋扭矩下的内旋(P < .05)。
- 前外侧韧带/髂胫束切断后,5 N·m内旋扭矩下60°和90°屈曲内旋分别增加5.1°(95%CI,3.6°至6.7°)和6.7°(95%CI,4.3°至9.1°)(P = .99)。
- 轴移试验中外侧间室移位增加小于2 mm。
- 前外侧韧带重建使60°和90°屈曲内旋恢复至前交叉韧带重建状态0.5°(95%CI,-1.9°至2.9°)和0.7°(95%CI,-2.0°至3.4°)以内(P < .05)。
- 前外侧韧带重建使前交叉韧带移植物受力在轴移试验中最多降低75 N,在内旋试验中最多降低81 N。
临床怎么用
- 前外侧韧带/髂胫束切断后旋转稳定性的微小改变似乎不支持在初次前交叉韧带损伤中常规附加前外侧韧带重建。
- 作者指出临床例外可能存在,如重度不稳的3级轴移膝和翻修膝。
- 作者同时担忧前外侧韧带重建可能对正常胫骨旋转造成过度约束。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The effect of an anterolateral ligament (ALL) reconstruction on rotational knee stability and corresponding anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) graft forces using multiple knee loading conditions including the pivot-shift phenomenon has not been determined. PURPOSE: First, to determine the rotational stability and ACL graft forces provided by an anatomic bone-patellar tendon-bone ACL reconstruction in the ACL-deficient knee alone and with an associated ALL/iliotibial band (ITB) injury. Second, to determine the added rotational stabilizing effect and reduction in ACL graft forces provided by an ALL reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: A 6 degrees of freedom robotic simulator was used to test 7 fresh-frozen cadaveric specimens during 5 testing conditions: intact, ACL-sectioned, ACL-reconstructed, ALL/ITB-sectioned, and ALL-reconstructed. Lateral and medial tibiofemoral compartment translations and internal tibial rotations were measured under Lachman test conditions, 5-N·m internal rotation, and 2 pivot-shift simulations. Statistical equivalence within 2 mm and 2° was defined as P < .05. RESULTS: Single-graft ACL reconstruction restored central tibial translation under Lachman testing and internal rotation under 5-N·m internal rotation torque ( P < .05). A modest increase in internal rotation under 5-N·m internal rotation torque occurred after ALL/ITB sectioning of 5.1° (95% CI, 3.6° to 6.7°) and 6.7° (95% CI, 4.3° to 9.1°) at 60° and 90° of flexion, respectively ( P = .99). Lateral compartment translation increases in the pivot-shift tests were <2 mm. ALL reconstruction restored internal rotation within 0.5° (95% CI, -1.9° to 2.9°) and 0.7° (95% CI, -2.0° to 3.4°) of the ACL-reconstructed state at 60° and 90° of flexion, respectively ( P < .05). The ALL procedure reduced ACL graft forces, at most, 75 N in the pivot-shift tests and 81 N in the internal rotation tests. CONCLUSION: Although the ALL reconstruction corrected the small abnormal changes in the internal rotation limit at high flexion angles, the procedure had no effect in limiting tibiofemoral compartment translations in the pivot-shift test and produced only modest decreases in ACL graft forces. Accordingly, the recommendation to perform an ALL reconstruction to correct pivot-shift abnormalities is questioned. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The small changes in rotational stability after ALL/ITB sectioning would not seem to warrant the routine addition of an ALL reconstruction in primary ACL injuries. Clinical exceptions may exist, as in grossly unstable grade 3 pivot-shift knees and revision knees. However, the concern exists of overconstraining normal tibial rotations.
引用
- Noyes FR, Huser LE, Jurgensmeier D, et al. Is an Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction Required in ACL-Reconstructed Knees With Associated Injury to the Anterolateral Structures? A Robotic Analysis of Rotational Knee Stability. Am J Sports Med. 2017. PMID: 28056513. doi:10.1177/0363546516682233
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。