文献速递运动医学关节外科

临界肩角是否与肩袖撕裂进展相关?

Does the Critical Shoulder Angle Correlate With Rotator Cuff Tear Progression?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2017-01-24

该回顾性纵向研究纳入313例无症状肩袖撕裂患者和119例对照,测量临界肩角(CSA)。撕裂组CSA高于对照组(34°±4° vs 32°±4°,平均差2.0°,95%CI 0.7°-3.2°,p=0.003),但CSA与基线撕裂大小、撕裂扩大及时间变化均无显著相关。作者认为CSA不太可能与肩袖疾病相关。

要点

  • 仅21%(326/1552)的X线片质量足以测量CSA。
  • 肩袖撕裂患者CSA高于对照(34°±4° vs 32°±4°,p=0.003),但差异小。
  • CSA与基线撕裂长度、宽度、撕裂扩大及时间变化均无显著相关。

核心结论

  • 即使采用纵向研究方案,多数X线片质量不足以测量CSA。
  • 有退行性肩袖疾病史的患者CSA值高于对照,但差异小,可能受测量误差影响,临床意义可能不重要。
  • CSA与撕裂大小或撕裂进展不相关,且似乎不随时间变化,结果提示CSA不太可能与肩袖疾病相关。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性比较纵向收集的数据,纳入无症状肩袖撕裂患者313例(评估1433张X线片),对照为肩袖正常且肩胛骨影像学正常的粘连性肩关节囊炎患者119例。
  • 两名观察者盲法测量CSA,仅纳入符合Suter-Henninger标准的X线片;最终分析撕裂组179例(57%)、对照组50例(42%)。
  • 撕裂扩大者94例;亚组179例中59例初末次X线片间隔至少3年,用于评估CSA变化。

主要发现

  • 共评估1552张X线片,仅326张(21%)质量足以测量CSA。
  • 撕裂组CSA高于对照组(34°±4° vs 32°±4°;平均差2.0°;95%CI 0.7°-3.2°;p=0.003)。
  • CSA与基线撕裂长度(ρ=0.22,p=0.090)或宽度(ρ=0.16,p=0.229)不相关。
  • 撕裂扩大组与稳定组CSA无差异(34°±3° vs 34°±4°;平均差0.2°;95%CI -0.9°至-1.4°;p=0.683)。
  • CSA不随时间变化(时间1均值33°±4°,时间2均值33°±4°;平均差-0.2°;95%CI -0.6°至0.1°;p=0.253)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 研究为回顾性设计。
  • 多数X线片质量不足以测量CSA。
  • 作者指出观察到的CSA差异小,可能受测量误差影响,临床意义可能不重要。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The critical shoulder angle (CSA) has been reported to be associated with rotator cuff disease and has been suggested as an etiology for cuff tears. However, it is unclear whether acromial morphologic characteristics such as CSA are a cause or effect because all studies to date have been retrospective. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How often can the CSA be reliably measured? (2) Is the CSA associated with rotator cuff disease? (3) Is the CSA correlated with baseline tear size or tear enlargement? (4) Does the CSA change with time? METHODS: In this retrospective comparison of longitudinally collected data, patients with asymptomatic rotator cuff tears underwent ultrasonography and standardized AP radiographs at enrollment and yearly thereafter during a median of 4 years. Three hundred ninety-five patients were included, of whom 14 were excluded as they were not yet eligible for 2-year followup and 68 (18%) were lost to followup, leaving 313 study patients who were evaluated with 1433 radiographs. Patients with adhesive capsulitis with normal rotator cuffs and radiographically normal scapulae were included as control subjects (119 subjects). Two observers (PNC, DS) measured the CSA in a blinded fashion. Radiographs that met Suter-Henninger criteria for CSA measurement reliability were included. For the study group, 179 of the 313 (57%) patients with radiographs that met Suter-Henninger criteria were further analyzed; the remainder were excluded from this study. For the control group, 50 of 119 (42%) subjects met criteria and were further analyzed. Tear enlargement was found in 94 patients, and the CSA was compared in patients with tears and control subjects, and in tears with or without enlargement, and was correlated with tear size. In a subgroup of the study group in which 59 of 179 patients had a minimum of 3 years between initial and followup radiographs, two CSA measurements were performed to measure change. RESULTS: In total, of the 1552 radiographs evaluated, only 326 (21%) were of sufficient quality to measure the CSA. The CSA was higher among patients with cuff tears than control subjects (34° ± 4° versus 32° ± 4°; mean difference, 2.0°; 95% CI, 0.7°-3.2°; p = 0.003). The CSA did not correlate with baseline tear length (ρ = 0.22, p = 0.090) or width (ρ = 0.16, p = 0.229). The CSA was not different between tears that enlarged and those that were stable (34° ± 3° versus 34° ± 4°; mean difference, 0.2°; 95% CI, -0.9° to -1.4°; p = 0.683). The CSA did not change over time (CSA Time 1: mean 33° ± 4° SD; CSA Time 2: mean 33° ± 4° SD; mean difference, -0.2°; 95% CI, -0.6° to 0.1°; p = 0.253). CONCLUSIONS: Even with a longitudinal protocol, most radiographs are of insufficient quality for CSA measurement. Although patients with a history of degenerative cuff disease have higher CSA values than control subjects, the difference is small enough that it could be influenced by measurement error in practice; in any case, a difference of the magnitude we observed is likely to be clinically unimportant. The CSA is not correlated with tear size or tear progression, and does not seem to change with time. These results suggest that the CSA is unlikely to be related to rotator cuff disease. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, prognostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chalmers PN, Salazar D, Steger-May K, et al. Does the Critical Shoulder Angle Correlate With Rotator Cuff Tear Progression? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017. PMID: 28120293. doi:10.1007/s11999-017-5249-1

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。